Yep, I'm more or less speaking from the viewpoint of the time. The received wisdom was that it was IBM's deliberate decision to allow clones that made the difference; nowadays we can see that this was only part of the story, but that original belief coloured how people saw things.
On the other hand, though, perhaps the decision to use off-the-shelf parts was also part of the wider clone-friendly decision process. So it's not an either/or, even in hindsight.
IBM didn't want clones, it created the PS/2 to make a PC that couldn't be reverse engineered and cloned by the competition, but even then it was too late.
If IBM could they would have banned all clones, but as I said before OEMs weren't infringing any patents so they couldn't be sued nor stopped.
It didn't, the team behind Project Chess used off-the-shelf parts to cut down on costs and dev times so the end product was also easier to reverse engineer.
A company did just that and made a BIOS that didn't infringe on IBM patents. Couple that with an Intel processor and a DOS copy you could buy fair and square from Microsoft and you got a Clone just as good as an official IBM PC.
On Mac clones, it wasn't a bad idea, just too little too late: by the time Apple decided to go ahead with OEMs the Mac's marketshare was a shadow of its former self and Apple was already in trouble. Windows had become the standard, nuff said.