2. The equity question is something that I asked about... basically the thought was that its your work, you should get to profit from it. Just like when you buy a server from dell, dell doesn't get a slice of equity from your company.
3. This program as being run as a low cost high impact bootstrapped startup itself. That said the costs are a LOT lower than just about anything like it. Tech Stars for example is six percent of your company for office space, and coaching for 120 days. This is just $1500, for just the coaching. (And there are quite a few coffee shops in Portland that will let you work from them if you so choose.)
2) I'm not sure the analogy makes sense. Dell doesn't judge a company's business plan before it decides to sell you a server.
One of the important considerations with Portland 10 isn't whether or not I should get 100% of the ownership/profit, it's whether or not their advice helps me grow my business enough that I don't care that they get a cut of the equity.
3) That's fine - I don't agree that the trade-off (upfront capital with relatively unproven advisors vs. giving up equity with more proven investors who have a track record of investing in strong companies)is optimal.
That said, it's good to see something happening in Portland.
1) Not sure about the quality of advisors - doesn't mean they're bad, I've never really heard of them.
edit: It seems that although Carolyn may be well connected, she hasn't run a startup herself. Not promising.
2) I don't really see a lot of conviction in their ability to pick winners, else they would be more interested in equity.
3) "we don’t invest capital; we train entrepreneurs to get things done without it" - It seems kind of funny that they expect entrepreneurs to pay to learn how to conserve capital :)
If I were YC, I'd be annoyed that they claim to be similar.