Re:The People's Bailout
by smsm42 on Friday November 09, 2012 @01:52AM
(#4761721)
Many jobs require a degree, but not every degree leads to a job. Unfortunately, easy access to huge loans and widespread confusion about the relationship between the degree and the paying jobs has lead to ever increasing number of people in huge debts with no way to repay it ever. It reminds me some recent history when people got into huge debt in order to get something that is sure to provide them huge value and make them rich - and then it turned out not to be so. We're heading into it again, full steam.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The People's Bailout
by eli_gottlieb on Friday November 09, 2012 @08:13AM
(#4762602)
The problem is that not getting a university degree still makes you far more likely to end up poor. So people are still making the "rational" investment, which is to take a 40% chance of a good job over a 10% chance (numbers pulled from my ass, but you get the point).
Correlation != casuation. Degree in feminist basket weaving is not going to make you rich (unless you land a sinecure job in some Diversity Office, but these are severely limited in number) or even richer. It is almost guaranteed to make you significantly poorer unless you get some deal to get it for free. That's the part of the confusion - the fact that average college graduate now in his 40ies makes more than average non-graduate in his 40ies, does not mean getting into 100K debt would actually work out for you as a current college student.
It's like saying "stock market returns 8% annually long term, so I'll put all my life saving into Shady Gadgets Inc. that was touted to me by some guy I don't know on the phone". That's not how rational investment is made.
>Correlation != casuation.
This. It's not at all clear people make more money as a result of college or if people who are generally more likely to make more money are also more likely to go to college. There are certainly some very famously high earning college dropouts.