News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple patents the page turn by nsxwolf on Friday November 16, 2012 @05:19PM (#4796174)
I get that it's a skeuomorph, and that skeuomorphs are the cool thing to hate now, but what's ugly about it? I think it is very beautiful and elegantly done.

Are books ugly?

Re:Apple patents the page turn by warfangle on Friday November 16, 2012 @08:46PM (#4796797)
Real books are not ugly. But they are more than text on a dead tree. Books age; books gather a patina of use. As the glue and the paper and the binding and the spine age together, the smell of them changes. Real, physical, well-made books are pieces of art onto themselves -- something we've lost in reading these things on a flat, lifeless screen.

Digital books can be more than simply text on a screen as well; I noticed in a recent Amazon title that passages which were frequently highlighted by other users were set differently (I think it was a highlight as well; I can't remember the title I saw it in). Never mind the privacy concerns; it's the morphing of a medium.

On the other hand, applying the skeuomorphs of such a thing cheapens it. It's a mask, trying to hide its nature. For me, it's almost an uncanny valley feel. And I think the best design is that which unleashes full intuitiveness: if I had never seen a book, why would I expect this animation to be there when reading an e-book? It's superfluous to the nature of the media.

Even the page turning itself is superfluous to the media. Its purpose is to add pauses to the interaction. You lose part of that experience when there is no longer a physical page.

Re:Apple patents the page turn by GuiA on Friday November 16, 2012 @05:25PM (#4796194)
Why do we need a metaphor for a physical page on a digital device?
Re:Apple patents the page turn by kennywinker on Friday November 16, 2012 @06:22PM (#4796389)
It helps alert the user to how the data they are being shown is changing.

There are lots of non-skeuomorphic animations that could serve this purpose... cross-dissolves, flashes, slide-ins, etc. This just happens to be a reasonably nice one, that fits with the "this-is-a-book" metaphor of iBooks.

Even the name of iBooks is "skeuomorphic". It would be more accurately called "iMedium-to-long-static-documents-available-for-purchase" but that's a fucking awful title. Everybody has an idea of what a book is, so calling it iBooks means users know that there are book-ish-things contained within.

An app called iBooks where the next page trickled down like the title sequence from The Matrix would be tacky as hell and users would ask themselves why their "book thing" was doing this non-book thing.

Re:Apple patents the page turn by nilsbunger on Friday November 16, 2012 @06:41PM (#4796449)
+1 for "iMedium-to-long-static-documents-available-for-purchase" !
Re:Apple patents the page turn by graeme on Friday November 16, 2012 @05:57PM (#4796308)
We don't need one. But they can look nice. Corinthian columns are based on wooden palm tree supports from ancient egypt. They're obviously not necessary now, but they're pretty.
Re:Apple patents the page turn by harryh on Friday November 16, 2012 @10:10PM (#4797017)
They really aren't. That's kind of the point.
Re:Apple patents the page turn by graeme on Saturday November 17, 2012 @12:25AM (#4797314)
Aren't necessary or aren't pretty? They're too very different questions.