Reproducibility adds nothing here
Say you're making a chat app - you wouldn't incorporate a delete feature, and you might be tempted to use some kind of blockchain to prove all messages were delivered without gaps. But if you ignore archival needs you design something similar to IRC which is much simpler.
Not that you are wrong, industry keeps thinking they can make themselves immune and so long term reproducibility is useful, but I submit they are wrong.
Literally none of your statements are applicable to that realm, sorry.
Rail operators have long since been operating their air-gapped infrastructure with 99.999% safety results, literally not adhering to any of the policies you claim are endemic to the industry.
Toolchains absolutely need to be maintained with some degree of longevity.
The whole world doesn’t march to your consumer-user beat. Sometimes it functions at industrial-user tempo’s, too ..
Why not? Debian has a fantastic track record of providing old versions, for instance here's the build tools from Debian 2.0 from 1998:
https://mirrors.accretive-networks.net/debian-archive/debian...
Just baking in build ID and commit is enough. What you think reproducible builds add ?
> Please don’t make bold claims about ‘no reason and little benefit’ while demonstrating ignorance of this hard fact: reproducible builds should have been the norm, in computing, from the get-go.
So far not a single person in the thread gave me concrete example (as in existing project, existing problem, no other solution can solve it). Just claiming it's better based on their feelings. Come on, be the first one.
Think industrial applications, such as rail and heavy industry transportation. We use reproducible builds here as part of a wider safety-critical protocol which guarantees that what we are running is what we expect to run - nothing more, nothing less.
Reproducible builds are certifiable. They can be relied on in environments where certification costs millions and takes years.
Think outside your consumer box for a minute.
Anyone having to maintain a code base or a distributed fleet of devices will gain from this decision, immensely, as their operational periods come and go.
Reproducible builds are about longevity as much as they are about security.
Please don’t make bold claims about ‘no reason and little benefit’ while demonstrating ignorance of this hard fact: reproducible builds should have been the norm, in computing, from the get-go.