News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by SoftTalker on Monday May 11, 2026 @12:45PM (#48097395)
> To some degree yes, in practice, not so much.

We used to say that (not long ago, even) about the code-writing part. Why do we believe that LLMs are going to stop there? Why do we think they won't soon be able to talk to people, listen, and determine what they need? I think it's mostly a cope.

We have robots walking just fine now, by the way.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by sarchertech on Monday May 11, 2026 @01:07PM (#48097669)
If they can do those things they can effectively replace any white collar job. That’s about 45% of the workforce. Societies tend to collapse around 25-30% unemployment.

Imagine 45% of higher than average paying jobs gone.

If that happens we’ll either figure out a new economic system, or society will collapse.

Also saying robots are walking just fine is misleading for any definition of just fine that is anywhere near as good as a human.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by ryandrake on Monday May 11, 2026 @01:24PM (#48097891)
Look at how the billionaires are talking about AI: Their clear, unambiguous goal is basically to replace all white collar "knowledge" jobs. And there's currently nothing regulatory that's stopping them--they just need to wait for the state of the art to improve. Once AI is "good enough" if it ever is, they won't even think twice about 45% unemployment. What are we unemployed workers going to do about it? There's no effective labor organization left. Workers have basically no political power or seat at the table. We're not going to get violent--the police/military are already owned by the billionaire class. We're just going to eventually become economically irrelevant and die off.
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by geodel on Monday May 11, 2026 @01:49PM (#48098215)
> We're just going to eventually become economically irrelevant and die off.

As harsh it may sound, it seems rather likely to me. It is not like s/w engineers have helped struggling workers in other sectors other than sanctimonious "Learn to code" advice. So software folks can't expect any solidarity or help from others.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by kiba on Monday May 11, 2026 @01:51PM (#48098237)
The fundamental issue isn't unemployment due to automation, but the fact that society cannot benefit from unemployment.

It should be something for us to celebrate, because it means greater freedom for humans to pursue something else rather than spending time doing drudgery.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by shinryuu on Monday May 11, 2026 @02:27PM (#48098748)
Put it another way, the issue is that resources are not shared more equitably. This is especially egregious considering that LLMs are trained on all human knowledge. We've all been contributing to this enterprise, and what we may end up getting in return is unemployment.
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by monknomo on Monday May 11, 2026 @01:47PM (#48098181)
45% of folks sitting on their hands are going to have the free time to talk, and this group of people are skilled at organization. Are you planning on throwing your hands up and passively accepting whatever comes your way?
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by rootusrootus on Monday May 11, 2026 @02:44PM (#48099010)
And at least in the US they have >45% of all the small arms weaponry. There is no bunker strong enough nor private army big enough if 100M people come for you.
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by ryandrake on Monday May 11, 2026 @03:01PM (#48099227)
They're probably be betting that the technology they will need to defend their bunkers, think autonomous kill-bots or whatever, will emerge before people start to riot.

Or they're planning to build an Elysium-like colony in the ocean or space, to keep the billionaire class far from danger.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by rootusrootus on Monday May 11, 2026 @02:41PM (#48098951)
I get that it is popular to hate billionaires these days, but realistically, they did not get to be billionaires by being stupid. It runs directly counter to their own interests to induce anything like 45% unemployment. They will get poorer, the world they live in right along with the rest of us will get noticeably shittier, etc.

More likely they figure out what to do with a bunch of idle talent. Or the coming generation of trillionaires will.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by layla5alive on Tuesday May 12, 2026 @08:45PM (#48116518)
"Poorer?" That implies they still rely on money. But money is just a form of fiat power. The billionaires/trillionaires will not much need fiat currency or fiat power, because they're building real power.. by extension, they won't really need to worry very much about the rest of us, either..
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by BurningFrog on Monday May 11, 2026 @01:47PM (#48098180)
It's important (and calming) to understand that since the Industrial Revolution started ~250 years ago, we've automated away most jobs several times over, while employment levels have stayed pretty constant.

"Automating half the jobs" is the same as "double productivity per worker".

When the doubling happens in 5 years rather than 50, it might be more disruptive, but I'm convinced we're on the verge of huge improvements in human standard of living!

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by wartywhoa23 on Monday May 11, 2026 @02:10PM (#48098503)
What in the current state of world affairs outside of IT do you think is indicative of that potential for huge improvements in human standard of living?
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by BurningFrog on Monday May 11, 2026 @03:54PM (#48099835)
It's what I mentioned:

If we double productivity per worker, we have twice as much wealth on average.

I know there are angry people convinced that this will all be consumed by billionaires and jews, but historically that is not at all the track record of the last 250 years, and I expect that to continue.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by jplusequalt on Monday May 11, 2026 @07:28PM (#48102154)
>If we double productivity per worker, we have twice as much wealth on average.

That's not true. There are other factors at play such as demand.

If we make the average IT worker twice as productive, that doesn't mean now every IT worker is being paid twice as much, because most users aren't going to care if there are twice as many options on the app store, or twice as many bug fixes per release.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by BurningFrog on Tuesday May 12, 2026 @11:59AM (#48110132)
Consumption in a society will always be roughly equal to production.

There are differences due to import/export balance, investments, government borrowing etc, but as a first approximation, if GDP increases by 10%, consumption will rise by a similar amount.

About your IT worker example: Let's say s/he produces $150k/year in value and is paid $140k. If AI makes them produce $300k of value, they may not automatically get a raise. But it becomes very attractive for another employer to hire them for $200k or $250k, or even $280k.

In the medium/long term, I don't see why wages would keep proportional to produced value.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by timacles on Tuesday May 12, 2026 @10:03AM (#48108475)
If you are going to bring up history you should really look into what it took to redistribute wealth from oligarchs in the past.

The fact that oligarchy now has more resources than ever in the history of humankind, a means to mass surveillance and generating mass propaganda, those wealth redistributions are looking much MUCH harder to accomplish.

Yea, historically it will inevitably happen. Realistically it will be after the new version of fuedalism and dark ages. So strap in for the next 400 years aren’t looking too good

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by bborud on Monday May 11, 2026 @01:02PM (#48097602)
We never noticed how easy the code writing part had already become because it happened slowly. Through mechanical means, through the ability to re-use code, and through code generation.

Heck, even long before LLMs about 10% to 30% of my code was already automatically generated. By tooling, by IDLs and by my editor just being able to infer what my most likely input would be.

> We have robots walking just fine now, by the way.

I don't think you got the point I was trying to make.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by SoftTalker on Monday May 11, 2026 @01:13PM (#48097743)
True, but I guess I see a distinction between scaffolded/templated boilerplate or autocomplete and actual application logic. People have generated boilerplate from templates for ages, as you say. RoR maybe a pretty good example, but there wasn't even early-days AI involved in doing that.
Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by phkahler on Monday May 11, 2026 @01:15PM (#48097763)
>> We used to say that (not long ago, even) about the code-writing part. Why do we believe that LLMs are going to stop there? Why do we think they won't soon be able to talk to people, listen, and determine what they need?

Because they are currently "generative AI" meaning... autocomplete. They generate stuff but fall down at thinking and problem solving. There is talk of "reasoning models" but I think that's just clever meta-programming with LLMs. I can't say AI won't take that next step, but I think it will take another breakthrough on the order of transformers or attention. Companies are currently too busy exploiting the local maxima of LLMs.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by rootusrootus on Monday May 11, 2026 @02:46PM (#48099032)
> Companies are currently too busy exploiting the local maxima of LLMs

I get the feeling we can already spot the next AI Winter. Which is okay, we need a breather, and the current technology is useful enough on its own.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by terseus on Monday May 11, 2026 @01:00PM (#48097582)
> Why do we believe that LLMs are going to stop there?

Why do you believe they wont? I think it's reasonable to assume that we will hit a ceiling that current models will not be able to break.

> We have robots walking just fine now, by the way.

Walking and reasoning are unrelated abilities.

Re:Software engineering may no longer be a lifetime career by SoftTalker on Monday May 11, 2026 @01:07PM (#48097663)
Walking was given as an example of "hard to program a robot to do it" by GP. Well, now we have robots that can walk.

What evidence is there that LLMs have hit a ceiling at being able to do things like talk to users or stakeholders to elicit requirements? Using LLMs to help with design and architecture decisions is already a pretty common example that people give.