News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Actually, Democracy Dies in H.R. by rayiner on Monday May 18, 2026 @12:03PM (#48181614)
We don’t know what would have happened in a counterfactual scenario where the popular vote mattered in 2016. Campaigns spend their money trying to turn out voters to win the electoral college, because that’s what counts. That’s especially true of Republicans, because they have to schlep across a bunch of small towns to energize their voters, while Democrats can focus their get-out-the-vote effort on a couple of big cities in each state. When the margins are a couple of points in either direction, turnout makes a big difference.

In 2024, Trump made a deliberate play for the popular vote, holding rallies in California and New York City. And there was a major swing in his direction in both states. E.g. Biden won California by 29 points. Harris won California by only 20 points.

It came out later that the internal polling available to both campaigns had Trump ahead the entire time. So he likely felt comfortable taking a risk and spending time in California and New York. But you’ll notice that he parked his surrogates in places like Pennsylvania the entire time.

Re:Actually, Democracy Dies in H.R. by cdrnsf on Monday May 18, 2026 @12:34PM (#48182003)
I'm not as concerned with internal polling as I am with him attempting to undermine elections and his history of sexual assault.
Re:Actually, Democracy Dies in H.R. by Forgeties79 on Monday May 18, 2026 @01:17PM (#48182482)
> We don’t know what would have happened in a counterfactual scenario where the popular vote mattered in 2016

You can’t brag about his popular vote for one election then disregard it for another. He lost if by a lot more in 2016 than he won it by in 2024. Both elections were decided by the electoral college and the popular votes we are comparing both happened in that context. 2.7% margin vs. 0.5% is a stark difference.

Republicans had the stones to call his victory margin “a mandate” yet they would never say Hillary Clinton had one. You’re playing funny with numbers here.

Re:Actually, Democracy Dies in H.R. by rayiner on Monday May 18, 2026 @01:23PM (#48182570)
My post was responding to someone who expressed skepticism in U.S. elections. I wasn’t “bragging” about anything, I was pointing out that elections work. I mentioned the popular vote only to preempt a counterpoint from people who don’t like the EC.
Re:Actually, Democracy Dies in H.R. by Forgeties79 on Monday May 18, 2026 @01:38PM (#48182765)
Everyone understands the EC decides elections and you’re the only one talking about the popular vote. You explicitly stated that instead of the one that actually matters and is relevant in the other comment. And again, he barely won it.

Either way you can’t selectively use it in conversation and then dismiss it when others use it.