Re:'Millions' of pounds saved by replacing Palantir tech in ...
by PunchyHamster on Thursday May 14, 2026 @07:43PM
(#48142709)
Could probably be moderately complex excel sheet. Well, hopefully not but keeping that one guy that know how it works is still cheaper than Palantir!
Re:'Millions' of pounds saved by replacing Palantir tech in ...
by marysol5 on Friday May 15, 2026 @03:52AM
(#48145752)
They did that with the COVID19 tracker.
And ran out of rows
Re:'Millions' of pounds saved by replacing Palantir tech in ...
by shrikant on Friday May 15, 2026 @06:41AM
(#48146967)
The core data platform for NHS Test and Trace was not Excel based at all. It was a reasonably simple but solid AWS setup using S3, Glue and the smallest Redshift instance at the time, on top of which were Tableau/Quicksight/PowerBI dashboards. Some organisations insisted on enabling an "export to CSV" feature which was...not a good idea for so many reasons, and Public Health England (PHE) in the article found out one of those reasons the hard way.
Re:'Millions' of pounds saved by replacing Palantir tech in ...
by OliverGuy on Saturday May 16, 2026 @03:08AM
(#48157600)
Have you got a source for the s3/glue/redshift bit?
Re:'Millions' of pounds saved by replacing Palantir tech in ...
by shrikant on Saturday May 16, 2026 @06:14AM
(#48158758)
Page 68 of this PDF (https://covid19.public-inquiry.uk/wp-content/uploads/2025/05...), section G2 titled "Testing and Operations Data" has some high level information. I know the details because I designed and built the first version when I was at Deloitte, so I suppose it depends on how much you believe me...
Re:'Millions' of pounds saved by replacing Palantir tech in ...
by vkou on Thursday May 14, 2026 @07:41PM
(#48142698)
Hundreds of thousands of documents is small enough that you can feasibly run a pen and paper office handling them. Especially since most of them do not cross-reference eachother (family applications do, but unrelated families have no such links).
That America's brightest tech minds can't solve this problem is embarrassing. (Never mind the baggage of giving a foreign, potentially adversarial nation access to something as sensitive as residency and visa information.)
Re:'Millions' of pounds saved by replacing Palantir tech in ...
by jimbokun on Thursday May 14, 2026 @07:46PM
(#48142726)
This article is about the UK.
Re:'Millions' of pounds saved by replacing Palantir tech in ...
by MikeTheGreat on Thursday May 14, 2026 @07:50PM
(#48142761)
I assumed that when the GP said the UK was "giving a foreign, potentially adversarial nation access" the GP meant that the US is that "foreign, potentially adversarial nation"
I can't believe that in our timeline Europe has to think like this, but here we are.
Re:'Millions' of pounds saved by replacing Palantir tech in ...
by vkou on Thursday May 14, 2026 @07:48PM
(#48142749)
I'm well aware.
Note that Palantir is an American company that failed to solve this problem well, and introduces an adversarial risk to the UK.
Re:'Millions' of pounds saved by replacing Palantir tech in ...
by InsideOutSanta on Friday May 15, 2026 @04:21AM
(#48145953)
Yeah, this exactly. "multiple government systems", "tens of thousands", "hundreds of thousands" is the typical "part-time allocation for four people in an office" government project. This should have a budget in the low hundreds of thousands of £ at most.
Re:'Millions' of pounds saved by replacing Palantir tech in ...
by ekjhgkejhgk on Friday May 15, 2026 @08:19AM
(#48147697)
Exactly. And more importantly is the fact that when done inhouse the incentives are different than when done by a contractor. The latter has an incentive to keep the client dependent.
This is the kind of thing GDS and other Civil Service departments build all the time, its a completely standard kind of challenge that a small team of Devs (+ supporting staff) from a departments DDAT department does day in and day out.
The output will be open source by default and use existing standards.