News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by noosphr on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @10:51PM (#47684419)
This is the counter argument: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2026_Iran_massacres

Here's hoping the regime is destabilised enough to topple by itself.

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by hrimfaxi on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @10:55PM (#47684442)
How is this in any way a counter argument to the US bombing a school? That their own government would stoop to such lengths gives free reign to foreign governments?
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by Manuel_D on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @11:13PM (#47684598)
The idea is that incurring a few hundred civilians deaths to liberate Iranians from a regime that slaughtered them by the thousands or tens of thousands is a net positive for human life. Of course this only works as a justification if the Iranians actually are liberated front their regime, which I don't think they will.

But the justification, if the liberation actually transpires, is sound. An order of magnitude more French and Dutch died at the hands of Allied bombing and shelling in 1944. I think most agree the the upside of being liberated from Germany makes the Allied landings a net positive, though.

But to reiterate, I really doubt the revolutionary guard is going to lose control of Iran.

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by RiverStone on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @12:12AM (#47685128)
This aligns with conversations I’ve had with Iranians. They really do believe that the ends justify the means here if they can destroy the regime.
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by jacquesm on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @01:14AM (#47685589)
Iranians abroad or Iranians in Iran?

Because the ones abroad don't have a lot to lose and much to gain. The ones in Iran have a lot to lose as well.

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by noosphr on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @01:23AM (#47685654)
Like being killed if they said they want regime change.
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by jamesgill on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @11:35PM (#47684807)
Congratulations for rediscovering Machiavelli. “The ends justify the means” is such a winning philosophy.
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by renewiltord on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @11:49PM (#47684933)
The ends do alter the acceptability of the means. E.g. if I offered you the means of “pay money to flip coin to make money as many times as possible” and the numbers involved were $50k if heads, lose $1k if tails and $50 buy in that’s way different if the numbers involved were $1k if heads, lose $50k if tails and $500k buy in.

If you can’t alter your reasoning to include outcomes then you will make poorer decisions.

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by pstuart on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @11:53PM (#47684967)
> Of course this only works as a justification

If killing those kids was instrumental in a greater good, only then is it worth being philosophical about. From what I've seen, they were too eager with the bang bang boom boom to actually double check that it was a valid target.

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by KennyBlanken on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @12:11AM (#47685122)
Double checked?

They fed ancient intelligence into an AI which spit out a target list that nobody seems to have checked, period.

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by eesmith on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @11:50PM (#47684942)
The situation is hardly comparable.

The French and Dutch were members of the Allies, with Charles de Gaulle as leader of the Free-French forces and Queen Wilhelmina the head of the Dutch government-in-exile, both in London. Both wanted the allies to get the Germans out of their countries.

There is no government-in-exile calling for the bombing of Iran as a method for liberation.

Just as Laos did not call for the US to drop some 2 million tons on that country - more than were dropped on Japan, Germany and Britain during World War II - resulting in the deaths of over 200,000 people, as part of the US's ineffective attempt to "liberate" North Vietnam.

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by bcrosby95 on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @12:03AM (#47685045)
I wouldn't personally do so, but arguably those tens of thousands rest at our feet considering the current government was political blowback from the US and UK regime changing Iran back in the '50s.

It's even less likely to work because Trump has already claimed, publicly, to arming the protestors. That already makes any regime change illegitimate. They're all foreign backed agitators.

I bring it up because this shit is messy.

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by stanfordkid on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @11:26PM (#47684722)
No one wants to liberate Iran. Israel just wants to continue committing genocide and apartheid without any opposition. Iran arms Hezbollah and Hamas, the main forms of Palestinian resistance. The whole point of this operation is to decimate those groups so ethnic cleansing can continue without any resistance. Israel could care less about the Irani people.

You are very naive if you think the IRGC truly killed 10's of thousands of it's own people. Israel openly talks about Mossad organizing and supporting the coup, and good old Donny has admitted they have given weapons to organized resistance.

I estimate that many of the death numbers come from armed resistance being killed by the IRGC, not ordinary peaceful protestors. I also think armed resistance killed many Irani citizens. There is obviously fog of war here. The thousands of deaths were likely inflated and obfuscated.

Look at the coups we have backed in the middle east (including formerly in Iran which is what originally led to the Islamic revolution) -- and you will see a pattern. Both US and Israel provide material support to groups like ISIS or actors like Bin Laden. An Al-Qaeda fighter is literally the head of Syria now thanks to Israel.

I don't love Hamas, IRGC or Hezbollah, I don't like their ideology. But it is myopic to think they exist in a vaccum.

[dead]
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by int_19h on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @11:24PM (#47684701)
> Accidents are common in war

That's precisely why you don't just start wars to show the world that your dick is still bigger than everybody else's.

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by sho_hn on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @10:59PM (#47684472)
> Accidents are common in war;

As an engineer a substantial amount of my professional effort is spent on preventing them. They aren't acceptable.

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by annexrichmond on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @11:03PM (#47684511)
Nobody is saying they are acceptable. But it'd be naive to say there's ever zero risk. What's your brilliant plan? Let Iran have nukes?
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by cogman10 on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @11:11PM (#47684577)
> Nobody is saying they are acceptable.

Saying "Accidents happen in war" is absolutely a way of saying "Accidents are acceptable in war".

That's what's being said here. Otherwise, it's a useless thing to say.

> What's your brilliant plan? Let Iran have nukes?

There was no evidence that Iran was pursuing nukes. Certainly no evidence that they were `n days` away from getting nukes.

My "brilliant" plan would have been the negotiations that were happening where Iran agreed to pretty strict monitoring and stipulations on nuclear fuel development.

The "Iran was getting nukes" rhetoric needs real evidence that was actually happening not "we think that might be happening because Trump said so."

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by alex_sf on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @11:21PM (#47684675)
> Saying "Accidents happen in war" is absolutely a way of saying "Accidents are acceptable in war".

Bridges fall down sometimes. I don't think it's acceptable. It's a statement of fact. There are always going to be mistakes, in every field and in pursuit of every goal. Your objection and implications aren't particularly charitable here.

> My "brilliant" plan would have been the negotiations that were happening where Iran agreed to pretty strict monitoring and stipulations on nuclear fuel development.

Iran was not complying with the monitoring requirements.

> The "Iran was getting nukes" rhetoric needs real evidence that was actually happening not "we think that might be happening because Trump said so."

Intelligence agencies under both Biden and Trump (and since at least the 90s) have repeatedly confirmed it.

This isn't really a question or doubt any reasonable person can have. There can be an argument about how close they are at any given moment, but they are actively pursuing nuclear weapons.

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by cogman10 on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @12:16AM (#47685155)
> Intelligence agencies under both Biden and Trump (and since at least the 90s) have repeatedly confirmed it.

Cite your source. When did this happen under Biden?

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by alex_sf on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @01:06AM (#47685522)
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by cogman10 on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @10:18AM (#47690598)
I disagree with your interpretation of these reports.

The ODNI report wasn't saying that Iran was perusing nuclear weapons, but rather that it was stockpiling weapons grade uranium. And, in particular, it calls out the reason they did this. Because the US withdrew from the JCPOA. It also called out the fact that Iran continued to say that they'd rejoin the JCPOA if the US was willing to.

Trump in the first term withdrew from our agreements, why should Iran have continued obeying the terms of an agreement that the US renegged on?

That's why I say they weren't pursuing nuclear weapons. They were stockpiling enriched uranium mostly because they were trying to use that as a negotiation tactic with the US.

But in negotiations with Trump both before the 12 day war and this time, they had agreed to re-enter the monitoring regime with the JCPOA and to completely destroy their stockpile, in return for lifted sanctions.

> Iran uses its nuclear program for negotiation leverage and to respond to perceived international pressure. During the past year, it has modulated its production and inventory of 60-percent uranium. Tehran has said it would restore JCPOA limits if the United States fulfilled its JCPOA commitments and the IAEA closed its outstanding safeguards investigations.

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by Invictus0 on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @11:12AM (#47691353)
I see in your bio that you work on cars. Surely you've heard of car accidents? Clearly we find them acceptable enough to keep driving, wouldn't you agree?
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by tdeck on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @11:27PM (#47684731)
These kinds of accidents seem to be particularly common in wars waged by Israel for some reason.
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @11:04PM (#47684522)
> Accidents are common in war

Sure. The point is this was a particularly tragic accident. And it happened for, from the looks of the ceasefire conditions, jack shit.

More pointedly: if it was an accident, it should be investigated. Honestly. Openly. Not only is it horrible, bombing children is a strategic blunder in a war for hearts and minds.

[dead]
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by sali0 on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @11:18PM (#47684640)
The school was bombed by US Tomahawk missiles, twice via a double tap so the medical personnel were killed too.

It's absolutely absurd to think this would be caused by a misfire from Iran.

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by hilbertseries on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @11:05PM (#47684530)
Investigation isn’t finished, but it was almost certainly the US. If it was Iran Trump or Hegeseth would not have been able to contain themselves.
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by stouset on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @11:50PM (#47684944)
The American commander in chief was, as of yesterday, vowing to end their entire civilization.
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by noosphr on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @11:56PM (#47684983)
Here's hoping. Executing lgbt folx is something we can all agree is the sign of a hateful fascist culture that needs to be destroyed.
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by KennyBlanken on Wednesday April 08, 2026 @12:10AM (#47685109)
Aside from the fact that the events you linked to have no connection whatsoever to why the US started attacking Iran, there is absolutely no reality or moral code in which "a government kills a couple hundred of its citizens" justifies another government on the other side of the world blowing up a hundred plus schoolchildren and other civilians.
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by mindslight on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @11:53PM (#47684970)
> Here's hoping the regime is destabilised enough to topple by itself.

It's looking like this is the exact type of magical thinking of the most useless "president" ever. Meanwhile in the real world, such things take hard work.

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by 8note on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @11:30PM (#47684761)
i dont imagine spending a bunch on the military and oil is nearly enough to topple the US government.

what case does it make that the constitution needs to be abandoned?

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by lern_too_spel on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @11:21PM (#47684666)
The counter argument is missing some justification. Is it reasonable to go killing people on the hope that something good will come out of it? Is there no less violent way to achieve those objectives? Do we really think that people will organize a toppling while they're being bombed without Internet access? Do we think they'll topple the current regime for one that is less antagonistic to Israel and the US after the bombings?
Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @10:53PM (#47684434)
> This is the counter argument

When the French helped us during the Revolutionary War, they didn't shore bombard the colonists' kids because it would have been bad and counterproductive.

Re:Trump announces two-week ceasefire as Iran says talks to ... by pphysch on Tuesday April 07, 2026 @11:42PM (#47684876)
This is black propaganda, not a counterargument.

At most there were a couple thousand casualties from violent riots that involved armed gangs (or sleeper cells if you want to go that route).

There were not "60,000" peaceful protestors executed by the government, as Trump claimed yesterday without evidence. That is murderous propaganda, blood libel intended to deflect from the actual mass murder of civilians by American forces e.g. the Minab school.

It was a narrative specifically designed to induce comments like yours.