Re:Garry Tan, the CEO of venture YC, accused me of unethical...
by tptacek on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @11:56AM
(#48195055)
There's a whole subthread that already covered this ground. The passage obviously implicates Lim --- the subject of the entire document --- a reporter, in lawbreaking, without alleging facts sufficient to establish that liability, and was written by the DA's office. When Trump's DOJ does this sort of thing, we all (rightly) freak the fuck out.
Re:Garry Tan, the CEO of venture YC, accused me of unethical...
by boroboro4 on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @07:57PM
(#48201279)
DOJ puts an accusation with clarifying text in semi private document? They don’t do this, they do much worse things (and get, rightly, much worse response).
This document isn’t great, but comparing it to Trump administration actions isn’t great either. As well as focusing on it rather than on a substance of the article in question (which is, about Garry Tan accusations in a first place).
Thank you for your comment though it made me go back and reread the linked text more critically.
Re:Garry Tan, the CEO of venture YC, accused me of unethical...
by jrflowers on Sunday May 24, 2026 @05:12AM
(#48255788)
> Thank you for your comment though it made me go back and reread the linked text more critically.
Yeah he was just making stuff up.
Re:Garry Tan, the CEO of venture YC, accused me of unethical...
by jrflowers on Sunday May 24, 2026 @04:57AM
(#48255713)
I like that I explained incontrovertibly that your statement was wrong here and your response is “somewhere else we established that he was a bad guy and that means the bad guy is trump”
lmao that nothing that you said is true at all in any way, and was trivial to disprove but you’re sticking to the vibes anyway 8-)
tptacek: “The DA for San Francisco and the DA for Chicago were the same guy and I know that because the SF guy is Trump because I did not read what he wrote and theres a thread about that“
Anyway, possibly poorly-worded title aside, it is made clear that Lim was receiving information from someone that clearly was violating HIPAA laws.
Here is the text:
It says that the victim’s HIPAA rights were violated in the process of that information being released, which appears to be objectively true. The second reference goes further to clarify:> This suggests Ms. Lim was received a patient’s privileged medical records from another unauthorized source in violation of HIPAA.
The only way to read that sentence as an accusation of Lim violating HIPAA would be to read it and conclude that she was both “an unauthorized source in violation of HIPAA” and also the reporter that the unauthorized source shared the information with (in violation of HIPAA, the law)
Calling the whole document “Trumpian” is kind of extreme when the criticism is “There’s an ambiguous phrase in it and I will not be addressing the clarifying language a couple sentences away from it” or “I think this lawyer meant ‘statutes’ when he wrote ‘rights’ which I imagine makes him wrong”