Re:Ingress proves once again: Google gets its users
by munificent on Saturday November 17, 2012 @06:54PM
(#4799363)
Whenever people think about Google doing stuff like this, they often get freaked out. Like, "OMG Google is using me for its own benefit!"
Well, yes, that may be true. But the important thing to keep in mind is that you aren't losing anything here. Yes, Google may be using your GPS data to improve its maps. But that doesn't mean you are having any less fun playing the game because of it.
This is, I think, one of the things that's deeply fundamental to Google's culture and really great about the company: Google is always looking for non-zero sum solutions. Where many companies think, "What's the most I can take from my customers to make us money?" Google thinks, "How can we maximize the sum of both us and our users?"
Look at ads, for example. Where many sites are constantly playing, "what's the most ads I can cram into my site before people start leaving?", Google is thinking "how can we make the ads as relevant as possible so that users actually want them to be there?"
Re:Ingress proves once again: Google gets its users
by MrDubious on Saturday November 17, 2012 @07:20PM
(#4799410)
I used to be a rather paranoid "Big Brother" fearing type, but Google wins me over again and again with not only a user focus that attempts to win us over by being better than the alternatives in meaningful ways, but also by having a greater understanding of what we actually want.
It's kind of embarrassing how much of a fanboy I sound like these days, but I've just been endlessly impressed with their innovation.
As a side note, it was really awesome seeing something I wrote posted on HN. I feel like a real boy now.
Re:Ingress proves once again: Google gets its users
by ChuckMcM on Saturday November 17, 2012 @11:33PM
(#4799843)
When I worked there I was a bit surprised to learn that nearly the entire justification for their GOOG-411 service (a free directory service they have since shut down) was to develop tools for speech recognition. The context was constrained enough that you could 'guess' a lot and get a good result for the user but mostly they were interested comparing the way different people said different things to get access to pretty much every accent you could imagine. It was remarkably successful.
That they would use 'Ingress' to update Map information is right up there in terms of cleverness. You get to play an engaging game, they get (in the large) lots of valuable data about where things are exactly, and to some extent how their gear reports things relative to where they really are. So if you can recognize that this particular street has crappy GPS you can fill in by translating what you're seeing from the AGPRS chip and make it seem like it is right on the money.
Re:Ingress proves once again: Google gets its users
by TimJRobinson on Saturday November 17, 2012 @09:44PM
(#4799663)
It comes back to the ultimatum game http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultimatum_game). Most people don't like others getting a better deal than themselves and will even choose to get nothing instead of something just so the other person also loses.
Re:Ingress proves once again: Google gets its users
by jkn on Sunday November 18, 2012 @05:45AM
(#4800366)
I had a similar thought after they released Google Now. Microsoft, Google, Apple, etc. all collect user data, but Google stands out in how hard they try to bring value to the user from all the data they have.
Re:Ingress proves once again: Google gets its users
by kenjackson on Saturday November 17, 2012 @11:53PM
(#4799880)
Google+ answered the question of how to get social signaling relevance in search values.
Really? First this answer has been known since the MySpace days at least -- and quite likely before then. Remember Google bought Orkut?
Google+ was more of a reaction against Facebook than some holistic answer to some problem that no one else could forsee. It was more like, "Google late to the game with a competitor that no one wants to use".
Re:Ingress proves once again: Google gets its users
by adiM on Saturday November 17, 2012 @10:27PM
(#4799729)
> first with the advent of email “conversation” threads
Google did not invent email conversations. Most email clients worth their salt could sort email based on thread since at least 1999/2000 (and also before that I only started using computers around that time).
Re:Ingress proves once again: Google gets its users
by thrownaway2424 on Saturday November 17, 2012 @10:43PM
(#4799757)
The way Gmail groups and sorts conversations is not the same as the way a threaded email client does or did it. Here's a random example of the way almost all three-pane, graphical, threaded MUAs looked for years: http://img.brothersoft.com/screenshots/softimage/c/claws_mai...
Gmail did it differently and was considered innovative. Some people who had always used threaded readers hated and still hate it. Other people like it better, or never used the old way.
Re:Ingress proves once again: Google gets its users
by MrDubious on Saturday November 17, 2012 @10:29PM
(#4799734)
Perhaps, but none of the other webmail clients had that, and Outlook didn't. While it may have been an available feature, it certainly wasn't in any way widespread.
Re:Ingress proves once again: Google gets its users
by muoncf on Saturday November 17, 2012 @09:01PM
(#4799595)
At the risk of incurring massive downvotes: if anyone happens to have a key for the game laying around, I would be very interested in getting one. I'm sitting on the edge of my chair, waiting for this game to go public. :D
Re:Ingress proves once again: Google gets its users
by beering on Saturday November 17, 2012 @11:11PM
(#4799808)
No mention of local advertising? Google feels like it's behind on the whole "local" business compared to rivals like Yelp, and this would be one way to get people to use a location-aware Google app.
Re:Ingress proves once again: Google gets its users
by MrDubious on Saturday November 17, 2012 @11:16PM
(#4799822)
Really? I'd really consider Google Local to be a superior product to Yelp, and with the acquisition of Zagat, they've got all the street cred they need. Why do you think Yelp is still a concern?
Re:Ingress proves once again: Google gets its users
by TeMPOraL on Sunday November 18, 2012 @07:38AM
(#4800473)
When I started playing I saw that Resistance had more global control. I just checked, they still have (55% R to 45% E).
Anyway, in my case, the decision had several reasons. As far as the narrative goes I sided with Resistance, but thougth to myself: hell, it's time for a change. There was also a little bit of "transhumanists vs. bioconservatives" orangecat mentioned, and then maybe a little bit of: a) I got an invitation from a Resistance guy so I thougth going to the other team will be more fun, and b) I have small negative feelings toward Ada (because of the overblown popularity of A. Lovelace) and small positive feelings for Jarvis (AI from Iron Man movies!) :).
Re:Ingress proves once again: Google gets its users
by orangecat on Saturday November 17, 2012 @10:24PM
(#4799721)
As somebody at my office put it: "Transhumanists versus bioconservatives...you have to ask?" But yeah, it would be nice to have some more resistance targets around.
Re:Ingress proves once again: Google gets its users
by 2muchcoffeeman on Saturday November 17, 2012 @11:59PM
(#4799892)
Not in Australia :( It also says its not compatible with the Nexus S. But considering what I went through it work this out, I think it's just not in Australia yet.
Well, yes, that may be true. But the important thing to keep in mind is that you aren't losing anything here. Yes, Google may be using your GPS data to improve its maps. But that doesn't mean you are having any less fun playing the game because of it.
This is, I think, one of the things that's deeply fundamental to Google's culture and really great about the company: Google is always looking for non-zero sum solutions. Where many companies think, "What's the most I can take from my customers to make us money?" Google thinks, "How can we maximize the sum of both us and our users?"
Look at ads, for example. Where many sites are constantly playing, "what's the most ads I can cram into my site before people start leaving?", Google is thinking "how can we make the ads as relevant as possible so that users actually want them to be there?"
It's kind of embarrassing how much of a fanboy I sound like these days, but I've just been endlessly impressed with their innovation.
As a side note, it was really awesome seeing something I wrote posted on HN. I feel like a real boy now.
That they would use 'Ingress' to update Map information is right up there in terms of cleverness. You get to play an engaging game, they get (in the large) lots of valuable data about where things are exactly, and to some extent how their gear reports things relative to where they really are. So if you can recognize that this particular street has crappy GPS you can fill in by translating what you're seeing from the AGPRS chip and make it seem like it is right on the money.
Well played Google, well played.
Really? First this answer has been known since the MySpace days at least -- and quite likely before then. Remember Google bought Orkut?
Google+ was more of a reaction against Facebook than some holistic answer to some problem that no one else could forsee. It was more like, "Google late to the game with a competitor that no one wants to use".
You can call it a reaction to Facebook, etc all you want but that doesn't disprove the author's statement.
Social signaling was never included in search results until Google+ came along.
Personally, I love seeing items in my search results that people in my Circles have shared on Twitter or Google+.
Google did not invent email conversations. Most email clients worth their salt could sort email based on thread since at least 1999/2000 (and also before that I only started using computers around that time).
Gmail did it differently and was considered innovative. Some people who had always used threaded readers hated and still hate it. Other people like it better, or never used the old way.
There's an invite thread there, and secret item codes. Also, +google on a request on G+.
Anyway, in my case, the decision had several reasons. As far as the narrative goes I sided with Resistance, but thougth to myself: hell, it's time for a change. There was also a little bit of "transhumanists vs. bioconservatives" orangecat mentioned, and then maybe a little bit of: a) I got an invitation from a Resistance guy so I thougth going to the other team will be more fun, and b) I have small negative feelings toward Ada (because of the overblown popularity of A. Lovelace) and small positive feelings for Jarvis (AI from Iron Man movies!) :).
https://plus.google.com/109471940039062886080/posts/5ZBXzZmh...