News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don't Outsource the Learning by amarant on Sunday May 17, 2026 @04:56PM (#48173120)
I dunno. People worry we give up vital skills doing this. I question if they'll be vital in the future? If the LLM can genuinely solve the bug today, why wouldn't it be able to tomorrow?

One thing that seems fairly certain is that llms aren't going to get any worse. They'll probably keep getting better, but there is 0% chance they'll get worse.

If you can get away with not fixing the bug yourself today, the very idea of doing it yourself will be laughable tomorrow.

I try to learn the skills that the LLMs struggle with. Some of those skills will be made irrelevant too, probably when Mythos gets released to the public. But also some of them won't. Probably. The skills that Claude has a handle on today? Waste of space in my brain!

Re:Don't Outsource the Learning by dominotw on Sunday May 17, 2026 @05:01PM (#48173159)
thinking is vital. just like homework at school to improve your thinking. final output can be totally ignored .

one could argue that thinking itself would be not needed in future. But we are not there. I would love that future though. thinking is suffering. if ai can think for us then it would eliminate suffering.

Re:Don't Outsource the Learning by yoyohello13 on Sunday May 17, 2026 @05:14PM (#48173255)
What are we without thinking? What’s the point of our existence in that case? Just being a biological bag of soup consuming resources?

In fact, thinking is what makes humans interesting. What separates us from random bacteria if we don’t think anymore?

Re:Don't Outsource the Learning by copperx on Sunday May 17, 2026 @05:53PM (#48173528)
Your questions only make sense if you assume there's a "point" to existence.
Re:Don't Outsource the Learning by yoyohello13 on Monday May 18, 2026 @04:19PM (#48184992)
I guess my point is if our future really is just Wall-E, sitting in hover chairs waiting for the bots to feed us our food slop while we watch TV I'd rather just die and get it over with TBH.
Re:Don't Outsource the Learning by dominotw on Sunday May 17, 2026 @06:07PM (#48173609)
its the Faustian bargain we have to make to eliminate suffering
Re:Don't Outsource the Learning by amarant on Sunday May 17, 2026 @06:24PM (#48173713)
But you can't successfully outsource all of "thinking" to a LLM today(or, likely, ever), so this is mostly a strawman.

Thinking isn't Boolean either. A LLM let's you not think about, say, rust lifetimes, as an example. You'll still need to think about other things.

I'm not abandoning all thinking, I just change what things I think about. Some things I delegate thinking about(like rust lifetime syntax, to stick with my example), which frees up time to think about other, more interesting things, like application design, or architecture!

Re:Don't Outsource the Learning by dominotw on Sunday May 17, 2026 @08:59PM (#48174597)
whats the basis for your claim that its impossible in future.
Re:Don't Outsource the Learning by r_lee on Sunday May 17, 2026 @05:50PM (#48173508)
I don't see how that would be a good future... how is thinking suffering?
Re:Don't Outsource the Learning by copperx on Sunday May 17, 2026 @06:03PM (#48173584)
'Suffering' is hyperbole. But one can't deny thinking is hard and painful. Otherwise we wouldn't have so many shortcuts for it.
Re:Don't Outsource the Learning by dominotw on Sunday May 17, 2026 @06:00PM (#48173567)
suffering comes from movement of thought. doesnt it?
Re:Don't Outsource the Learning by mhitza on Sunday May 17, 2026 @06:25PM (#48173724)
Something that only thinks of the things thought before isn't much of a tinker now is it?
Re:Don't Outsource the Learning by xscott on Sunday May 17, 2026 @07:45PM (#48174167)
I believe almost nobody thinks original thoughts. I never have. At best I applied an idea from one area to another, which is something AI can do.

Moreover, most novel advancements seem like they come when society is ready for them - the nearly simultaneous discovery of calculus for example.

Pick any thought of yours you truly believe is novel and do a serious literature search on the topic and adjacent fields. Ask an AI to help you with the search if necessary :-)

Re:Don't Outsource the Learning by mhitza on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @05:51AM (#48191308)
Interesting though experiment, if you train an LLM with all available knowledge (cut-off date) before the day Einstein published/first time discussed the relativity theory, would an LLM be able to come up with that?
Re:Don't Outsource the Learning by xscott on Tuesday May 19, 2026 @07:04AM (#48191763)
I think about that kind of thing a lot. For Special Relativity, maybe? I don't know the historical interactions between Einstein, Minkowski, and Lorentz, but my gut tells me the idea was ripe. For General Relativity, I'm less optimistic the current flavor of LLMs could make that leap.

There's so much I don't know though, and I'm certain we aren't the only two who think about it :-)

Re:Don't Outsource the Learning by dominotw on Thursday May 21, 2026 @11:30AM (#48224441)
what about the famous go game move that ai came up with. move that baffled experts.
Re:Don't Outsource the Learning by bkal01 on Sunday May 17, 2026 @06:52PM (#48173876)
> thinking is suffering

then thinking is also joy and happiness :)

Re:Don't Outsource the Learning by kernzistor45 on Monday May 18, 2026 @07:32AM (#48178187)
What does it feel like, to not be able to think? Is it conceivable? Oh, wait, I can't think when I can't so, I guess not.