News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Audacity of Doing Nothing by ryanwaggoner on Thursday February 12, 2009 @10:31AM (#478520)
Haven't we just rediscovered that "money management" is basically pseudoscience? These are the kinds of people who promise to beat the market using their special models or skills. On average they fail.

No. While they may fail on average, they certainly don't all fail. There are some money managers who are truly brilliant and have consistently had great returns. Granted, these people are few and far between, but that doesn't negate the value of the entire field.

Using your logic, you could easily make the case that entrepreneurship is pseudoscience, since almost all entrepreneurs fail, therefore no one should invest with them or trust them.

Re:The Audacity of Doing Nothing by nradov on Thursday February 12, 2009 @10:54AM (#478557)
Are they brilliant or just lucky? And how do you tell the difference?
Re:The Audacity of Doing Nothing by ryanwaggoner on Thursday February 12, 2009 @11:51AM (#478625)
That's an entire discussion of its own. My point was that they're not all just lucky.
Re:The Audacity of Doing Nothing by mattmaroon on Thursday February 12, 2009 @12:15PM (#478658)
You can't prove that, and even if you could, you couldn't prove which ones weren't just lucky so the statement is useless.
Re:The Audacity of Doing Nothing by ryanwaggoner on Thursday February 12, 2009 @01:33PM (#478774)
Isn't the argument the same for any field? Can't we argue that successful practitioners in every field may have just gotten lucky, from entrepreneurship to science to anything else?

Not being able to prove something empirically doesn't mean that it's automatically invalid, or that we should dismiss it as being unworthy of . People don't start companies because they can prove that they'll be successful, and people don't invest in companies because they can prove that they're going to succeed. They invest because they believe the odds of success are sufficiently high to justify the risk.

In the same way, I don't think we've rediscovered that money management is pseudoscience just because most money managers fail to beat the market. That market is itself made up of people who are trying to beat each other, and statistically, most will fail and disappear. That doesn't mean that the market is a failure or that it's "pseudoscience".

Re:The Audacity of Doing Nothing by mattmaroon on Thursday February 12, 2009 @10:35PM (#479382)
No, you really can't say that for almost any field. Money management and poker tournaments are about all I can come up with. In any competitive field with a quantifiable scoreboard, you could take the data, extract from it means and standard deviations, and say with x% certainty that one player is better than another.

In money management, x is never very large. It's so small that you can't reliably say that anyone is better than anyone else, in fact the overall distribution of money managers isn't much different from what it would be if it were all chimpanzees selecting stocks with darts. In basketball or chess, x gets to pretty near 100.

Re:The Audacity of Doing Nothing by jimbokun on Thursday February 12, 2009 @05:02PM (#479063)
'That market is itself made up of people who are trying to beat each other, and statistically, most will fail and disappear. That doesn't mean that the market is a failure or that it's "pseudoscience".'

The trouble is, you can come up with a pretty good approximation of a portfolio that reflects the "wisdom" of the broad market on your own. Pick one or a few diversified index funds, follow some guidelines to split up your portfolio between fixed income and equities (maybe add some real estate or commodities if you want to get fancy), and you're done. You might get some suggestions on the particulars of which index fund, or exact allocation percentages, from a money manager but that's not really adding much value. Maybe just a one time consultation.

But what if you want to beat the market? Is there someone you can go to and be confident he or she has a good chance to succeed?

Well, if such a person exists, you probably will not be able to identify him or her, except maybe if you know as much about money management as they do. Bernie Madoff is the perfect example here. The people who invested with him were not able to distinguish his pyramid scheme scam from a good investing scheme until it was too late. Some of his investors were supposedly pretty sophisticated in financial matters, too.

So, you can get the average market return on your own, and you probably can't tell a good money manager from a bad one. That eliminates most of the reasons for employing a money manager, even if good ones exist.

Re:The Audacity of Doing Nothing by ryanwaggoner on Thursday February 12, 2009 @05:19PM (#479094)
I'm firmly in the camp of index fund investing over picking individual stocks or money managers. Statistics will tell you that you're far better off just picking an index fund. But that doesn't make money management an invalid field or a pseudoscience. It just means that it's hard to differentiate between those with true skill and those who just got lucky.

It seems like the same can be said for venture investing. How do you know which entrepreneurs will be successful? You don't, so you go off of their past performance, the market environment, the strength of their idea and their team, etc, etc. But you also go one step further and try to spread the risk across a portfolio of investments. Perhaps you should do the same with money managers? Pick the 10-20 at the top of the field and let them all manage a piece of your portfolio? Obvious problems here as well.

On a related note, does this mean that venture funding is fundamentally flawed? That venture funds would be better off just putting their money in index funds? I have a hard time seeing that.

Re:The Audacity of Doing Nothing by mattmaroon on Friday February 13, 2009 @12:02AM (#479466)
It's not hard to differentiate between those who have true skill and those who got lucky, it's impossible. The variance is just too high. Hard implies that if you worked at it enough, you could somehow do it. You can't.

And yes, venture funding is fundamentally flawed and the average VC firm underperforms the market. LPs as a whole would be better off with index funds.

However, unlike with equities, you can get an edge in VC investing because results tend to perpetuate themselves. Remember, equities of non-public companies aren't priced by the market, so they aren't as efficient, and it's the efficiency of the market that makes beating it untenable. Also there's a tremendous deal of collusion in private equity that doesn't exist in public due to regulation. It's actually a mystery to me how they get away with much of what they do.

The two types of investing aren't really comparable due to that. You could simply invest every year in the top few VC firms from the previous year and outperform the market for a long time that way. You cannot do this with hedge funds or mutual funds, or if you could, you and I would both not support the notion of just sticking it in ETFs.

Re:The Audacity of Doing Nothing by comatose_kid on Thursday February 12, 2009 @02:13PM (#478824)
Not really - think about a heart surgeon's success rate vs. a money manager over the long term (20 years).
Re:The Audacity of Doing Nothing by crux_ on Thursday February 12, 2009 @01:33PM (#478775)
Likewise, if I were to roll a die 100,000 times there will likely be a nonzero number of periods where I roll a 4 or better over 20 times in a row! (Numbers made up because this is arguing on the internet.)

Entrepreneurship isn't even a pseudoscience, by the way, in the same sense that raising a family isn't. Apples, oranges. ('Economics' would qualify.)

Re:The Audacity of Doing Nothing by ryanwaggoner on Thursday February 12, 2009 @02:03PM (#478813)
Rolling a die is a truly random act, where the initiator has no control over the outcome. I don't think the same can be said for entrepreneurship, raising a family, or investing. I don't think they're apples and oranges at all. Just as many money managers (investors) may end up getting lucky through no merit of their own, many businesses succeed or fail due to random chance, and many kids turn out horribly even though they grew up in stable, loving homes. Does that mean that your success in entrepreneurship and raising a family are pure chance?

I don't think that the YC approach to investment carries the same amount of risk as someone going to crunchbase and investing in random companies they find there. Surely there's some value to studying what has worked in the past and trying to apply it to future endeavors.

Re:The Audacity of Doing Nothing by crux_ on Thursday February 12, 2009 @05:12PM (#479084)
I'm simply pointing out that the existence of successful investors doesn't itself carry any information about why they might be successful.

As for the rest, well, yes, it is apples and oranges. What hypotheses does entrepreneurship make about way the world works? Is the purpose of doing so to explain or enlighten? Even religion is more scientific in its goal.

It's like calling pottery or engineering or writing a (pseudo-)science. (Ceramic chemistry, physics, or linguistics would all count.... see?)

Re:The Audacity of Doing Nothing by tokenadult on Thursday February 12, 2009 @07:47PM (#479249)
There are some money managers who are truly brilliant and have consistently had great returns.

Who, for example?