IMO the only advantage of working from home is that you can control all those free variables that make you distracted: E.g. Get a quiet study where you tell your wife, cat(s) etc that you cannot/will not be distracted during work hours. Doing that at work can be tried but depending on the work place, may not be kosher.
I personally prefer working in the library. I have been most productive doing that back in school and sorely miss it.
Well, sojacques already addressed the cat point, so they only thing I have to add is that I live in Manhattan, in a very spacious place by our standards, but one that doesn't really come with a study - not unless I wanted to tear down everything in the closet, toss my wife's things into a box, and have a space the size of a desk to work in :P
I can filter out 50% of the noise at work, because it probably doesn't apply to me.
I can filter out 10% of the noise at home, because if my wife is talking or our cats are meowing, it's almost certainly directed at me.