Our society has laws and I don't know where you live, but I'm a Brit and live in a democracy. The majority will get to decide. There will be ways round it - going to other countries, etc but as a society that's just how we do things. There are things that are more important (to some of us) than one person, or even a group of people, or even everyone living for ever and those things are worth protecting.
Your post does make an amusing (and very sci-fi) idea pop into my head though, that of fugitive, criminal immortals. The idea of an immortal hiding what they are isn't new - it's usually because they don't know how people will react, or they wouldn't be able to fit into society, or they might get experimented upon to find the secret. It seems at least a little novel to have a situation in which it is known that some people will live forever, and by the very nature of having taken on immortality they are necessarily fugitive.
I suppose it's not too dissimilar from some of Asimov's robot stuff.
Why should you get to say whether I can live forever? You don't want to, go ahead and die.
That came across as more confrontational than I intended. There will never be a credible strategy until the situation is faced, humanity does not seem to work the other way (with actual foresight).