News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:VLC Core is LGPL by Nursie on Thursday November 15, 2012 @06:48AM (#4788122)
On a reading of how it was done, I guess if anyone had contributed stuff under the GPL and particularly objected to LGPL relicensing the could probably still make arguments about derivative works...

Interestingly there's no mention of dissenting opinions from anywhere. Not that I'm implying that this move is a bad thing, I would just expect if you ask a large enough group of developers any question about licensing you would get a variety of arguments cropping up.

Re:VLC Core is LGPL by pm215 on Thursday November 15, 2012 @07:40AM (#4788261)
The commit message includes in its list of modules which are not converted:

- iOS audio output and video display, because author refuses the license change

- Mono, Headphone and Dolby, because author refuses the license change

So there is some dissenting opinion.

Re:VLC Core is LGPL by jbk on Thursday November 15, 2012 @07:46AM (#4788274)
2 authors out of 230 is not that much... And for example, the author of headphone objected only on Headphone and Dolby, but allowed the rest of his code to be changed.
Re:VLC Core is LGPL by Nursie on Thursday November 15, 2012 @09:51AM (#4788751)
That's quite remarkable, given how contrary and argumentative developers often seem to be!
Re:VLC Core is LGPL by jbk on Thursday November 15, 2012 @09:56AM (#4788776)
Yep. I was surprised too :)
Re:VLC Core is LGPL by Florin_Andrei on Thursday November 15, 2012 @04:36PM (#4790878)
Rip out that stuff, replace it anew.
Re:VLC Core is LGPL by jbk on Thursday November 15, 2012 @08:56AM (#4788521)
> On a reading of how it was done, I guess if anyone had contributed stuff under the GPL and particularly objected to LGPL relicensing the could probably still make arguments about derivative works... Read part 1 and 3

> Interestingly there's no mention of dissenting opinions from anywhere. Not that I'm implying that this move is a bad thing, I would just expect if you ask a large enough group of developers any question about licensing you would get a variety of arguments cropping up.

Because the vast majority of VLC developers want their code to be used, not fight over licenses.

Re:VLC Core is LGPL by Nursie on Thursday November 15, 2012 @09:48AM (#4788730)
> Read part 1 and 3

I have read part 1, didn't know there was a part 3.

I'm just saying that imagine (in a hypothetical situation) there is a large code module written by an original author under the GPL. Over time it is worked on and line by line it is eventually fully replaced with new code by 5 other people.

Even if you get the 5 to agree to a license change, the original 1 would still have an argument that it was all derived from his original work and should remain under GPL.

I have no idea if this situation applies to you, it was just an idle thought.

Re:VLC Core is LGPL by jbk on Thursday November 15, 2012 @09:56AM (#4788773)
> I'm just saying that imagine (in a hypothetical situation) there is a large code module written by an original author under the GPL.

This is not the case here. And part 1 explains exactly this, with the git log part.

Part 3 will close the loop altogether.

Re:VLC Core is LGPL by Nursie on Thursday November 15, 2012 @10:02AM (#4788814)
Oops, missed that!

In my defence I drank a lot of rum last night...

Re:VLC Core is LGPL by jbk on Thursday November 15, 2012 @01:05PM (#4789847)
But you did not share your rum with me, this is unacceptable :)