1) Not sure about the quality of advisors - doesn't mean they're bad, I've never really heard of them.
edit: It seems that although Carolyn may be well connected, she hasn't run a startup herself. Not promising.
2) I don't really see a lot of conviction in their ability to pick winners, else they would be more interested in equity.
3) "we don’t invest capital; we train entrepreneurs to get things done without it" - It seems kind of funny that they expect entrepreneurs to pay to learn how to conserve capital :)
If I were YC, I'd be annoyed that they claim to be similar.
2. The equity question is something that I asked about... basically the thought was that its your work, you should get to profit from it. Just like when you buy a server from dell, dell doesn't get a slice of equity from your company.
3. This program as being run as a low cost high impact bootstrapped startup itself. That said the costs are a LOT lower than just about anything like it. Tech Stars for example is six percent of your company for office space, and coaching for 120 days. This is just $1500, for just the coaching. (And there are quite a few coffee shops in Portland that will let you work from them if you so choose.)
2) I'm not sure the analogy makes sense. Dell doesn't judge a company's business plan before it decides to sell you a server.
One of the important considerations with Portland 10 isn't whether or not I should get 100% of the ownership/profit, it's whether or not their advice helps me grow my business enough that I don't care that they get a cut of the equity.
3) That's fine - I don't agree that the trade-off (upfront capital with relatively unproven advisors vs. giving up equity with more proven investors who have a track record of investing in strong companies)is optimal.
That said, it's good to see something happening in Portland.
Long story made short, its a training program to get your business to the point where you can can take outside investment. This is a very solid program developed by an expert in the fund raising process, for getting the financial and business put together so your startup doesn't flame out.
The $1M figure is from the goal of the program which is to develop at least Ten companies in Portland (i.e. Portland Ten) with over a million dollars in REVENUE. So you don't necessarily have to get outside funding, but in either case your ready to grow.
No equity is being traded for this program. The costs are quite low compared to other programs of its kind.
Also office space is not provided, its an add-on at the new Portland co-working space, http://nedspace.com you don't need to use it but its recommended.
The program is solid. Check out http://bigpaperblog.com/ for the program developers website.