Congress has explicit authority to craft exceptions and regulations to SCOTUS appellate authority and what executive can do via power of the purse
Congress has explicit authority to reshape the court system
Legislative branches then have ultimate authority. The people in power are merely LARPing their hands are tied as they appeal to the propaganda we were all fed in public school (curriculum dictated by legislation)
It's all quid pro quo and intentional obfuscation by the people holding the scepter, gavel; whatever sigils and totem of power the elders worship blindly
SCOTUS authority should be whittled down the to explicitly defined powers with regard to ambassadors and treaties. The Judiciary as a whole should a part of these decisions not a cherry picked panel of obviously partisan hacks vetted by obviously partisan hacks
That we all sit around waiting on a bunch of incontinent elders glazing over live on TV is an massive indictment of the American public itself
What about striking down unconstitutional laws, though? That has to be up to SCOTUS, nobody else can do it.
So do not listen to justices that claim to be "originalist". SCOTUS authority to strike laws is self dealing and not at all an originalist power.
The original expectation was the public would demand such change via elections every 2-6 years and remove the corrupted Senator or Representative.
SCOTUS is not supposed to have power over theoretical cases yet it operates on concepts all the time. Just another way in which the system is rigged; the appeals of originalists who have clearly read the words, they're plain English, are just more self dealing power away from the public to the elites
It's not propaganda. It's a legal and historical theory that found popular purchase. The word propaganda has a meaning, and we're in a point in history where ensuring it retains that meaning is more important than in any other time in my life.
You can claim as you wish while I and others can do the same.
If you're saying we need to hold to beliefs of the past, that's a position that physical reality makes untenable.
See you in church? That was the center of communal life for the majority for centuries. Anyone that's abandoned such agency has engaged in abandonment of history, of norms others can just as easily (and do) claim are more important than ever.
You can make whatever claims you want rhetorically but the non-fractal reality we live in does not allow for the strict conservatism you appeal for. Entropy gives rise to generational churn which gives rise to shifting social values.
These corny appeals to history you never directly experienced are little more than parroting grammatically correct statements you were taught.
Sure. The definition of propaganda OP uses is an internet niche one to mean any broadly-held (and thus disseminated) theory one disagrees with.
The argument against co-equal branches is a legitimate one. Calling the theory propaganda cheapens a real argument by making it look childish.
noun The systematic propagation of a doctrine or cause or of information reflecting the views and interests of those advocating such a doctrine or cause.
...my use seems to fit the definition to me.
You are applying personal emotional bias to a very plain stated definition.
Where is that definition from? It lacks key elements of the definition, notably, an agenda.
Your operating definition would turn the teaching of evolution (or frankly, any education or broadly-communicated message) into propaganda.
That isn’t a serious claim. If it is for someone, that person’s definition of propaganda isn’t the generally-accepted one, which means it’s unclear how they’re speaking about anything else. By being hyperbolic you’re getting downvoted and ignored.
> You are applying personal emotional bias
Nope. I’m explaining why a serious argument you’re making, one that deserves consideration, is being downvoted and ignored for being introduced with a thoroughly unserious assertion.
You're one rando on a random text forum
You're self selecting as biology do and appealing to authority you don't have
You don't know what's generally accepted beliefs just your own biased belief
Oh no a meaningless social credit score!
I just Googled the definition; it reads the same as the posted definition on various sites; from Merriams to Oxford. Will go with the definition put forth by people who actually do the research not some self promoting random tech nerd
Imo your ego is driving you more than a well reasoned argument; you know how to game reputation on social media ergo you are correct
wanking motion
These are those source’s definitions [1][2]. They’re significantly more precise than the one I suspect you got from Google’s AI, hence your mis-use of the word. (Mis-use is fine. Doubling down against evidence is less forgiving.)
It was mentioned on a podcast recently that in many cases, the SC is not making a decision on what should/shouldn't happen/be the policy/is correct or whatever. They are deciding which layer of government gets to decide a given question. The Executive Branch? Legislation? Constitution? Who is the controlling entity?
Now, in a practical sense, by the time it gets to the SC, making a decision on who gets to decide, is, functionally, picking what the outcome is, since the various layers of government have already made their positions clear.
But the upshot is, if one is upset with what happens with a given policy after a SC decision, in many cases (although not all), the proper target of one's ire should not be the SC; since what they are usually saying is something like "this is something that is controlled by statute. If the statute is dumb/bad/poorly written, that is not our fault nor within our control, take it up with Congress to rewrite the statue", and instead one should be upset with whoever the controlling entity is for doing a bad job (in recent years: most commonly congress, not so much for doing a bad job so much as not doing any job)