Re:Ending the cults of personality in free software
by CodeMage on Sunday November 11, 2012 @09:42AM
(#4769572)
Maybe I'm just naive, but I don't think "Linus is as likely to be 'wrong' about desktop Linux as most others who use the desktop." While I agree that other people might be overestimating the importance of Linus's opinion on desktop Linux, I believe he's less likely to be wrong about these things than a whole bunch of people. It's not the same as with "rocket ships, film production, oil recovery techniques", because he has a lot more to do with Linux in general than those other topics.
Yes, it's important not to jump on a bandwagon, but that goes both ways: it seems to be increasingly fashionable to attack "celebrities" in our field through thinly veiled ad hominems. Calling Linus a "grumpy-head" or describing Stallman as "waddling" and having a "beard matted into a bizarre pizza crust flapping off the end of his chin" [1] are just recent examples. It's ruse and it does not truly contribute to the point the author is trying to make anyway.
As @math and @forgottenpaswrd mentioned in their comments, Linus is a smart guy who, furthermore, has a non-negligible level of expertise and credibility when it comes to Linux-related topics in general. I'll pay attention to his opinions and try to extract facts from them, in order to form my own. I understand that the author is frustrated with people who don't do that, but dissing Linus is not the way to rectify the situation.
In the end, I don't care what Linus uses on his computer as much as why he uses (or refuses to use) it and how that might applied in general.
Yes, it's important not to jump on a bandwagon, but that goes both ways: it seems to be increasingly fashionable to attack "celebrities" in our field through thinly veiled ad hominems. Calling Linus a "grumpy-head" or describing Stallman as "waddling" and having a "beard matted into a bizarre pizza crust flapping off the end of his chin" [1] are just recent examples. It's ruse and it does not truly contribute to the point the author is trying to make anyway.
As @math and @forgottenpaswrd mentioned in their comments, Linus is a smart guy who, furthermore, has a non-negligible level of expertise and credibility when it comes to Linux-related topics in general. I'll pay attention to his opinions and try to extract facts from them, in order to form my own. I understand that the author is frustrated with people who don't do that, but dissing Linus is not the way to rectify the situation.
In the end, I don't care what Linus uses on his computer as much as why he uses (or refuses to use) it and how that might applied in general.
[1]: http://brooklynhacker.com/post/35445721578/that-moment-when-...