News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The People's Bailout by tsotha on Thursday November 08, 2012 @11:36PM (#4761328)
>Except debt can be exactly due to some random accident like getting hit by a car while crossing the street and you don't have the insurance to pay for the medical bills.

That's why we have bankruptcy laws.

From what I heard at the time, the big hobby horse for the OWS people was student debt, which can't be forgiven in bankruptcy. And that kind of debt is entirely optional.

Re:The People's Bailout by sc68cal on Friday November 09, 2012 @12:29AM (#4761503)

    That's why we have bankruptcy laws.
Yes - bankruptcy laws that were passed in 2005 which made it significantly harder to get debt forgiven in bankruptcy, and also removed some forms of debt from being able to be discharged in bankruptcy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bankruptcy_Abuse_Prevention_an...

    It was widely claimed by advocates of BAPCPA that its 
    passage would reduce losses to creditors such as credit
    card companies, and that those creditors would then pass
    on the savings to other borrowers in the form of lower 
    interest rates. These claims turned out to be false.
    After BAPCPA passed, although credit card company 
    losses decreased, prices charged to customers 
    increased, and credit card company profits soared.
http://ssrn.com/abstract=1157158

    And that kind of debt is entirely optional.
Not when the majority of jobs that create a vibrant middle class in the post-industrial United States require at least a college degree.
Re:The People's Bailout by tsotha on Friday November 09, 2012 @01:10AM (#4761616)
>Not when the majority of jobs that create a vibrant middle class in the post-industrial United States require at least a college degree.

That's a self-refuting argument. If your degree was really the ticket to a "vibrant middle class" job you'd be able to pay off your student debt.

The reality is not all degrees are created equal, and people should think a little bit before they go $200k into debt for a degree that's going lead to a $40k job. Granted, 18 year olds aren't very good at this kind of reasoning, but that's what parents are for.

On top of that, for a lot of fields a degree from a public university is just as good as one from an Ivy. Nobody is entitled to a pricy private college education. Either you go on family money or you think very carefully about how those loans are going to get repaid.

Re:The People's Bailout by btilly on Friday November 09, 2012 @02:48AM (#4761822)
>Not when the majority of jobs that create a vibrant middle class in the post-industrial United States require at least a college degree.

That's a self-refuting argument. If your degree was really the ticket to a "vibrant middle class" job you'd be able to pay off your student debt.

You just failed at basic logic.

Saying that jobs of type X require a degree IS NOT saying that getting a degree guarantees that you will get a job of type X. As an example, a law degree is required to become a lawyer. But only something like 70% of people graduating with law degrees will pass the bar, and be put on a track to a job where they can reasonably expect to pay back their debts.

I also see that you are happy to blame the victim. Yet many victims are not to blame. Let me take a real example, my wife. She got an MD. She went into residency. She got injured, had to take time off then leave residency. She is in another residency now. She still does not make enough to contribute towards her debts, I've been doing it instead.

She did nothing wrong. Yes, the degree was expensive, but an MD is generally a worthwhile investment. Yes, she got injured. But that was not her fault. There are no guarantees in life. Bad luck will happen to a certain fraction of people. It happened to her.

Now you have a lot to say about planning. Well back when she took on that debt, bankruptcy could discharge it. It was not until after she had the MD that the rules changed on her. Thanks to me, she's not in trouble. But when she took on the debt, the bank agreed to one set of risks, and then Congress changed the terms of the contract out from under her later. In what world is it fair that you sign one thing, and then because the right politicians got bribed, you're bound to a different thing?

Re:The People's Bailout by tsotha on Friday November 09, 2012 @04:00AM (#4761975)
>Saying that jobs of type X require a degree IS NOT saying that getting a degree guarantees that you will get a job of type X.

No, but he was talking about the majority of jobs. I understand people get unlucky. That's life. But there's a huge disconnect between what the population of college students is paying for degrees and what the job market is paying for labor. This isn't a question of some small percentage of people getting unlucky. It's a fundamental overestimation of the value of what they're buying.

>I also see that you are happy to blame the victim.

People who make dumb decisions are not victims. Like I said, not everyone is in that position because they made a dumb decision. But most of them are.

Re:The People's Bailout by btilly on Friday November 09, 2012 @01:31PM (#4764072)
No, but he was talking about the majority of jobs.

You're making the exact same logic error, but this time talking about majorities, so in addition to failing at logic you're failing at statistics.

Let me point you again at the law student example. All jobs as a lawyer require law school. About 70% of people who get law degrees will successfully pass the bar, and get a high paying job they otherwise couldn't and be able to pay their debts. About 30% will fail to pass a bar, and be put on that track, with the result that their best available jobs are much lower paying and they are hosed.

Did that 30% make a bad decision to go to law school? If so, then so did a lot of the other 70%, because it is not obvious going in who will and won't succeed. Most of the time, law school is a good choice. Some of the time it is a terrible choice.

Complicating the issue even farther, very few people going into law school are aware of how high the odds are of getting into serious debt problems. Until recently there was little public awareness of it, and marketing materials from law schools certainly make no mention of the issue.

(I'm pulling up this particular example because unsuccessful law graduates make up a high portion of seriously distressed student debt, and there have been lawsuits about false advertising around this issue.)

Re:The People's Bailout by tsotha on Friday November 09, 2012 @02:08PM (#4764259)
>You're making the exact same logic error, but this time talking about majorities, so in addition to failing at logic you're failing at statistics.

One of us is being stupid, but I don't think it's me.

The assertion is college is necessary for a middle class lifestyle. What I'm saying is 1) it's not and 2) when you add up lost opportunity costs, direct costs, and interest on student debt many people (maybe even most) are losing money by going to college. Now, that's their choice, but I don't want to be on the hook for someone else's personal enrichment.

>Did that 30% make a bad decision to go to law school?

Yes. Anyone who goes to law school right now is an idiot, unless that law school is Harvard or Yale. The 70% in your example are either lucky or have been shunted into jobs that don't require a law degree or they're working as lawyers and making less than they would have made teaching Social Studies to the local second graders. The number of newly minted lawyers far, far exceeds the number of jobs for newly minted lawyers.

The exception, of course, being people who got in to the very, very top schools.

Re:The People's Bailout by btilly on Friday November 09, 2012 @03:44PM (#4764659)
One of us is being stupid, but I don't think it's me.

You also have proven unable to parse English.

The assertion is college is necessary for a middle class lifestyle.

Your continued inability to parse English is getting old. Here, for the record, is the original assertion.

Not when the majority of jobs that create a vibrant middle class in the post-industrial United States require at least a college degree.

Now why do I say that you failed to parse this correctly? Because "majority" does not mean "all". So the majority these jobs could require a college degree but there could still be lots of them that don't require a college degree.

Going back to what you wrote...

Yes. Anyone who goes to law school right now is an idiot, unless that law school is Harvard or Yale. The 70% in your example are either lucky or have been shunted into jobs that don't require a law degree or they're working as lawyers and making less than they would have made teaching Social Studies to the local second graders. The number of newly minted lawyers far, far exceeds the number of jobs for newly minted lawyers.

Can you cite a source?

According to what I can find now, until 2009, law school had a fairly stable economic outlook. Then the bottom dropped out. Median starting income for newly graduated lawyers has dropped 35% since then. (See http://www.nalp.org/classof2011_salpressrel for a source.)

However stop and think for a second. Law school takes 3 years. People graduating this year into the dismal market entered in 2009, with decades of history of law being a good economic choice. The lifetime income for someone with a law degree averaged DOUBLE the lifetime income for someone with a bachelor's degree. In retrospect, the law degree was likely a mistake. But when they committed to it, based on the data that then existed, it looked like a good choice.

So, were all of the people who are walking around with useless newly minted law degrees demonstrating poor decision making abilities when they chose to do that? I don't really think so. They didn't spot the oncoming macro-economic train, but these things tend to be much clearer in hindsight than in advance. (I knew about the oncoming problem, but only because my brother was selling stuff to lawyers, and he told me how the financial crisis was impacting law firms.)

Re:The People's Bailout by tsotha on Friday November 09, 2012 @04:20PM (#4764792)
I give up. Instead of reading what I write you keep building straw men out of cherry picked sentences and then slap them down. It must be easier to "win" an argument that way, but you're just wasting my time and that of everyone else who reads what you write.
Re:The People's Bailout by eli_gottlieb on Friday November 09, 2012 @08:11AM (#4762593)
Dumb decisions like becoming a medical doctor? This isn't a matter of what decision someone's wife made. You just like blaming the victim by default and forcing them to defend themselves before your imagined seat of justice.
Re:The People's Bailout by tsotha on Friday November 09, 2012 @01:21PM (#4764029)
Try to read every sentence.
Re:The People's Bailout by sc68cal on Friday November 09, 2012 @01:35AM (#4761679)
I believe that the vast majority of student debt is not people going to an Ivy institution. The major concentration of serious debt issues has been in the private-education-as-big-business sector from companies like University of Phoneix and DeVry, whose business models depend on government backed student loans, or loans from private companies that are subsidized/guaranteed by the government (before President Obama signed a law that allowed the government to manage student loans without requiring a private company to act as an intermediary).

http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2011/09/gi-bill-for-prof...

"Last winter, the Department of Veterans Affairs tasked its newly hired blogger, a cantankerous Iraq vet named Alex Horton, with investigating the website GIBill.com, one of many official-looking links that come up when you Google terms like "GI Bill schools." With names like ArmedForcesEDU.com and UseYourGIBill.us, these sites purport to inform military veterans how to best use their education benefits. In reality, Horton found, they're run by marketing firms hired by for-profit colleges to extol the virtues of high-priced online or evening courses. He concluded that GIBill.com "serves little purpose other than to funnel student veterans and convince them their options for education are limited to their advertisers."

http://www.motherjones.com/media/2012/08/explosive-growth-pr...

"The for-profit higher education industry was the target of a bruising report issued last week. Based on a two-year effort, the report detailed high rates of loan default, aggressive recruiting, higher than average tuition, low retention rates, and little job placement assistance. It was spearheaded by Sen. Tom Harkin, D-Iowa, a longtime critic of the industry. (ProPublica has written a number of pieces looking more closely at the explosive growth sector, including questionable recruiting and marketing.)"

And finally -

http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2009/11/university-phoen...

"After federal regulators accused the University of Phoenix of systematic enrollment abuses in 2004, the school's parent company paid out nearly $10 million to resolve the allegations.

Phoenix allegedly had broken the law by tying recruiters' pay to enrollment numbers, U.S. Department of Education investigators found, creating pressure to sign up unqualified students.

In the years since, Phoenix cemented its stature as the nation's largest for-profit school and the single biggest recipient of federal student aid. But some of the school's recruiters have continued to use high-pressure, deceptive tactics, according to a dozen current and former students and two former recruiters who spoke to ProPublica and Marketplace as part of a joint investigation."

Re:The People's Bailout by tsotha on Friday November 09, 2012 @04:05AM (#4761984)
>I believe that the vast majority of student debt is not people going to an Ivy institution.

The difference is nobody goes into $200k debt studying at the University of Phoenix, whereas people who go to lower tier Ivies on student loans and get less marketable degrees have literally sold themselves into debt slavery.

Re:The People's Bailout by tilgovi on Friday November 09, 2012 @03:03PM (#4764502)
Except you're the one who brought up $200k as a number to begin with. And those people who sold themselves into debt slavery, by going to an extremely good school, may actually still hold jobs that will allow them to repay their loans eventually. Ignoring your arbitrary choice of debt number, we're looking at many people in debt and many of them without any college degree whatsoever.

And talking about parents isn't helpful. Parents are the ones watching the State of the Union address where the President talks about higher education and competing with China and then go out in the town and talk to the other parents about where their children are going to college and what their children are doing with their degrees. Thinking that only 18-year-olds can be fooled into saddling themselves with excessive debt is nonsense.

Re:The People's Bailout by tsotha on Friday November 09, 2012 @03:37PM (#4764634)
>Except you're the one who brought up $200k as a number to begin with.

Yes.

>And those people who sold themselves into debt slavery, by going to an extremely good school, may actually still hold jobs that will allow them to repay their loans eventually.

Well then, there's no problem, is there?

>Thinking that only 18-year-olds can be fooled into saddling themselves with excessive debt is nonsense.

At some point people have to think for themselves.

Re:The People's Bailout by zanny on Friday November 09, 2012 @03:11AM (#4761870)
> 18 year olds aren't very good at this kind of reasoning, but that's what parents are for.

It is a dangerous assumption to think it is the place for a parent to judge if their children should incur the equivalent of half a decades debt when they themselves may have no comprehension of the value of a degree their kid is thinking of.

Re:The People's Bailout by tsotha on Friday November 09, 2012 @04:11AM (#4761993)
I'm not sure what you mean by "half a decades debt".

At some point people have to be treated as adults. If your parents aren't up to advising you on financial matters you have to get outside help. Or you figure it out yourself.

I refuse to accept the notion we should alter agreements freely entered into by adults in an effort to protect them from themselves.

Re:The People's Bailout by zanny on Friday November 09, 2012 @09:12AM (#4762837)
I don't think so either, I just don't think its an excuse to say colleges and universities (especially since they are all federally funded) can practice extremely predatory financing expecting a kids parents to know better for them.

I agree you should not alter open agreements, but those agreements are already biased by federal dollars in the form of guaranteed stafford loans. We need to get rid of federal loan and grant guarantees that are not merit based limited funding that happens after acceptance (so that schools can't focus target anyone getting a federal scholarship).

Re:The People's Bailout by tsotha on Friday November 09, 2012 @02:17PM (#4764301)
I would get rid of GSLs. I would go further, too, and make the current financing process illegal.

Imagine if you went to the local car dealer and he told you "Every car on the lot is $200k. But give me a detailed listing of your assets and income and I'll adjust the price such that you can barely afford to buy one if you take out as much financing as possible."

That kind of price discrimination is illegal for your local car dealer, but it's exactly what happens when your kid goes off to college. Not only that, colleges collude so that you can't play one college off against another.

Of course what they say is they're just making sure they have a "diverse" student body by cutting the less well off students a deal. But the net effect is the college takes in the maximum amount of money in tuition.

It's the biggest driver of ever-rising tuition, and were I in Congress I'd go on the freakin' warpath against this industry.

Re:The People's Bailout by tilgovi on Friday November 09, 2012 @03:05PM (#4764511)
Here you are talking sense.
Re:The People's Bailout by mamoswined on Friday November 09, 2012 @06:04PM (#4765147)
It's threads like this that make me thank my parents, who prevented me, at the age society didn't even trust me with a beer, from signing on to most than a decades worth of debt in order to go to a trendy school.
Re:The People's Bailout by smsm42 on Friday November 09, 2012 @01:52AM (#4761721)
Many jobs require a degree, but not every degree leads to a job. Unfortunately, easy access to huge loans and widespread confusion about the relationship between the degree and the paying jobs has lead to ever increasing number of people in huge debts with no way to repay it ever. It reminds me some recent history when people got into huge debt in order to get something that is sure to provide them huge value and make them rich - and then it turned out not to be so. We're heading into it again, full steam.
Re:The People's Bailout by eli_gottlieb on Friday November 09, 2012 @08:13AM (#4762602)
The problem is that not getting a university degree still makes you far more likely to end up poor. So people are still making the "rational" investment, which is to take a 40% chance of a good job over a 10% chance (numbers pulled from my ass, but you get the point).
Re:The People's Bailout by smsm42 on Friday November 09, 2012 @02:03PM (#4764229)
Correlation != casuation. Degree in feminist basket weaving is not going to make you rich (unless you land a sinecure job in some Diversity Office, but these are severely limited in number) or even richer. It is almost guaranteed to make you significantly poorer unless you get some deal to get it for free. That's the part of the confusion - the fact that average college graduate now in his 40ies makes more than average non-graduate in his 40ies, does not mean getting into 100K debt would actually work out for you as a current college student.

It's like saying "stock market returns 8% annually long term, so I'll put all my life saving into Shady Gadgets Inc. that was touted to me by some guy I don't know on the phone". That's not how rational investment is made.

Re:The People's Bailout by tsotha on Friday November 09, 2012 @02:21PM (#4764322)
>Correlation != casuation.

This. It's not at all clear people make more money as a result of college or if people who are generally more likely to make more money are also more likely to go to college. There are certainly some very famously high earning college dropouts.

Re:The People's Bailout by bobwaycott on Friday November 09, 2012 @12:31AM (#4761511)
While I'm not entirely disagreeing with your point, there is an element of dubious optionality wrt student debt when one systemically cannot find gainful employment without a college degree. College degrees are increasingly becoming the new high school diplomas—wherein they are, for all intents and purposes, of equal compulsory nature, without the defense of laws requiring all 18-21-year-olds to be there. Thus, for vast majorities of the population who wish to lead productive economic lives, the "option" isn't quite optional anymore.
Re:The People's Bailout by greedo on Friday November 09, 2012 @09:24AM (#4762888)
The problem isn't that people are pursuing degrees, it's that some are pursuing economically unviable degrees. Here's a little anectdata from a friend. His daughter is in debt $60k for a degree in theater. Did well in college, but wants to "make it" in NYC.

Now obviously the theater industry is very competitive, especially in NYC. So while trying to do various theatrical activities to get her foot in the door, she's a dog walker. She doesn't make much money, so she's qualifying for assistance.

She could move back home, get a job in a different field (her dad has lined up several paying jobs), but she wants to stay in NYC. She's unable to make any payments on her loans, so those are going to build up quickly.

This is what drives fiscal conservatives crazy. And when groups are asking for student loan debt forgiveness/bailout, it's doubly frustrating. She's making multiple choices that are fiscally imprudent, and expecting to be subsidized both in assistance and loan forgiveness.

TLDR, basketweaving degrees aren't worth going into debt for, but an entitled generation wants to "pursue their dreams" on someone else's dime.

Re:The People's Bailout by bobwaycott on Friday November 09, 2012 @03:23PM (#4764587)
I really think you need to get your biases in check. Pursuing one's dreams is exactly what the last couple generations have been raised to do. They didn't exit the womb feeling entitled. They were told since near birth they could be whatever they wanted to be. They were told they needed to go to college. They did exactly as they were told and wound up with little to show for it and an overwhelmingly difficult job market. They have been following the cultural narrative.

Now, they're thinking, "What the fuck?" and society is acting like it didn't push them headlong into this. By the time they've realized the narrative failed them, it's too late.

Re:The People's Bailout by greedo on Friday November 09, 2012 @03:40PM (#4764647)
I agree 100% with your reply, but I guess I've got a blind spot about my biases. In the case of my friend's daughter, she's aware of her options, realizes that she's not making any progress towards her dreams, but refuses to acknowledge the failed narrative. If she was thinking "WTF?" she'd be moving on and not dogwalking...
Re:The People's Bailout by bobwaycott on Friday November 09, 2012 @03:59PM (#4764722)
Again, biases. You might be thinking, "WTF?" and rapidly moving on. That doesn't extend to people generally. The stronger a narrative, the longer people tend to hit their face against the brick walls of failure, believing the part of the narrative that's been telling them if they work and try hard enough for long enough, their dreams will become reality.

I'm obviously just commentating from the outside, but are you sure she is aware of her options in the same way you feel you are? What exactly are the options of someone who is trying to pursue her dreams? Do you step in and crush them, telling her it's time to give up and get practical? She'll be bombarded with anecdotes from the narrative that tell her to never give up. It's all-consuming. That's what cultural narratives do.

The narrative tells people to become self-actualized. The economic realities of a capitalist marketplace don't really have much room for that. The narrative has placed her in the disheartening place of having followed it and wound up unable to realize her dreams. That can be a very difficult place to move on from.

Re:The People's Bailout by greedo on Friday November 09, 2012 @04:45PM (#4764862)
Agreed. I do have far more experience with moving on. I've pursued two different "dream" careers, and am now in a third that seems to be the best fit for me.

She seems disheartened by her lack of success in the last five years, but I know from personal experience that it's hard to change direction without a huge outside catalyst.

I don't think it's necessarily wrong to encourage people to follow their dreams, but I think that society in general and parents specifically should do a better job of raising kids with the ability to critically evaluate themselves. Parents are often blind to the flaws of their children (at least I am), and the business world loves to encourage the idea of following your dreams. Expecting teenagers to have this self-awareness isn't realistic though; some do, but the majority need to skin their knees a bit. Parents need to help with this.

It's a tough nut to crack; we glamorize sports and celebrity when the chances of succeeding in those arenas are miniscule. We celebrate working with our minds and denigrate those who work with their hands.

Re:The People's Bailout by mkr-hn on Friday November 09, 2012 @10:28AM (#4763202)
Anecdotes do not prove the existence of an entitled generation. I have plenty of contrary anecdotes, and they would mean as much.
Re:The People's Bailout by tsotha on Friday November 09, 2012 @04:15AM (#4762001)
I disagree. There are all kinds of things you can do that don't require a college degree, including any kind of owner-operated business, a military career, or a skilled trade.

Even today only 40% of the population gets a college degree. That other 60% is doing something to make ends meet.

Re:The People's Bailout by bobwaycott on Friday November 09, 2012 @06:52AM (#4762355)
I think you miss the point. Systemically, exiting high school and entering college is the narrative. It is the path students are being presented as the way forward, not an option forward. Culturally, there is a very strong set of expectations placed on people wrt university education, and this narrative determines people's recognized option paths. There are strong social determinants in place, both positive and negative, to which people react and from which they draw their conclusions--even unknowingly.

Student debt has risen in tandem with the codification of the narrative. An entire industry of loan operations has exploited the inexperienced eighteen-year-olds of the last few decades, saddling them with lifelong debt in the pursuit of the supposed "dream" the American narrative has been selling them their whole lives.

Suffice to say, when one talks about options available to people, one should talk deeply of the real viability and potentiality of those options on a person and his/her life, and refrain from rattling off platitudes of the things someone could do other than follow the narrative. Those things typically aren't qualitatively better, and usually wind up being part of the greater narrative as how we ease our consciences and wash our hands of people we allow to systemically fail.

Re:The People's Bailout by greedo on Friday November 09, 2012 @09:27AM (#4762901)
Then we need to change this narrative, because it doesn't fit the real requirements of the job world. Trade schools, apprentice programs etc are common all over the world, but not as well accepted in the US.

You know who I envy? The electrician who came out last week to install a whole home surge protector. He makes excellent money, in a relatively safe work environment, and has reasonable hours. There's a whole world of "skilled" trades that offer gainful employment without a four year degree, but as a society focused on bling, we don't give those careers our blessings.

Re:The People's Bailout by bobwaycott on Friday November 09, 2012 @03:26PM (#4764602)
> Then we need to change this narrative, because it doesn't fit the real requirements of the job world.

Exactly this.

Re:The People's Bailout by tsotha on Friday November 09, 2012 @06:41PM (#4765254)
>You know who I envy? The electrician who came out last week to install a whole home surge protector. He makes excellent money, in a relatively safe work environment, and has reasonable hours.

Not only that, nobody's going to send his job to China.