Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines
by Confusion on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @07:35AM
(#4808705)
I upvoted you and your parent. His assertion triggered your informative response, which I'd have had to do without otherwise. He wasn't annoying, just wrong, which is entirely acceptable as long as we are civil about it.
Re:Low-cost Solution to Clearing Afghan Landmines
by wtvanhest on Tuesday November 20, 2012 @09:06AM
(#4809026)
While you are probably right about this mine clearing tool, there have been previous examples that show the military’s requirements for particular items are much higher than civilian requirements in times of relative peace. Obviously when there is a world war, requirements go down dramatically to get things done, but when making purchase decisions in time of peace it seems that requirements are very high. Items like devices/vehicles etc. get very expensive and complex.
[Added] I’m talking from a US perspective, but it seems plausible that most developed country militaries spend on technology when in time of peace.
If you manage to clear a field such that there is a single mine in it, it will likely become safer to march through than avoid - there are plenty of other things that can kill you, and they must be triaged in war time.
However, if you take that same field after the war is over and put a farmer on it, it's basically a matter of time until he steps on it. His only chance is that an animal blows it up, or the mine is defective.
Therefore, if it's not suitable for military clearing, it is even less suitable for civilian purposes (except for figuring out what needs to be cleared, as they say).