News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Starbucks, Google and Amazon: the tax crash of Monday aft... by smoyer on Tuesday November 13, 2012 @07:31AM (#4777603)
"Fundamentally immoral"

In the US a corporation's legal responsibilities are to it's shareholders ... it might be fundamentally immoral but it would be unethical to operate the company against the interests of the shareholders too.

It's the laws that need to be changed rather than blaming the companies for being good at accounting.

Re:Starbucks, Google and Amazon: the tax crash of Monday aft... by morsch on Tuesday November 13, 2012 @07:47AM (#4777665)
I don't follow that line of reasoning. Assuming it's fundamentally immoral, it remains fundamentally immoral for a company.

If a person did it, we'd call it immoral. When it's a group of persons doing it, we'd call it immoral. But when it's one group of persons doing it -- the employees -- in the name of another group -- the owners -- it's suddenly unethical not to do it? I don't get that.

I guess it'd be unethical for the employees to act one way when they know the owners want them to act another way. But if the owners willingly let the company act immorally, then they are themselves acting immorally. Which is, of course, the case.

Re:Starbucks, Google and Amazon: the tax crash of Monday aft... by wtvanhest on Tuesday November 13, 2012 @08:29AM (#4777824)
The problem is that shareholders include everyday people who have money in mutual funds who invest that money in large cap corporations who depend on management of those corporations to maximize their shareholder value at the expense of all outside, non-investors. Including employees, governments etc. as long as it is legal and maximizes long term shareholder value.

It is a fundamental shift in finance theory that occurred about 25-30 years ago. Many people will argue that management should put the shareholders above all else. I think there is a somewhat muted, but real discussion happening in a lot of places that the currently accepted system may not be the best one, but for now, management has a fiduciary responsibility to shareholders.

Re:Starbucks, Google and Amazon: the tax crash of Monday aft... by morsch on Tuesday November 13, 2012 @09:11AM (#4778038)
It's a problem because it spreads out the blame on a lot of people. Management can point to the shareholders. The shareholders argue they each own just a small bit of the shares and aren't involved at all in the day to day business. It's a systemic fault.
Re:Starbucks, Google and Amazon: the tax crash of Monday aft... by wtvanhest on Tuesday November 13, 2012 @10:30AM (#4778457)
Yes, I agree with you. But it is a current fact. I have no idea what the solution is, but when a system works conveniently for so many people it is unlikely to change.

The crazy thing is that people "blame evil corporations" while having almost 100% of their retirement invested in the corporations they dispise without even realizing it.

Unless you have no savings, you are likely a shareholder in a number of companies which are using transfer pricing to save on taxes.

Re:Starbucks, Google and Amazon: the tax crash of Monday aft... by Nursie on Tuesday November 13, 2012 @11:37AM (#4778839)
Very, very unlikely.

You are much more likely an investor in a unit fund that itself holds shares. As a result you have no say over anything, and pretty much no alternative but to join one of these schemes.

Re:Starbucks, Google and Amazon: the tax crash of Monday aft... by wtvanhest on Tuesday November 13, 2012 @12:40PM (#4779298)
The point is: You invest in funds that invest in companies that use transfer pricing to minimize taxes.

You could say you don't want to be invested by not investing in mutual funds/ETFs etc.

But, almost every American with savings does invest and is the direct beneficiary of transfer pricing.

You and others could decide to allocate a portion of your capital gains back to the UK government as a gift, but I think that is "very, very unlikely".

[Also] One strategy could be to only choose small cap names, then you are unlikely to hear of any of the "evil" things the corporations you own are doing... Obviously that would create problems with risk in your portfolio.

Re:Starbucks, Google and Amazon: the tax crash of Monday aft... by erichocean on Wednesday November 14, 2012 @05:26AM (#4782794)
If a person did it, we'd call it immoral. When it's a group of persons doing it, we'd call it immoral. But when it's one group of persons doing it -- the employees -- in the name of another group -- the owners -- it's suddenly unethical not to do it? I don't get that.

You don't strike me as having a libertarian bent, but that's essentially the argument used to justify taxes as immoral:

If I steal from my neighbor and distribute the proceeds to the community, including my neighbor and myself, it's theft – immoral.

But if the whole community gets together and vote to steal from my neighbor, and his neighbor, and everyone's neighbor, and split up the proceeds – that's suddenly moral?

Point is, not all arguments generalize from "a person doing it to" to a group doing the same thing collectively.

Re:Starbucks, Google and Amazon: the tax crash of Monday aft... by Zak on Tuesday November 13, 2012 @08:48AM (#4777911)
If a person did it, we'd call it immoral

Would we? It's pretty rare that I hear of someone being accused of immorality for taking every tax deduction allowed by law. If people want to complain about tax deductions, they usually say that the law is bad, not the people who follow it as written.

Re:Starbucks, Google and Amazon: the tax crash of Monday aft... by Nursie on Tuesday November 13, 2012 @08:58AM (#4777976)
Have you been to the UK recently? Do you know who Jimmy Carr is?
Re:Starbucks, Google and Amazon: the tax crash of Monday aft... by Zak on Tuesday November 13, 2012 @09:15AM (#4778053)
I was in the UK briefly this summer, but learned nothing relevant to this discussion while there. I didn't know who Jimmy Carr is until this post; it seems that the major controversy stems from the fact that he criticized others for avoiding taxes, then did the same thing himself.

I think countries should arrange their tax rates and accounting rules so that there's little incentive to avoid taxes by moving money around, but I don't think it's in any way immoral to pay as little tax as the law requires. Governments are not charities and do not run on donations.

Re:Starbucks, Google and Amazon: the tax crash of Monday aft... by bruceboughton on Tuesday November 13, 2012 @08:35AM (#4777848)
Your mistake is in your assumption: different people have different values of "fundamentally immoral". Different people do not have different values of "illegal".
Re:Starbucks, Google and Amazon: the tax crash of Monday aft... by morsch on Tuesday November 13, 2012 @09:04AM (#4778010)
Sure. That just means people have different moral evaluations of a company's conduct. It doesn't mean people shouldn't or can't sensibly have such evaluations.
Re:Starbucks, Google and Amazon: the tax crash of Monday aft... by smoyer on Tuesday November 13, 2012 @08:44AM (#4777886)
Do you pay the minimum amount of tax allowed by law? And is that immoral? I guess you're right ... it's not immoral after all.
Re:Starbucks, Google and Amazon: the tax crash of Monday aft... by Nursie on Tuesday November 13, 2012 @07:34AM (#4777616)
It's an interesting conflict, and clearly they do have a duty to investors to maximise their profit. If it was a privately owned company it might be more clear cut.

Absolutely agree the laws need to be changed. I, personally, would be looking to stop the 'convenient' reporting of losses in markets that are actually highly profitable but not tax efficient. There's an interesting comment on the Starbucks press release that coves it quite nicely -

"How can Starbucks tell Companies House and HMRC that its UK business is loss-making but tell analysts in SEC-regulated calls that the UK business is profit-making, without either making misleading financial statements or filing false accounts?"

Re:Starbucks, Google and Amazon: the tax crash of Monday aft... by rfugger on Tuesday November 13, 2012 @07:42AM (#4777646)
Re:Starbucks, Google and Amazon: the tax crash of Monday aft... by arethuza on Tuesday November 13, 2012 @08:22AM (#4777792)
They aren't the same legal entity - it is entirely possible that the US parent company is profitable and the UK subsidiary loss making (or indeed vice-versa).
Re:Starbucks, Google and Amazon: the tax crash of Monday aft... by Nursie on Tuesday November 13, 2012 @08:27AM (#4777821)
That's not what's happening though, there are reports by the parent company that the UK business is profitable, when it suits them to boost share prices, yet reports from in country that there has been a loss so they can minimise taxes.

I agree - it's possible that Starbucks UK is not pofitable, and that the parent company is, or vice versa. But reporting the same thing in different ways to different audiences seems fishy to me!

Re:Starbucks, Google and Amazon: the tax crash of Monday aft... by arethuza on Tuesday November 13, 2012 @08:36AM (#4777851)
Good point - I guess if they are saying in their UK tax return that they aren't profitable and the US reports that they are making substantial profits in the UK then that is extremely fishy.

Aren't they just transfer pricing their profits out of the UK to Switzerland and the US?

Re:Starbucks, Google and Amazon: the tax crash of Monday aft... by smoyer on Tuesday November 13, 2012 @07:48AM (#4777669)
You'd think these companies would be smart enough to show a small profit and pay the taxes on it ... You don't really gain anything by showing a loss.
Re:Starbucks, Google and Amazon: the tax crash of Monday aft... by edderly on Tuesday November 13, 2012 @08:04AM (#4777736)
No, more accurately a corporation is an autonomous legal 'person'.

http://hbr.org/2010/04/the-myth-of-shareholder-capitalism/ar...

"Shareholders do not own the corporation, which is an autonomous legal person. What’s more, when directors go against shareholder wishes—even when a loss in value is documented—courts side with directors the vast majority of the time. Shareholders seem to get this. They’ve tried to unseat directors through lawsuits just 24 times in large corporations over the past 20 years; they’ve succeeded only eight times. In short, directors are to a great extent autonomous."

Re:Starbucks, Google and Amazon: the tax crash of Monday aft... by dabeeeenster on Tuesday November 13, 2012 @08:02AM (#4777730)
How is paying taxes not in the interests of shareholders?

I think this attitude is at the heart of the problem.

Re:Starbucks, Google and Amazon: the tax crash of Monday aft... by Zak on Tuesday November 13, 2012 @08:53AM (#4777940)
If I live in the US and own shares of Starbucks, it is much more strongly aligned with my interests for Starbucks to pay me a dividend than to pay that same amount in UK taxes.

Even in a jurisdiction where I might see some benefit from the taxes, I'd probably see more benefit from that same amount of money in my pocket. It's perfectly rational to want to minimize one's tax obligation, especially to foreign governments.