News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Overestimation of microplastics potentially caused by sci... by idiotsecant on Sunday March 29, 2026 @10:54AM (#47563689)
Luckily HN software developers, the foremost authority on literally every subject imaginable, are here to bless the world with their insights.
Re:Overestimation of microplastics potentially caused by sci... by bonoboTP on Sunday March 29, 2026 @11:13AM (#47563862)
I think there's an important distinction of smug better-knowing instances.

"I have unique insight as a non-expert that all experts miss and the entire field is blind to" -> usually nonsense

"I think in this specific instance academically qualified people are missing something that's obvious to me" -> often true.

Re:Overestimation of microplastics potentially caused by sci... by timr on Sunday March 29, 2026 @11:15AM (#47563875)
There’s also the possibility that some of us actually, you know…have subject-matter expertise.
Re:Overestimation of microplastics potentially caused by sci... by refulgentis on Sunday March 29, 2026 @11:42AM (#47564122)
Doubtful, in your case, no?

"Nanomolar" is a dissolved-species concentration unit. It doesn't apply to spectroscopic particle counting.

Re:Overestimation of microplastics potentially caused by sci... by timr on Sunday March 29, 2026 @12:35PM (#47564675)
Uh, yeah. I know what the word means. See my response to the other comment where you say the same thing.
Re:Overestimation of microplastics potentially caused by sci... by Der_Einzige on Sunday March 29, 2026 @12:02PM (#47564319)
You joke, but given that SWE/AI researchers literally invented AI that does everything else for them and is often super-human at intelligence across most things, I would unironically prefer the opinion of the creator of such a system over most others for most things.
Re:Overestimation of microplastics potentially caused by sci... by hnlmorg on Sunday March 29, 2026 @12:23PM (#47564546)
I cooked a steak yesterday therefore I am an expert in biology.

Creating a user interface for the world’s knowledge doesn’t make the developer an expert on the knowledge that the interface holds in its database. Regardless of how sophisticated that interface might be.

Re:Overestimation of microplastics potentially caused by sci... by kelseyfrog on Sunday March 29, 2026 @12:43PM (#47564765)
'I disagree, therefore I am an expert in skepticism.' The sword cuts both ways.
Re:Overestimation of microplastics potentially caused by sci... by hnlmorg on Sunday March 29, 2026 @04:51PM (#47567180)
No it doesn’t. What you’re describing is an oxymoron.
Re:Overestimation of microplastics potentially caused by sci... by kelseyfrog on Sunday March 29, 2026 @07:45PM (#47568686)
Please. You don't get special treatment for being a skeptic. Either you have the credentials or you don't. Prove you're qualified.
Re:Overestimation of microplastics potentially caused by sci... by hnlmorg on Monday March 30, 2026 @03:31AM (#47571475)
You don’t need to be qualified to be unsure about something. Being unsure is a healthy position because it’s an acknowledgment that you don’t know something entirely. Which can also means you have an open mind to learn more about that subject.

Being certain, on the other hand, requires an assumption that you are a subject expert.

But this is all moot anyway because you’re constructing an elaborate strawman here. The original point was that the GP (possibly you?) trusts SWE more than others because they built AI. And I said building databases doesn’t make you smart at the subject loaded into the database.

Really, this whole premise of SWEs assuming expertise on subjects they’ve trained AI on says more about the Dunning-Kruger effect than anything of value in our little tangent.

Re:Overestimation of microplastics potentially caused by sci... by kelseyfrog on Monday March 30, 2026 @08:06PM (#47581208)
You can be skeptical in wrong ways. See solipsism for example.

Typically when I get genuine responses to the question, "What would change your mind?" it's an incredibly high bar that is practically impossible to achieve. That's not necessarily a bad thing, but when skepticism is applied without deliberation, it supports biases rather than truth.

So yes, you do need to be qualified to be skeptical, SWEs doubly so.

Re:Overestimation of microplastics potentially caused by sci... by queenkjuul on Sunday March 29, 2026 @08:28PM (#47568993)
You'd trust a programmer to be your doctor? Or design the structure of your house?
Re:Overestimation of microplastics potentially caused by sci... by idiotsecant on Sunday March 29, 2026 @11:01PM (#47569944)
Oh wow I've never seen such a prime specimen in the wild. I feel like you be pinned to a piece of cardboard in a drawer somewhere.
Re:Overestimation of microplastics potentially caused by sci... by refulgentis on Sunday March 29, 2026 @11:23AM (#47563933)
Spiritual equivalent of a life sciences forum discovering memory safety, one person who wrote code for a bit saying they wrote a memory bug in C once, then someone clutching pearls about why all programmers irresponsibly write memory unsafe code given it has a global impact.

Been here 16 years, it's always an adventure seeing whether stuff like this falls into:

A) Polite interest that doesn't turn into self-keyword-association

B) Science journalism bad

C) Can you believe no one else knows what they're doing.

(A) almost never happens, has to avoid being top 10 on front page and/or be early morning/late night for North America and Europe. (i.e. most of the audience)

(B) is reserved for physics and math.

(C) is default leftover.

Weekends are horrible because you'll get a "harshin' the vibe" penalty if you push back at all. People will pick at your link but not the main one and treat you like you're argumentative. (i.e. 'you're taking things too seriously' but a thoughtful person's version)

Re:Overestimation of microplastics potentially caused by sci... by david-gpu on Sunday March 29, 2026 @11:53AM (#47564236)
> Spiritual equivalent of a life sciences forum discovering memory safety, one person who wrote code for a bit saying they wrote a memory bug in C once, then someone clutching pearls about why programmers irresponsibly write memory unsafe code given it has a global impact.

I used to be a code monkey, I wrote systems software at megacorps, and still can't understand why so many programmers irresponsibly write memory unsafe code given it has a global impact.

So Poe's law applies here.

Re:Overestimation of microplastics potentially caused by sci... by refulgentis on Sunday March 29, 2026 @11:56AM (#47564263)
That's the analogy working as intended: the answer to "why do programmers still write memory-unsafe code" is the same shape as "why do microplastics researchers still wear gloves." The real answer is boring and full of tradeoffs. The HN thread version skips to indignation: "they never thought of contamination so ipso facto all the research is suspect"

(to go a bit further, in case it's confusing: both you and I agree on "why do people opt-in to memunsafe code in 2026? There’s no reason to" - yet, we also understand why Linux/Android/Windows/macOS/ffmpeg/ls aren't 100% $INSERT_MEM_SAFE_LANGUAGE yet, and in fact, most new written for them is memunsafe)

Re:Overestimation of microplastics potentially caused by sci... by peyton on Sunday March 29, 2026 @03:12PM (#47566195)
You’re ignoring the article to grind your axe.
Re:Overestimation of microplastics potentially caused by sci... by refulgentis on Sunday March 29, 2026 @06:18PM (#47567993)
What do you mean? (Genuinely seems you replied to wrong comment to me. What axe? What’s in the article that’s been ignored?)
Re:Overestimation of microplastics potentially caused by sci... by nineteen999 on Monday March 30, 2026 @10:44AM (#47575023)
They may have meant .exe
Re:Overestimation of microplastics potentially caused by sci... by david-gpu on Sunday March 29, 2026 @08:48PM (#47569144)
Thank you for helping me understand. I get it now.