News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by inaros on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @12:40PM (#47505424)
Hopefully some commercial professional pilots will comment on this thread, but if you go to sites where they normally hang out like:

https://www.airlinepilotforums.com

You will see many are terrified ( in commercial pilot terms...) of flying into La Guardia or JFK...

Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by rglover on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @01:10PM (#47505918)
> https://www.airlinepilotforums.com/major/152572-aircraft-fir...

Just a quick read/speculation based on the linked forum post...

Short of insane visibility conditions that prevented them from seeing the plane coming, the firetruck operator seems to be the liable party (beyond the airport for understaffing controllers—this seems to be exacerbated by government cuts but that's still no excuse for having a solo controller at that busy of an airport, especially at night).

The controller in question seems to have caught their mistake quickly and reversed the order instead asking the firetruck to stop (but for some reason, this wasn't heard).

Is it common now to have solo operators running control towers?

Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by wk_end on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @01:38PM (#47506372)
"Liability" isn't really how we try to see things in aviation. While it's true that it's ultimately considered the responsibility of the truck/plane to visually confirm that crossing the runway is safe, refuse unsafe commands from ATC, and comply to the best of their ability when ATC says "stop" at the last second, we can't stop our analysis there if we want to prevent this from happening in the future, because unless things change someone will make this mistake again in the future. Telling people not to make mistakes isn't going to help at all; it's obvious, and no one wants to cause an accident. The error is just the last step in the process that led to the collision.
Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by rglover on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @02:26PM (#47507018)
I don't think the ATC is at fault here. If they were put in a difficult situation and responsible for too much at once, I'd view that as a leadership bug, not their personal fault (or anything they should be held liable for). The weak links imo here are the firetruck driver and whoever that ATC reports to directly (i.e., there shouldn't have been an opportunity for this to happen—that's an executive failure, whether they want to take ownership or not).
Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by SecretDreams on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @04:42PM (#47508932)
The weak link is the system in place which puts so much work on so few staff.

The fire truck received the go ahead. They weigh 3x more than a normal firetruck. They're rushing to a different emergency. The plane is moving fast as hell. They can't just react instantaneously.

The ATC worker is clearly too stretched and such an incident was an inevitability. When they're shouting stop, they are no longer directly talking to the firetruck, which obscures the situation for everyone.

It is a terrible tragedy that will only be prevented with reform in staffing and safety procedures.

Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by TheSpiceIsLife on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @06:31PM (#47510447)
The NTSB’s role is to not to assign blame.

We aren’t in the aviation industry, and neither are we the NTSB.

Prosecutions and convictions do occur as a result of aviation incidents, pilots loose their jobs, pilots loose their licenses, ATC staff can be prohibited from ever working in the industry again.

We free to talk about all of those aspects here.

Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by joncrane on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @01:16PM (#47506030)
The controller was talking to Frontier plane when he first said stop, then said stopstopTruck1stopstopstop and it would be easy for there to be a gap in processing for the driver of truck 1 because the verbiage all flowed in the same stanza that was started when addressing the Frontier flight.
Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by inaros on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @01:32PM (#47506273)
I am afraid the fire truck might have some level of responsibility, since it seems FAA ground vehicle guidance says:

AC No: 150/5210-20A - "Subject: Ground Vehicle Operations to include Taxiing or Towing an Aircraft on Airports"

https://www.faa.gov/documentLibrary/media/Advisory_Circular/...

“you must ensure that you look both ways down the runway to visually acquire aircraft landing or departing even if you have a clearance to cross.”

These trucks seem to have pretty good visibility from inside. Not sure if La Guardia model was the same: https://youtu.be/rfILwYo3sXc

Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by phearnot on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @01:40PM (#47506396)
Not arguing with the regulations, just pointing out that based on airport diagram[1], since the truck was crossing rwy on taxiway D, the CRJ was on the right approaching from behind. I have never been inside an airport firetruck, but I guess from the driver's seat the jet would be quite hard to see in this case.

[1]https://www.avherald.com/h?article=536bb98e

Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by inaros on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @02:05PM (#47506736)
That is a good point but it seems instructions for ground vehicles seem to really stress this. For example this one: https://skybrary.aero/sites/default/files/bookshelf/1003.pdf

Says at pag 9:

"While driving on an aerodrome : Clear left, ahead, above and right

Scan the full length of the runway and the approaches for possible landing aircraft before entering or crossing any runway, even if you have received a clearance."

Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by cucumber3732842 on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @02:05PM (#47506737)
>but I guess from the driver's seat the jet would be quite hard to see in this case.

They have mostly glass cabs for exactly that reason. Only thing that would block your view is a passenger in the right seat.

Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by userbinator on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @08:29PM (#47511586)
...and that passenger should also be actively looking around.
Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by caminante on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @02:07PM (#47506762)
Visibility was bad (night and mist) too.

But if your truck has blind spots and vis is poor, you shouldn't be driving as fast if at all.

Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by dghlsakjg on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @04:57PM (#47509160)
He was stopped until he received instructions to cross the runway from the person whose job it is to sit in a position with good visibility and tell people when they can cross runways. He wasn’t driving fast at all. The whole system is set up so that vehicles with blind spots (every large passenger jet) can safely move.

We can’t say that emergency vehicles should just stay in on dark and stormy nights.

Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by caminante on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @08:22PM (#47511536)
>from the driver's seat the jet would be quite hard to see in this case.

..is what I was responding to.

>We can’t say that emergency vehicles should just stay in on dark and stormy nights.

This conclusion is flawed and doesn't apply to what I said.

If a truck can't see (conditions or not), then they shouldn't be on the same runway as takeoff/landing because...the consequences were severe despite the safeguards you mentioned, e.g. Not driving fast is relative and the "eyes" failed too initially.

Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by dghlsakjg on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @11:35PM (#47512944)
“Vehicles with large blind spots don’t belong on the runway” is a completely untenable proposal.

Almost every airplane is bigger, blinder and slower than that truck. If it had been a plane cleared across the runway, this would have been so much worse.

Even if you want to exempt airplanes, it would require a complete rebuild of most major airports or using completely different emergency equipment. Every airport you have ever flown to commercially has ground vehicles crossing or operating on runways every day. It is simply not possible to operate a commercial airport without ground vehicles in aircraft movement areas, including runways.

The solution is not to spend billions on new trucks or access roads because of a single incident. It is to ensure that controllers, the people directly in charge of coordinating safe ground movement, have the mental bandwidth and tools to do their jobs. The fact that this was a truck and not an airplane is luck, making any discussions about truck cab visibility very much secondary. You have to go upstream of “trucks have blind spots” to truly prevent another of these incidents.

Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by caminante on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @09:46AM (#47517312)
“Vehicles with large blind spots don’t belong on the runway” is a completely untenable proposal.

I never said this. This is very different to what I said.

This reveals you're having a different conversation.

Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by dghlsakjg on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @10:48AM (#47518055)
You said: “If a truck can't see (conditions or not), then they shouldn't be on the same runway as takeoff/landing”

All of my arguments apply to this statement as well as they do to my paraphrase of the statement.

Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by caminante on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @11:34AM (#47518790)
They still "apply to your paraphrase" which isn't accurate?

What?

It doesn't work like that unless you're having a different conversation.

Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by dghlsakjg on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @01:18PM (#47520331)
You even earlier: “ But if your truck has blind spots and vis is poor, you shouldn't be driving as fast if at all”

How do you propose that a truck not driving “at all” manage to drive on the runway? Driving on the runway, (or anywhere) is a subset of driving “at all”. Logically I can conclude that since you think that the trucks should not be driving “at all” due to blind spots, that you also think that they should not be driving on runways because of blind spots.

My argument paraphrased you to highlight a specific situation that would arise as a result of what you argued and to point out the folly of just banning any vehicle with a blind spot from crossing the runway. By extension, that planes can’t cross the runway either (the difference between a fire truck and an airplane crossing the runway is that the plane is larger, with bigger blind spots, less maneuverable, fragile and filled with people).

The solution is not to ban vehicles with blind spots from crossing runways, but to provide tools and guidance for those vehicles to operate safely. You could, for example, provide them with a trained observer in an elevated place that can be responsible for saying whether it is ok to be on the runway. We could give the person coordinating movement in the elevated place tools like radar mapping the ground, or automated semaphore systems at runway crossings (I’m describing things that already exist). Using a system like that we could do things like operate in 0 visibility where the weather causes the blind spot to be anything past the windshield (which is something that happens at JFK for example).

Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by vkou on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @01:44PM (#47506451)
Every other truck in the column immediately stopped when the call was made. Truck 1 was the only one that didn't.
Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by krisoft on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @03:00PM (#47507524)
I very much doubt that you know the exact timing of the event. My guess is that you might have seen a video where some industrious editor put the ATC recordings over the leaked surveilance footage, but there is no way that is correctly synced.
Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by hatthew on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @06:09PM (#47510178)
With publicly available information we can sync it to within ~2 seconds. All trucks other than the first one were definitely in the process of stopping in between the first and second time ATC told them to stop (5 seconds apart).
Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by dghlsakjg on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @05:02PM (#47509245)
They were all, including truck 1, queued up at the stop line waiting for clearance to cross. Truck 1 received clearance to cross, he began crossing, then received instructions to stop after it was too late.

The rest of the emergency vehicles were stopped because they hadn’t been authorized. Truck 1 started moving because he had received specific instructions to do exactly what he was doing.

I take it you’re not a pilot, controller or someone who has ever worked an aviation radio?

Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by hatthew on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @05:36PM (#47509745)
"Truck 1 and company" were cleared to cross. A few seconds later, "truck 1" was instructed to stop.

Edit: Confirmed truck 1 was the one involved in the collision. Previous text: It is unclear which truck specifically was involved in the crash. In photos, the truck has the number 35 on it, not sure if that would preclude it from being identified as "truck 1" verbally.

Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by dghlsakjg on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @09:05PM (#47511861)
Ah. I missed hearing that “and company” in the recording.

In any case, if they were cleared across the runway, and they were, it isn’t really on them. It doesn’t change the gist of the argument. The broader point is that it wasn’t that one truck was barreling around being reckless as implied by gp, it’s just that one truck made it out and the rest of the company had yet to start moving (whether because they saw the plane coming from their viewpoint farther back, or just hadn’t started moving yet, we will find out later). The entire company had stopped at the line, and when cleared across the lead truck was struck. Of course the rest were still stopped behind the line, there was a giant fire truck in their path moments before.

The instruction to stop is, to my pilots ear, irrelevant. Until an instruction is read back by the receiving party, it is worthless. It might not have been received, or received incorrectly. That’s the whole point of the readback, to ensure that the instruction was received correctly (notice how I missed the “and company”… a readback would have caught that). If there is not a readback, controllers are instructed to ask for one. On top of that, it was a panic instruction using non standard verbiage. If he was already past the line, the instruction to stop might have made it worse.

Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by doubleg72 on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @09:58PM (#47512245)
“I take it you haven’t ever worked with radio.. “. Seems like you haven’t a clue how any of this works. Doesn’t matter if they had radio clearance, the fire truck is responsible for ensuring runways is clear and not driving in front of plane.
Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by dghlsakjg on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @10:48PM (#47512605)
I’m a certificated pilot in two countries, trained in this region, and own an airplane. I have a pretty good grasp how this works, but am willing to learn if you have citations besides the CFR pull quotes elsewhere in this thread.

All people (pilots included) are responsible for only following ATC instructions if it is safe/possible to do so. You aren’t supposed to land on a runway with other traffic on it, even if cleared. You aren’t supposed to cross a runway if there is a plane taking off or landing, even if cleared. You aren’t supposed to clear a vehicle onto a runway at the same time you cleared a plane to land (this one’s an assumption, I’m not a trained controller).

You are making the assumption that the truck did not check the runway, but keep in mind that it is a 30ish ton vehicle, and the plane was moving at 150 mph at touchdown, 100 mph at the time of impact. There very well may not have been a plane visible when the truck started moving. The truck might not have received the non-standard clearance revocation, or received it and tried to get off the runway by accelerating across, or received it and begun slowing in the path of the plane.

The truck driver could have prevented this, but they certainly aren’t the primary cause.

Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by jmtulloss on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @05:34PM (#47509723)
FWIW the whole group received permission to cross. The instructions were to "Truck 1 and company", not just Truck 1
Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by dghlsakjg on Wednesday March 25, 2026 @03:07PM (#47521775)
Thanks, I missed that.
Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by sssilver on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @01:17PM (#47506047)
> Is it common now to have solo operators running control towers?

At Class D airports it’s always been the norm. But KLGA is Class B.

Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by rdtsc on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @02:39PM (#47507230)
Truck was on a different frequency from the aircraft so they couldn’t even hear each others’ clearances.

Also first time ATC told the truck to stop it wasn’t too clear who the message was addressed to. It’s a bit hard to hear “Truck1” there, not clear who he wants to stop. The second time, one can argue by the time “stop” command was heard it might have been better to gun the engine. As the truck sort of slowed down in the middle of the runway.

Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by bko on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @01:44PM (#47506440)
> this seems to be exacerbated by government cuts

What government cuts? 2025 FAA air traffic budget was up around 7% from 2025

https://enotrans.org/article/senate-bill-oks-27-billion-faa-...

Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by rglover on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @02:28PM (#47507044)
From the article:

> The crash has raised fears that operations at US airports are under extreme stress. Airports have been dealing with a shortage of air traffic controllers, exacerbated by brutal federal government personnel cuts by Donald Trump’s administration at the start of his second presidency.

Not my opinion, just reading from there.

Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by bko on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @03:57PM (#47508193)
So where there budget cuts or not? That was the claim. I have yet to find anything that suggests there were budget cuts, just vague mentions of "brutal federal government personnel cuts".

I'm just looking for: budget was X in <2026 and in 2026 it is Y, where X > Y

Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by ridgeguy on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @04:59PM (#47509195)
Analyze staffing, not budget. That gets more directly at workload.
Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by rglover on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @06:14PM (#47510235)
You said budget cuts, not me.
Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by sophacles on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @02:37PM (#47507193)
Notably 2025 was also the year that Elon started firing people and shutting down things that were in the budget, as well as several shutdowns.
Re:LaGuardia pilots raised safety alarms months before deadl... by Yizahi on Tuesday March 24, 2026 @07:32PM (#47511095)
I've seen the NTSB footage of the plane and helicopter crash in Washington. It is practically impossible to discern a landing plane over the lights of a big city at night. Next, the truck had been angled away from the plane approach, so it was coming from the right side (passenger side) and at back. There was zero chance that firetruck could have seen the plane in the seconds it covered hundreds of meters, flying at 200+ km/h. And also in that NTSB investigation there was a case of missed comms, when ATC recording clearly showed controller saying an important word, but it jot "jammed" in the process and there was silence at the receiving end instead of that word (in the middle of the transmission). Not saying it was a case here, but it is possible too.

Just like in that collision, it is possible there is no one single person to blame (apparently helicopter pilot was not outside of the legal corridor, despite the speculations), but it was a compounding error issue.