Ah, thank you for the example, I understand how a linearly-increasing counter can be useful, if you use it that way. It would obviously be more versatile with write access & configurable clock dividers, pre-setters, counting direction, etc. The current design probably allows re-using the counter across cores & minimize space, so makes sense to me. I should dig into the RTL when I have a bit of time… Maybe I'll make it my bedside reading?
You could also say it's up to the user to implement a fully-fledged timer/counter in a BIO coprocessor if they need one, though ideally there would be a shared register (or a way to configure the FIFOs depth + make them non-blocking) to communicate the result.
Small cores like these are really fun to play with: the constraints easily fit in your head, and finding some clever way to use the existing HW is very rewarding. Who needs Zachtronics games when you have a BIO or PIO?
I think it will be interesting to see what people end up doing with it and what are the pain points. As you say, it's a v1 - with any luck there will be a v2, so we could consider the time starting now as a deliberation period for what goes into v2.
The good news is that it also all compiles into an FPGA, so proposed patches can be tested & vetted in hardware, albeit at a much slower clock rate.