News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I built "Middle Class Museum", a tour of things that used... by MarkusQ on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @10:33AM (#47935216)
Not adjusting for inflation and quality really damages the integrity of the comparisons, as does cherry picking your base examples.

Taking your first, the $47K 3 bedroom starter home with a yard. In 2026 that would be $200K (cumulative inflation is a little over 4x[1]); picking a random US city[2] and looking on Zillow[3] I find that...yeah, you can get a comparable home today.

There are certainly arguments to be made about tradeoffs, quality issues (though those aren't as obvious as you might initially suppose[4]) and so on. But just listing unadjusted price comparisons like this is disingenuous.

[1] https://www.in2013dollars.com/us/inflation/1980?amount=1 [2] https://www.randomlists.com/random-us-cities [3] https://www.zillow.com [4] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I4C62HC1HSo

Re:I built "Middle Class Museum", a tour of things that used... by psadauskas on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @11:07AM (#47935685)
Just "adjusting for inflation" isn't good enough. Minimum wage was $4/hr. Now its $8. An elementary school custodian could afford a mortgage, a car, support a family of 4 and go on vacation on just that single income. They had healthcare and a pension. You could work over the summer and pay for a year of college at a state school.

Yes, the house now is more energy efficient. The car is safer. But if the price of everything went up 4x-10x, and the median income only went up 2x, AND you have to pay for more things that used to be included, then everything is more unaffordable, inflation be damned.

Re:I built "Middle Class Museum", a tour of things that used... by maldusiecle on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @11:50AM (#47936172)
In 1979, 13% of US hourly workers were making the federal minimum wage. By 2025, that number had dropped to 1%.

Inflation-adjusted wages have been at worst stagnant. Inflation-adjusting prices is necessary for these comparisons to be meaningful at all.

This is a website for engineers, you should be embarrassed to be posting these completely innumerate comments.

Re:I built "Middle Class Museum", a tour of things that used... by neaden on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @11:31AM (#47935957)
"An elementary school custodian could afford a mortgage, a car, support a family of 4 and go on vacation on just that single income. " Can I ask what you are basing this off of? I'm fairly skeptical of this claim.
Re:I built "Middle Class Museum", a tour of things that used... by psadauskas on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @06:48PM (#47941894)
The head custodian at my elementary school (in the 80s) was a friendly guy that loved talking with the kids. He'd talk about his life, ask us if we did anything fun over the summer, and tell us where he went with his wife and kids. The school was in a small town in the rural midwest, not particularly affluent, but not poor either.

The elementary school where my kids went (in a much more wealthy district) doesn't even have a custodian that I'm aware of, just a 3rd-party cleaning service that hires immigrants for as cheap as possible, and I'm sure doesn't offer healthcare or even full-time work. They have too many highly-paid administrators to afford a custodian.

Re:I built "Middle Class Museum", a tour of things that used... by neaden on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @08:19PM (#47942645)
Ok so you're moving the goalposts here. What you said was a custodian (who I'm assuming did a lot more than just clean) and now you've switched to a head custodian and are comparing him to contract workers. So you're comparing two different jobs in two different school districts. Now is it possible that they've eliminated or reduced those positions? Sure, but you haven't actually shown that at all. Like I could easily counter with the fact that the school my wife teaches at still has a head custodian but I don't know what his family situation is and we'd just be trading anecdotes. So do you have any actual evidence for your initial claim? Because the overall stats with wages and prices are the opposite from what you claim.
Re:I built "Middle Class Museum", a tour of things that used... by briffle on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @10:52AM (#47935467)
> Not adjusting for inflation and quality really damages the integrity of the comparisons, as does cherry picking your base examples.

But then they also need to make sure to also match salaries to inflation too.. Because wages have not kept up with inflation, which is the reason for most of this..

Re:I built "Middle Class Museum", a tour of things that used... by MarkusQ on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @11:00AM (#47935584)
> wages have not kept up with inflation

This is not true.

https://econofact.org/factbrief/fact-check-have-inflation-ad...

Re:I built "Middle Class Museum", a tour of things that used... by syel on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @10:40AM (#47935301)
Thanks for the feedback. The whole experience/site is mainly satirical/humorous. It's not inflation adjusted cause I didn't want it turn into a finance piece tbh, but you're definitely right, if inflation adjusted most cards need to be re-built to account for inflation and better judge what we're getting today vs what we used to get
Re:I built "Middle Class Museum", a tour of things that used... by pjc50 on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @10:43AM (#47935334)
It's about money! How is it not a finance piece?
Re:I built "Middle Class Museum", a tour of things that used... by xattt on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @10:57AM (#47935532)
“JUST A PRANK, BROS‼”
Re:I built "Middle Class Museum", a tour of things that used... by syel on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @11:23AM (#47935872)
I like to call it satire actually
Re:I built "Middle Class Museum", a tour of things that used... by neaden on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @11:31AM (#47935962)
So you're making fun of people who think the past was more affordable?
Re:I built "Middle Class Museum", a tour of things that used... by wang_li on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @12:08PM (#47936377)
He has a belief that is mainly supportable only if he cherry picks specific examples that don't contradict his belief system.
Re:I built "Middle Class Museum", a tour of things that used... by syel on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @11:34AM (#47935989)
no, cause I personally think the past was more affordable
Re:I built "Middle Class Museum", a tour of things that used... by neaden on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @11:56AM (#47936246)
I don't get the satire then.
Re:I built "Middle Class Museum", a tour of things that used... by pjc50 on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @10:42AM (#47935333)
Not adjusting for inflation makes it look completely stupid.

There's one good effort - comparing a car to the salary of a car-worker. But it only has half the comparison (what are today's car workers earning?). That's the comparison that Marx would recognize: how long do the people making something have to work to buy the thing they made?

Re:I built "Middle Class Museum", a tour of things that used... by alex43578 on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @10:57AM (#47935539)
Is the implicit expectation that people making something should have some correlation with their ability to buy that thing?

The assembly-worker making a Civic and a 7 Series BMW are doing effectively the same thing, but the BMW assembler shouldn’t be getting paid 3 to 4x.

Re:I built "Middle Class Museum", a tour of things that used... by MarkusQ on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @11:05AM (#47935670)
The reference to Marx and (implicitly) the labor theory of value renders the GP unserious. Just looking at the people doing the assembly (and not all the people in the supply chain), ignoring the time aspect (I doubt there's any product that costs more than one of the people assembling it would expect to make over the time it would take them to single-handedly create the product from scratch), and so on.

It's a nonsensical position, meant to invoke a certain sort of feels, and nothing more.

Re:I built "Middle Class Museum", a tour of things that used... by ben_w on Wednesday April 29, 2026 @02:27AM (#47944806)
> It's a nonsensical position, meant to invoke a certain sort of feels, and nothing more.

It may be so, but those feelings are part of the disconnect and they themselves cause all sorts of problems - or benefits, if directed appropriately, e.g. the IKEA effect is part of the same thing: we put in effort so we think the result is worth that effort.

Marx being wrong doesn't mean trade unions didn't rise for much of the 20th century on the basis of similar feelings, being in error didn't stop the USSR being one of the world's two superpowers for about half a century.

If the employees are satisfied their labours will bear fruits then they historically have not minded much that billionaires skim the cream; but when they are not satisfied, revolutions come. Those are messy and unpleasant, but they come anyway.

Re:I built "Middle Class Museum", a tour of things that used... by MarkusQ on Wednesday April 29, 2026 @10:05AM (#47948663)
Sure. Lying to people and telling them they're somehow oppressed just because other people are more successful than they are can be used to stir up a revolution and get a lot of the useful idiots killed.

That's why it's important to call the nonsense out.

Re:I built "Middle Class Museum", a tour of things that used... by ben_w on Wednesday April 29, 2026 @10:47AM (#47949194)
When someone's making billions and the goods and services they get you to pay are functionally mandatory even if theoretically avoidable, with costs going up because someone somewhere has apparently cornered the market, is it even a lie?

People asking "Why can't I afford a car from 9 months salary when my dad could? Why is a house 10x my salary not 3x like my dad's? Why can't my partner and I afford kids even on two incomes when our parents managed it on one?" don't want a series of ten hour-long degree-level lectures on economic theory to be able to understand the real answer, especially not when there's clearly a bunch of very rich people who keep loudly telling them that they ought to be happy because some stock index has gone up (when they don't own stocks) or that they've moved up the value chain (which if true doesn't answer why cars and houses are less affordable).

Give them an answer about Baumol's cost disease (easy to understand without much economics study), and suddenly you're back to Marxism but with different language, where Marx's "means of production" happen to be inalienable to the human form (or at least have been so far, plumbers are not yet quaking in terror at the videos of androids falling over while attempting to open a dishwasher).

Re:I built "Middle Class Museum", a tour of things that used... by MarkusQ on Wednesday April 29, 2026 @03:27PM (#47953201)
Being untrue is what makes these things lies[1][2].

Arguing that they are emotionally compelling is just confirming that they're manipulative lies.

[1] https://www.in2013dollars.com/New-cars/price-inflation [2] https://econofact.org/factbrief/fact-check-have-inflation-ad...

Re:I built "Middle Class Museum", a tour of things that used... by ben_w on Thursday April 30, 2026 @03:36AM (#47959408)
Counterpoint for [1], that is claiming $15k in 1947 is $76,801.50 today. Here's a quote from Wikipedia about a 1948 luxury brand car model:

  The Cadillac Series 62 Coupe de Ville was introduced late in the 1949 model year.[4][9] Along with the Buick Roadmaster Riviera, and the Oldsmobile 98 Holiday, it was among the first pillarless hardtop coupes ever produced.[4][9] At $3,496 ($47,306 in 2025 dollars [5]) it was only a dollar less than the Series 62 convertible, and like the convertible, it came with power windows standard. It was luxuriously trimmed, with leather upholstery and chrome 'bows' in the headliner to simulate the ribs of a convertible top.[4][9]
And yes, I did check Wikipedia's references, it's page 115: https://archive.org/details/standardcatalogo00beve/page/114/...

And from the same source, the 1946 Crosley sedan was $905, three digits. (Page 813).

From your own [1], "Cars priced at $3,496 in 1949→$15,003.75 in 2026", and "Cars priced at $905 in 1947→$4,633.69 in 2026". The prices your [1] link give for 2026 sound like the price of new Chinese cars before tariffs, which Americans can't buy. And yes, I also noticed that $3,496 (1949) becoming $15k (2026) according to your link is completely out of sync with the number Wikipedia gave (Wikipedia agrees with https://www.bls.gov/data/inflation_calculator.htm which says the $905 (1946) Crosley sedan would cost $13,899.66 in 2026, where is 2026's new car for $14k? Oh, right, they're in China and just about here in Europe), which is my next counterpoint:

Counterpoint for [2], inflation is not one number for all things: https://www.aei.org/carpe-diem/chart-of-the-day-or-century-8...

This matters because of all the debate about which goods and services go into the basket of goods that is used to measure inflation, and that the headline number is generally wrong in both directions at the same time once you look at subgroups who are more and less dependent on different goods and services.

This also means that as groups stop buying certain things, they move out of those baskets fractionally or entirely. Like, fewer kids being born means less spending on childcare means it's weighted less in the basket, even if the reason for fewer kids is more expensive childcare.

For more about how the headline number hides the details, see: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yU2raZftgmE&t=601s

Re:I built "Middle Class Museum", a tour of things that used... by plytow on Wednesday April 29, 2026 @10:08AM (#47948696)
Less idiots is a good thing retard.
Re:I built "Middle Class Museum", a tour of things that used... by syel on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @10:48AM (#47935424)
Will review the numbers this week and see how I can update all numbers to adjust for inflation while keeping the satirical angle
Re:I built "Middle Class Museum", a tour of things that used... by pjc50 on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @10:53AM (#47935478)
"The summer job" card gets this exactly right and is a good example.

I'd paste the text, but you've somehow disabled select/copy/paste, UX strike number two.