Yes, it's important not to jump on a bandwagon, but that goes both ways: it seems to be increasingly fashionable to attack "celebrities" in our field through thinly veiled ad hominems. Calling Linus a "grumpy-head" or describing Stallman as "waddling" and having a "beard matted into a bizarre pizza crust flapping off the end of his chin" [1] are just recent examples. It's ruse and it does not truly contribute to the point the author is trying to make anyway.
As @math and @forgottenpaswrd mentioned in their comments, Linus is a smart guy who, furthermore, has a non-negligible level of expertise and credibility when it comes to Linux-related topics in general. I'll pay attention to his opinions and try to extract facts from them, in order to form my own. I understand that the author is frustrated with people who don't do that, but dissing Linus is not the way to rectify the situation.
In the end, I don't care what Linus uses on his computer as much as why he uses (or refuses to use) it and how that might applied in general.
[1]: http://brooklynhacker.com/post/35445721578/that-moment-when-...
You can not make an informed opinion on _everything_. There is too much information out there to fact check all bits of it. Sooner or later you will have to take somebody elses opinion on faith, i.e. to trust that he has fact checked something so you dont have to.
Unfortunately, ideas like "is open-source good" are usually very difficult to turn into pure facts, and are therefore opinions. And these are usually very different depending on what different people think the world is or should be - there is no "correct" fact which I can trust someone else to verify.
The review may be in a language you speak (and may be in a language they speak,) and they may have understood my book, but I am a clever author and they were the cheapest reviewer I could find. They are not themselves an author, nor can they read, but they have talk to authors before and have looked at the pictures in my book (I had not realized they were there!) and asked me questions I did not understand.
Oh, and I will not correct, evaluate or pay you for your sequel but readers of my book can choose to also read your book. I can cancel or up the fee for my book whenever I feel like it, so future readers may not exist.
I would say that it is a "correct fact" that it is a disadvantage to undertake the project I suggest even though you may on occasion succeed. Similarly, I would suggest you avoid building on your own dime on a closed source framework. But hey, I can't prove that golfing in lightning storms is a bad plan, so go nuts..
The reality is that Linus is good at kernels and DRCS for the same reason and is not mere "knowledge", and for the same reason you should pay attention when he talks about software in general.
OP says that whatever makes him good at kernels doesn't help to make him good at version control systems (X->K but X-/->V), whereas you say that there is a third factor that makes him good at both (X->K and X->V): I say that it is his long experience with managing a zillion patches and branches for the kernel that made him good at version control (K->V).
Otherwise I could counter-argument that people that use a lot Desktop features in their day to day work are in line to create the best desktop ever, which is not true.
For Linus handling a lot of patches was just the motivation and what also gave him the required background (that is not enough) and the opportunity to be an user itself of his ideas on RCS.
Another argument is that Git does not offer incredible advantages only to big projects, it is winning actually because its wast advantages can "scale down" very easily to small projects.
The bandwagon effect in OSS is a truth, but this is not a cult behavior, this is skills recognition. Just look at how languages and tools have changed in the last ten years, these changes are driven by users not by BDFLs.
When I compare software to, let's say politics or the media, I'm not ashamed of the open source community.
Then, when you're challenging open-source it's a whole different thing, you're criticizing a philosophy, you can't just bash it, you have to refute it logically.
I knew if I don't do that others will turn the comment thread into a open source vs proprietary war and the main point will be dismissed.
So I thought I'd highlight that I'm just using that as an example that everyone has seen and can relate to so that people will keep the conversation around the bigger picture.
I see this cult-like behaviour quite a lot.
Particular examples, when it comes to open source and free software and gnu/unix, vim emacs etc...
It feels like most people just follow the cult's teachings and hold the same opinions that they saw.
I'm sure you guys all think open source software is fantastic and can give me 10 reasons and examples in support of your opinion.
But how much of it is truly your own conclusion and your findings vs just repeating what you were told before and what everyone else seems to be saying?
Have you ever stopped for a second and asked yourself about it? Have you tried to challenge the popular opinions of the cult?
What would you be doing, if every other hacker was bashing open source today and praising proprietary software?
There's a factor in here that I call 'Bandwagon Threshold Theory'. People react negatively to new and disrupting ideas until a critical mass of people start admiring it. By then they jump on the bandwagon and start preaching and telling everyone about how cool this thing is.
If you look around you can see it everywhere.
Older ideas and technologies have already established their bandwagon and therefore there's strong resistance and hesitance in saying anything negatively about them.
Don't believe me? just say something negative about open source and see how religiously people will defend it.
I guarantee you, the majority of those defenders will simply be doing so not as a result of deep understanding and knowledge but because of the teachings of the cult.
I have previously written a short rant here as well: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4601593
PS: I just used the open source examples etc to make a point. My comment is general about the cult-like behaviour in the industry not about something specific. In summary, I think we should all stop worrying about standing out and start challenging the things we take for granted as a result of being surrounded and constantly fed a set of accepted and popular beliefs and opinions.