Re:I’ve banned query strings
by altairprime on Saturday May 09, 2026 @08:14PM
(#48079651)
[delayed]
[ Parent
| on HN ]
actually, instead of the object hash, you could also use the commit-hash. then the filename would be mandatory, but the url would be more readable and usable: give me the file VERBS.md as it is at commit <hash>
That's actually what it is here, a7e17290a39250092055fcda5ae7015868dabdb4 is a commit's oid: https://github.com/gritzko/beagle/commit/a7e17290a3925009205...
yes, you are right. and it makes a lot more sense that way. see my other comment on the difference between commit blob and raw.
But the path misses param names (or types?). E.g who said the hex-encoded part is a commit hash? Maybe it's a tree hash, or just weird ref.
Query strings are more verbose as force to give each param a name.
Re:I’ve banned query strings
by altairprime on Saturday May 09, 2026 @11:39PM
(#48080789)
Which target audience of github needs extra verbosity in the commit hash, though? Once you know it you know it; if you don’t know git you aren’t the target audience; etc. Saying /user=foo is no better than ?user=foo if your audience can work it out without confusion from your unadorned paths. We have a great deal of history with filesystems showing that people are capable of keeping up with paths that lack key names if exposed to and familiar with them, and if the filesystem isn’t being constantly randomized.