News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Will US send ground troops to Iran? by anovikov on Saturday March 14, 2026 @08:40AM (#47376077)
It might be a good thing to resolve the crisis - just take over entire coastline to some depth where the first easily defendable natural barrier occurs, throw all locals out of there and make sure no one can infiltrate - then threat to shipping will be gone.
Re:Ask HN: Will US send ground troops to Iran? by jleyank on Saturday March 14, 2026 @10:54AM (#47377307)
While there's coast near Bandar Abbas (sez Google), there's a whole lot of mountains inland of that. Not sure what the range of Iranian weaponry is, but digging troops out of mountains is something that tends to be avoided. There is a mountain division in the US inventory as I recall, but (a) no clue what its strength is and (b) also no clue when it last played in the hills post-WW II.

If the Marines actually face well-armed zealots, it's going to look far too much like WW II in the Pacific. Are the US-ians ready to re-experience such casualties? Cuz I expect the zealots would be willing to do so. And Ukraine has shown the power of man-portable weaponry against the traditional tools of 20th century military operations.

Re:Ask HN: Will US send ground troops to Iran? by anovikov on Saturday March 14, 2026 @11:48AM (#47377852)
Surely no going to the mountains. Coast needs to be taken to prevent launch of any boats of mini-subs for minelaying. Of course, preventing drone launch will require capturing entire country - Shaheds have 1500+ km range - that isn't an option.

Iranian missile capability is almost extinguished as it is, and drones are to be defended from using Ukrainian interceptors - first line of defence, on the ground on the coast, and second line, on ships themselves.

Ah, and Iranian electric grid needs to be knocked out, and kept like that. It was done easily in Iraq in 1991. It alone prevents nuclear enrichment for the lack of electricity.

It will perhaps never result in victory, but sustain suppression may be enough, Cuba-like.

Re:Ask HN: Will US send ground troops to Iran? by mindslight on Saturday March 14, 2026 @01:54PM (#47379243)
So before long the new generation born to secular parents will only have known life under US oppression and will be eager for the revenge being promised by the religious extremists. Sounds like a great plan for creating more terrorists!
Re:Ask HN: Will US send ground troops to Iran? by Guestmodinfo on Sunday March 15, 2026 @02:39AM (#47384885)
One thing apalling in the western and especially US mindset is that middle East ppl are terrorists. No Iran was never involved in any acts of individual or planned terrorism. Covert CIA like spy operations: Yes because everyone is it's enemy (I'm neither a fan of US nor Iran. I don't care who wins. I don't care who survives. But the bloodshed troubles me) It's just face-palm moment to realize that whoever has other sensibilities is an extremist or maybe terrorist.
Re:Ask HN: Will US send ground troops to Iran? by mindslight on Sunday March 15, 2026 @03:02AM (#47384969)
Well, I'll apologize for using the word. Usually I try to be a bit more nuanced with my analyses. But in this case it seems entirely appropriate to throw that fearmongering word right back at people driving the bloodshed with overly simplistic tales of being able to subjugate a country by keeping its electric grid destroyed from the air - especially a country where only a scant few weeks ago the narrative was all about how the population overwhelmingly desires a secular society and is eager to throw off the chains of its oppressive regime.
Re:Ask HN: Will US send ground troops to Iran? by krapp on Saturday March 14, 2026 @09:49AM (#47376662)
What video game rules do you think the real world operates under?