News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Patches Allow Building Linux IPv6-Only, Option to Dep... by jrm4 on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @12:02PM (#47602665)
Great question and my gut is that it makes it that much easier for large, perhaps corporate interests to gain surveillance and control. I'm aware it's possible now, but it really feels like there's some safety in the friction of the possibility that my home devices just switch up IP addresses once in a while.

Like, wouldn't e.g. IPv6 theoretically make "ISP's charging per device in your home" easier, if only a little bit? I know they COULD just do MAC addresses, but still.

Re:New Patches Allow Building Linux IPv6-Only, Option to Dep... by craftkiller on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @12:40PM (#47603246)
You can't correlate the number of addresses with the number of devices because IPv6 temporary addresses exist. If you enable temporary addresses, your computer will periodically randomly generate a new address and switch to it.

https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc8981.html

Re:New Patches Allow Building Linux IPv6-Only, Option to Dep... by jrm4 on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @12:59PM (#47603500)
"If you enable" is doing ALL THE HEAVY LIFTING THERE.

Again, my point isn't about what is possible, but what is likely. -- which is MUCH MORE IMPORTANT for the real world.

If we'd started out in an IPv6 world, the defaults would have been "easy to discover unique addresses" and it's reasonable to think that would have made "pay per device" or other negatives that much easier.

Re:New Patches Allow Building Linux IPv6-Only, Option to Dep... by craftkiller on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @01:23PM (#47603815)
Temporary addresses are enabled by default in OSX, windows, android, and iOS. That's what, like 95% of the consumer non-server market? As for Linux, that's going to be up to each distro to decide what their defaults are. It looks like they are _not_ the default on FreeBSD, which makes sense because that OS is primarily targeting servers (even though I use it on my laptop).
Re:New Patches Allow Building Linux IPv6-Only, Option to Dep... by zekica on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @02:25PM (#47604628)
Temporary addresses are used by any Linux distro using NetworkManager (all desktop ones). For server distros, it can differ.
Re:New Patches Allow Building Linux IPv6-Only, Option to Dep... by Levitating on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @03:03PM (#47605070)
In Gnome it's just a toggle in the network settings
Re:New Patches Allow Building Linux IPv6-Only, Option to Dep... by electronsoup on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @01:45PM (#47604111)
and most OS do enable it by default
Re:New Patches Allow Building Linux IPv6-Only, Option to Dep... by password4321 on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @05:02PM (#47606530)
> ALL THE HEAVY LIFTING THERE

> MUCH MORE IMPORTANT

I haven't done the exhaustive research but props in advance for being the only person shouting in caps on HN. Definitely one way to proclaim one's not AI-ness without forced spelling errors.

Re:New Patches Allow Building Linux IPv6-Only, Option to Dep... by jrm4 on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @07:41PM (#47608122)
Didn't even think about that. Interesting.
Re:New Patches Allow Building Linux IPv6-Only, Option to Dep... by saltcured on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @01:12PM (#47603671)
I feel like this is a silly narrowing of the problem for normal, retail users. My priority isn't masking "the number of addresses" or devices. My desire is to not have a persistent identifier to correlate all my traffic. The whole idea of temporary addresses fails at this because the network prefix becomes the correlation ID.

I'm not an IPv4 apologist though. Clearly the NAT/DHCP assignments from the ISP are essentially the same risk, with just one shallow layer of pseudo-obscurity. I'd rather have IPv6 and remind myself that my traffic is tagged with my customer ID, one way or another.

Unfortunately, I see no real hope that this will ever be mitigated. Incentives are not aligned for any ISP to actually help mask customer traffic. It seems that onion routing (i.e. Tor) is the best anyone has come up with, and I suspect that in today's world, this has become a net liability for a mundane, privacy-conscious user.

Re:New Patches Allow Building Linux IPv6-Only, Option to Dep... by ronsor on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @02:40PM (#47604799)
> The whole idea of temporary addresses fails at this because the network prefix becomes the correlation ID.

So the same as the public IPv4 on a traditional home NAT setup?

Re:New Patches Allow Building Linux IPv6-Only, Option to Dep... by graemep on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @02:44PM (#47604839)
Most home users do not have a static public IPv4 address - they have a single address that changes over time.
Re:New Patches Allow Building Linux IPv6-Only, Option to Dep... by db48x on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @04:09PM (#47605901)
But most ISPs aren’t giving out static IPv6 prefixes either. Instead they are collecting logs of what addresses they’ve handed out to which customer and holding on to them for years and years in case a court requests them. Tracking visitors doesn’t need to use ip addresses simply because it’s trivial to do so with cookies or browser fingerprinting. There’s exactly zero privacy either way.
Re:New Patches Allow Building Linux IPv6-Only, Option to Dep... by graemep on Thursday April 02, 2026 @04:53AM (#47611747)
> Instead they are collecting logs of what addresses they’ve handed out to which customer and holding on to them for years and years in case a court requests them.

They are only supposed to hang on to them for a limited time according to the law where I live (six months AFAIK). Courts are also unwilling to accept IPv4 addresses as proof of identity.

> Tracking visitors doesn’t need to use ip addresses simply because it’s trivial to do so with cookies or browser fingerprinting

Cookies can be deleted. Browser fingerprinting can be made unreliable.

Its not zero privacy either way. Privacy is not a binary. Giving out more information reduces your privacy.

Re:New Patches Allow Building Linux IPv6-Only, Option to Dep... by throw0101c on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @05:49PM (#47606959)
> Most home users do not have a static public IPv4 address - they have a single address that changes over time.

I'd be curious to know the statistics on this: I would hazard to guess that for most ISPs, if your router/modem does not reboot, your IPv4 address (and IPv6 prefix) will not change.

Re:New Patches Allow Building Linux IPv6-Only, Option to Dep... by jrm4 on Friday April 03, 2026 @11:54AM (#47628247)
Anecdatally, no. I had to yell at my ISP because mine changed AND I PAY FOR A STATIC ADDRESS.
Re:New Patches Allow Building Linux IPv6-Only, Option to Dep... by throw0101c on Wednesday April 01, 2026 @05:46PM (#47606940)
> My desire is to not have a persistent identifier to correlate all my traffic.

Reboot your router. Asus (with the vendor firmware) allows you do this in a scheduled manner. You'll get a new IPv4 WAN IP (for your NAT stuff) and (with most ISPs) a new IPV6 prefix.

As it stands, if you think NAT hides an individual device, you may have a false sense of security (PDF):

* https://oasis.library.unlv.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1...