Re:Is my blue your blue?
by hellojimbo on Monday April 27, 2026 @10:19PM
(#47929819)
For different brains, the answer has to be no because the images you see are a "neural net" construction and if that neural net differs then the "image" you see is different
this is actually a surprisingly rich area of debate in philosophy of mind. see: https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/qualia-inverted/
Consciousness and qualia are a mystery.
I would assume we don’t, simply because nerves are reproduced biologically, but I’m not a neuroscientist.
Re:Is my blue your blue?
by NoMoreNicksLeft on Monday April 27, 2026 @11:53PM
(#47930280)
>the same g-protein coupled b
If my "g-protein" actually your "g-protein"? Is my visual cortex firmware your visual cortex firmware?
Re:Is my blue your blue?
by gora_mohanty on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @08:49AM
(#47933840)
> If my "g-protein" actually your "g-protein"? Is my visual cortex firmware your visual cortex firmware?
That path leads down to solipsism which is not very intersting
Re:Is my blue your blue?
by NoMoreNicksLeft on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @03:11PM
(#47939130)
I was talking about something a little more empirical. Like, literally, does my g-protein consist of exactly the same amino acids chained together in the same sequence, and folded identically? Some minor mutations don't always make the protein non-functional, not all would result in color-blindness. I thought this was the basis for tetrachromats anyway, just with a different protein (and a more significant mutation).
Same with "firmware". If our brains process the data differently, then our actual perception might vary in (eventually, I would hope) real-world measurable ways.
define "experience the same way"
There's a philosophical school of thought (which I share) that there's no coherent definition.
Re:Is my blue your blue?
by altairprime on Tuesday April 28, 2026 @12:28AM
(#47930461)
My left and right eyes are shifted +cyan and +magenta respectively, so, no, definitely not — but hooray for the resulting semi-tetrachromacy :D
There is a cognitive science research group in japan that looks into this kind of problems [0]. They made a similarity judgement task, and construct embendings using it, which is basically a similarity structure in some vector space.
[0] Is my "red" your "red"?: Evaluating structural correspondences between color similarity judgments using unsupervised alignment https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40124475/
Is my "520 nm green" actually your "635 nm red"? And vice versa?
Are all of our color embeddings different despite the same g-protein coupled biochemical activation?