News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:VLC Core is LGPL by jbk on Thursday November 15, 2012 @08:56AM (#4788521)
> On a reading of how it was done, I guess if anyone had contributed stuff under the GPL and particularly objected to LGPL relicensing the could probably still make arguments about derivative works... Read part 1 and 3

> Interestingly there's no mention of dissenting opinions from anywhere. Not that I'm implying that this move is a bad thing, I would just expect if you ask a large enough group of developers any question about licensing you would get a variety of arguments cropping up.

Because the vast majority of VLC developers want their code to be used, not fight over licenses.

Re:VLC Core is LGPL by Nursie on Thursday November 15, 2012 @09:48AM (#4788730)
> Read part 1 and 3

I have read part 1, didn't know there was a part 3.

I'm just saying that imagine (in a hypothetical situation) there is a large code module written by an original author under the GPL. Over time it is worked on and line by line it is eventually fully replaced with new code by 5 other people.

Even if you get the 5 to agree to a license change, the original 1 would still have an argument that it was all derived from his original work and should remain under GPL.

I have no idea if this situation applies to you, it was just an idle thought.

Re:VLC Core is LGPL by jbk on Thursday November 15, 2012 @09:56AM (#4788773)
> I'm just saying that imagine (in a hypothetical situation) there is a large code module written by an original author under the GPL.

This is not the case here. And part 1 explains exactly this, with the git log part.

Part 3 will close the loop altogether.

Re:VLC Core is LGPL by Nursie on Thursday November 15, 2012 @10:02AM (#4788814)
Oops, missed that!

In my defence I drank a lot of rum last night...

Re:VLC Core is LGPL by jbk on Thursday November 15, 2012 @01:05PM (#4789847)
But you did not share your rum with me, this is unacceptable :)