News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stolen Money on Gittip, Part 1 by dmethvin on Monday November 05, 2012 @11:22AM (#4744213)
Openness about the problem is good, but I am not sure that it helps to provide that much detail about the ways you detected the fraud. That just give the attacker more information about how to circumvent your detection.
Re:Stolen Money on Gittip, Part 1 by taylonr on Monday November 05, 2012 @11:53AM (#4744413)
My favorite part was the 3 primary & 3 secondary factors they looked at to identify. So if the people doing this can tweak those factors it will help them out.
Re:Stolen Money on Gittip, Part 1 by whit537 on Monday November 05, 2012 @01:02PM (#4744917)
There were two primary factors, not three. And the point is that I'm planning to individually review and whitelist all new accounts. I'm able to adapt my heuristic in real time. ;^)
Re:Stolen Money on Gittip, Part 1 by Trufa on Monday November 05, 2012 @12:00PM (#4744460)
Yes, but it's so simple I don't really think you're enlightening criminal minds here.
Re:Stolen Money on Gittip, Part 1 by reidmain on Monday November 05, 2012 @11:48AM (#4744380)
Security through obscurity is never the solution.
Re:Stolen Money on Gittip, Part 1 by dasil003 on Monday November 05, 2012 @12:29PM (#4744685)
You're cargo culting on security dogma.

Information assymetry is probably your only advantage against credit card fraudsters, because there is no security hole, rather they are exploiting your core business flow.

Re:Stolen Money on Gittip, Part 1 by whit537 on Monday November 05, 2012 @01:20PM (#4744991)
I want to explore openness wrt fraud prevention, not out of a facile rejection of "security through obscurity," but as part of Gittip's identity as an open company. It's accepted doctrine that "information asymmetry is probably your only advantage." I'm asking: can we be open about fraud prevention and prevent fraud? If we can be, we should.

What are your thoughts on the value of the social graph in spotting suspicious accounts? It seems to me that we should be able to whitelist new accounts based on a review of GitHub or Twitter profiles, and perhaps for flagged accounts we "authorize without capturing," as dangrossman suggests above.

Re:Stolen Money on Gittip, Part 1 by dasil003 on Tuesday November 06, 2012 @05:27AM (#4747834)
I admire your motives, but I can't offer much encouragement.

My experience is that there is no such thing as preventing fraud in the absolute sense. It's not a binary proposition—maybe general security isn't either, but it's a hell of a lot less gray than credit card fraud. So while I think it's good for general fraud prevention techniques and information to be widely disseminated, I can't in good conscience discuss specifics of techniques that I've employed because those would be easily traceable to companies I've worked for, and thus would impose an undue cost on them. A lot of people who have worked on these issues are probably in similar position where we'd be happy to go into details over a beer but not on public record.

Re:Stolen Money on Gittip, Part 1 by reidmain on Monday November 05, 2012 @03:20PM (#4745572)
It may be the only thing I can do to help mitigate credit card fraud but is it not the solution to preventing it. Credit card companies should be operating on the theory that people freely throw around their credit card number (because, let's face it, a lot of people do) and come up with solutions that do not rely on hiding that information.

Obscurity of process/information can definitely be a benefit to the security of a system but it should not be the solution. The system should be designed for the absolute worst case scenario where this process/information could be exposed.

I realize this can only go so far until at some point there is going to be some sort of secret that needs to be kept (i.e. physical hardware key, encryption codes, etc) where if this is cracked your system is exposed and at that point you need to have some sort of plan B to regain control and minimize damage.

Re:Stolen Money on Gittip, Part 1 by dasil003 on Tuesday November 06, 2012 @05:36AM (#4747844)
This is gobbledygook. You are still thinking in terms of security, but with credit card fraud there is no security issue or system to be cracked per se. Rather it's an identity and information problem. You can impose additional steps to vet the legitimacy of a transaction, but there is nothing that can ever give you a 100% guarantee. So you have to balance your efforts at vetting the transaction against usability barriers that add friction to your core business function.

The difference between publishing your techniques (even with specific variables hidden) and often the difference between attackers being able to iteratively determine the minimum work around to get desired results and having to dedicate orders of magnitude more effort than necessary to ensure they are flying under the radar.

Re:Stolen Money on Gittip, Part 1 by reidmain on Tuesday November 06, 2012 @08:48AM (#4748332)
You're correct. I was not thinking about conning the system but actually breaking into it which is obviously a lot harder. It is a lot easier to look at ways to dupe the algorithms for determining fraud rather than breaking the system and bypassing them. Thanks for opening my eyes.
Re:Stolen Money on Gittip, Part 1 by dasil003 on Tuesday November 06, 2012 @10:09AM (#4748686)
Thanks for your comment, sorry if I was harsh.
Re:Stolen Money on Gittip, Part 1 by reidmain on Tuesday November 06, 2012 @03:16PM (#4750463)
No worries. I was wrong. Better to be corrected and have my feelings hurt than to go on being ignorant.
Re:Stolen Money on Gittip, Part 1 by scott_s on Monday November 05, 2012 @11:55AM (#4744421)
Obscurity is necessary for fraud prevention. If perpetrators know exactly what behavior gets flagged as fraud, it's easier for them to figure out ways to avoid it. If they don't know, perpetrating fraud is harder.
Re:Stolen Money on Gittip, Part 1 by reidmain on Monday November 05, 2012 @03:21PM (#4745579)
That is a good point. It honestly slipped my mind. Thanks for pointing that out.
Re:Stolen Money on Gittip, Part 1 by rm999 on Monday November 05, 2012 @02:10PM (#4745261)
This is true if a system can freely be reverse-engineered by the attacker. If not, the obscurity provides an added cost to the attacker. Obscurity can actually be one of the stronger weapons in an anti-fraud solution (I used to work in anti-fraud).
Re:Stolen Money on Gittip, Part 1 by reidmain on Monday November 05, 2012 @03:27PM (#4745617)
Yeah like scott_s pointed out I did not consider anti-fraud. In my quick glib reaction comment I did not consider all scenarios. Thanks for pointing this out.
Re:Stolen Money on Gittip, Part 1 by RickHull on Monday November 05, 2012 @02:09PM (#4745253)
The maxim is that you cannot achieve security through obscurity, where security offers some guarantees (mathematical, physical, etc.). Obscurity, while offering little to no guarantees, can certainly be a quite useful part of your protection plan.
Re:Stolen Money on Gittip, Part 1 by reidmain on Monday November 05, 2012 @03:25PM (#4745603)
You're 100% correct Rick. I should have been more explicit in my original post. It was a quick glib comment that I should have put a bit more thought into.

There is a reason people don't go around wearing their credit card numbers and SIN on their clothes. The system to protect them should be setup to work its best in the scenario this information is completely exposed but our attempts to hide his information does add a tangible benefit.

Re:Stolen Money on Gittip, Part 1 by darkarmani on Tuesday November 06, 2012 @10:19AM (#4748729)
Just stop. There are so many layers of security that use obscurity. Most basic example is not exposing valid account usernames during failed logins.
Re:Stolen Money on Gittip, Part 1 by reidmain on Tuesday November 06, 2012 @03:17PM (#4750475)
I will. I have been flayed by other HNers and made aware of my ignorant position.
Re:Stolen Money on Gittip, Part 1 by TheAmazingIdiot on Tuesday November 06, 2012 @12:50AM (#4747385)
Since your HN password is obscure, how bouts you publicise it here?

After all, hidden passwords are security through obscurity, and that's "just the wrong way".

Re:Stolen Money on Gittip, Part 1 by reidmain on Tuesday November 06, 2012 @08:51AM (#4748346)
True, it is the wrong way. Ideally there would be a better system for this kind of thing. It is the reason why physical authenticators and two phase authentication are becoming more popular.