While working on a C++ vector engine optimized for 5M+ documents in very tight RAM (240MB), I often find myself looking back at how Oberon handled resource management. In an era where a 'hello world' app can pull in 100MB of dependencies, the idea of a full OS that is both human-readable and fits into a few megabytes is more relevant than ever.
Rochus, since you’ve worked on the IDE and the kernel: do you think the strictness of Oberon’s type system and its lean philosophy still offers a performance advantage for modern high-density data tasks, or is it primarily an educational 'ideal' at this point?
I get the motivation for wanting to use LLVM, but personally I don't like it (and have the luxury of ignoring it since I only do compilers as a hobby...) and prefer to aim for self-hosting whenever I work on a language. But LLVM is of course a perfectly fine choice if your goal doesn't include self-hosting - you get a lot for free.
Is it? Isn't it rather the case that C is too low level to express intent and (hence) offer room to optimize? I would expect that a language in which, e.g. matrix multiplication can be natively expressed, could be compiled to more efficient code for such.
I would rather expect, that for compilers which don't optimize well, C is the easiest to produce fairly efficient code for (well, perhaps BCPL would be even easier, but nobody wants to use that these days).
That's exactly the question we would hope to answer with such an experiment. Given that your language received sufficient investments to implement an optimal LLVM adaptation (as C did), we would then expect your language to be significantly faster on a benchmark heavily depending on matrix multiplication. If not, this would mean that the optimizer can get away with any language and the specific language design features have little impact on performance (and we can use them without performance worries).
> Our results have shown that–because of the profiling feedback loop–object code produced by continuous optimizations is often of a higher quality than can be achieved using static "off-line" compilation. Optimization at runtime, if performed judiciously, can often surpass optimizations performed at compile-time, independent of whether the latter are guided by profiling information or not. Our results have also given evidence that reoptimizing an already running program in response to changes in user behavior can give rise to real performance improvements.
Kistler, Thomas, and Michael Franz. "Continuous program optimization: Design and evaluation." IEEE Transactions on Computers 50, no. 6 (2002). <https://doi.org/10.1109/12.931893>