News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Umano wants to tell you the news, literally by moocow01 on Wednesday November 21, 2012 @07:12PM (#4816974)
Im going to try to not be overly negative here... but arent there numerous other forms of media that already do this in a pretty crowded market? NPR, radio, podcasts, etc? I guess I dont really get why I would use this in that the audio forms of news that I have to choose from are pretty vast and high quality.
Re:Umano wants to tell you the news, literally by HorizonXP on Wednesday November 21, 2012 @07:21PM (#4816991)
The idea is that they're curating content from across the web, and reading actual articles to you. Podcasts and the like have a different style of delivery.

Think of this as text-to-speech for articles you would normally read, except done by an actual human so it doesn't sound off-putting.

I think it's a fantastic idea, but its success will be determined by the team's ability to scale across a wider gamut of content.

Re:Umano wants to tell you the news, literally by moocow01 on Wednesday November 21, 2012 @07:27PM (#4817007)
But isn't this essentially what the radio/podcast form of news essentially is?

Each station/organization curates information (in a similar way web-based reporters do) and then reports as much of it as their resources allow via someone reading/talking?

I'm not trying to beat up on their idea but I dont understand their competitive angle or what would cause me to use it over the huge amount of content out there.

Re:Umano wants to tell you the news, literally by HorizonXP on Wednesday November 21, 2012 @07:30PM (#4817021)
There are similarities, but there are differences too. Podcasts/radio will usually deliver the content more succinctly. Written articles tend to be more in-depth. Pros and cons to both.

Moreover, there is simply more written content than there are podcasts or radio. This can help bridge the gap.

Re:Umano wants to tell you the news, literally by jlees on Wednesday November 21, 2012 @11:52PM (#4817537)
I've never been a big fan of podcasts. Some have done a good job of mixing current topics with in-depth dives into specific areas and a dash of humour/personality (boagworld, for example), but most of the others I've tried out are either long rambles on very specialised topics or ego-stroking interviews. There's also production time delays/weekly (or longer) release cycles.

Radio news... I haven't really looked into this since moving to the US, but in the UK, no radio news channel covered technology well and it's difficult, given a finite amount of time, to use that time to listen to exactly what you want. e.g. tuning into the World Service here, I get some very random content which is sometimes interesting, sometimes not. Perhaps NPR is different.

I feel Umano addresses both of these - topic freshness/specialisation and good use of finite time - in different ways.

Re:Umano wants to tell you the news, literally by morsch on Thursday November 22, 2012 @11:46AM (#4819302)
I listen to a lot of news radio programs as podcasts. I love that I don't have fit my schedule around the program, and I love that I'm not tied to a specific program but can listen to the most interesting stuff from various stations. Including a few that aren't even in my country, such as This American Life.

I've also got a few things subscribed that are "genuine" podcasts. My observations mirror your own (a few good ones/almost all are terrible). But if it works, it works really well, I've had podcasts that went on about a topic for 3 hours without getting boring.

But almost none of the stuff I get this way deals with technology per se. It's mostly politics, science, sociology, history -- anything but pure tech.

Re:Umano wants to tell you the news, literally by pierrebouchet on Thursday November 22, 2012 @05:25AM (#4818249)
This reminds me of VoiceBunny. For short texts you can get a voiceover within minutes, and their API allows you to automate the whole process.

See API flowchart: http://voicebunny.com/developers/get_read