News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I Quit Law School and Became a Programmer by rayiner on Friday November 09, 2012 @06:46PM (#4765278)
Interesting article, but frankly the idea of an "innovative legal system" is quite frightening. The whole point of the legal system is to be a predictable backdrop against which human activity can take place. I don't want to be able to predict what Silicon Valley will do 10 years from now. I do want to be able to predict what judges will do 10 years from now!

It's not a sign of decay when the legal system uses principles that are 200+ years old, it's a sign of the fact that the heart of the legal system, dispute resolution, involves the same issues today that it did hundreds of years ago.

Re:Why I Quit Law School and Became a Programmer by DannyBee on Friday November 09, 2012 @06:52PM (#4765302)
I wish i could upvote this a billion times.

I don't want to start getting daily plea deal offers from the prosecutor.

"First 50 defendants to sign up get 50% off their sentence!"

Re:Why I Quit Law School and Became a Programmer by GuiA on Friday November 09, 2012 @10:27PM (#4765814)
And yet, for some fines, pleading guilty will lower the amount by ~50% ($550->$350 for a traffic violation in the recent experience of an acquaintance of mine).
Re:Why I Quit Law School and Became a Programmer by tptacek on Saturday November 10, 2012 @05:24PM (#4767948)
Traffic violations are probably a bad example.

(1) Judging cases imposes huge administrative costs. Somebody has to pay those costs; if it isn't you, it's everybody else. Particularly with moving violations, where offenses are so widespread and the cost of admitting guilt is so low and where so many people have interface with the legal system, it makes sense to charge people who force costly adjudication that later proves pointless (which is what a discount for a guilty plea effectively does).

(2) The fines associated with most traffic violations are artificially low. Although any one person who speeds or runs a red light is unlikely in that one instance to grievously harm someone, people who drive carelessly as a cohort impose enormous costs on the rest of society, and those costs simply aren't priced into the $300 you pay for a 55-in-a-35 speeding ticket.

Re:Why I Quit Law School and Became a Programmer by aristidb on Friday November 09, 2012 @06:57PM (#4765324)
I think a legal system should very much be stable, but it should also be flexible enough not to prevent innovation elsewhere from happening.
Re:Why I Quit Law School and Became a Programmer by jacques_chester on Saturday November 10, 2012 @02:39AM (#4766193)
That is precisely how the Common Law system works.