Even a half-assed attempt at doxing is still an attempt at doxing.
It'd be much easier to accept that you're acting in good faith had you deleted the post when it became obvious that the target doesn't appreciate it.
You could still do that, and it would very simply be the right thing to do.
It's all just publicly available information.
Anyway, I think a normal grown-up should be able to accept that we simply feel differently about just how unacceptable doxing is.
I encourage everyone to read the original article and make their own conclusion. Do not take this poster at their word.
No, I think it's grounds for a much harsher response.
Even a bad attempt at doxing is a threat of violence.
> you attempt to portray it as “doxxing” to mislead people into thinking that someone’s identity or address was published against their will
This is you being dishonest, nothing I've said suggests that. The very comment you're replied to calls the doxing "half-assed".
If you want to define doxing narrowly (as it was historically) then I would agree that all (or nearly all) such cases are wrong, but this is by no means clearly doxing. If you want to define doxing widely (as is common lately), then I'll accept this is clearly an example of doxing, but note that there's nothing inherently wrong with doxing.
Just saying "doxing" does not establish that the underlying actions are immoral, and so it does not follow that the target not appreciating it is relevant. If I take the last parking place in a crowded lot, the driver behind me certainly won't appreciate it, but I have no obligation to give it up. If you think Jani has done something incomparable to taking a parking place, you need to make the case.
It's probable that in the later 00s this would have been called a "faildox", but it's still just a fundamentally dick move to try to identify someone online who doesn't want to be identified. It doesn't matter if you do a completely shit job at it.
I fail to see how that’s supposed to be any better.
I've always understood doxing to be PII, which aliases aren't, AFAIK, unless they're connected to a real person. And, to my knowledge, everyone is contending that the names in the blog post are all aliases. And, regarding aliases, I've never understood it to be doxing for someone to say "FakeNameX and FakeNameY appear to be the same user."
So, to me, the thing that makes it not look like doxing is that it simply doesn't meet the basic definition of doxing. It provides no PII.
"Dox" is short for "documents", and it originally referred to compiling a multi-page document of all known personal information, using disparate public sources: name, address, phone, email, employer, family members, family address/phone etc, etc, etc. It came from troll boards and was designed to make it easy to harass targets.
The term got significantly watered down when it got out to the broader internet.
https://gyrovague.com/2023/08/05/archive-today-on-the-trail-...
[1] https://webapps.stackexchange.com/questions/145817/who-owns-...