News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by jpxxx on Friday November 02, 2012 @12:22PM (#4733331)
The complexity of getting to Mars is nothing compared to the complexity of creating a social unit that can survive and thrive on another planet.

Specifically, an Antarctic planet covered in chlorinated brominated rusty dust with essentially no air pressure or atmospheric water, a dim sun, rotten weather, two ugly little moons, and 57,600,000 millisecond ping times.

No chance to ever feel fresh air on your face, no chance to go swimming, never meeting a stranger until they're suddenly your neighbors for life, no chance to ever get away and start anew, and no chance to go back to Earth.

In a box, on a dead planet, for life.

Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by marvin on Friday November 02, 2012 @12:56PM (#4733574)
Seriously, are dismissive and pessimistic remarks like this the top-voted comment on _every single_ Hacker News post these days?

Elon Musk has built a fucking space rocket company and is defeating Boeing, Lockheed Martin and MDD in a business they've dominated for the last 40 years. I think this is an incredibly impressive accomplishment, and SpaceX's ambitions to make it possible to do manned missions to Mars is exactly what we need to bring humanity forward. Just from the science side alone, having actual people on Mars would be of tremendous value. If you think of what we know about Mars, think about how much more we would know if we were able to do more complex experiments there. Whether you personally think it's a good idea to settle down on Mars or not isn't very relevant.

You're pointing at some very relevant issues, but why not phrase it in a more constructive tone? I'm sorry for the negativity, but it pisses me off when grand ideas and accomplishments are dismissed so offhandedly. Getting to Mars is not nearly "nothing", even compared to _anything_ that humans have ever done.

Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by jpxxx on Friday November 02, 2012 @01:42PM (#4733821)
Sure. Elon Musk is a heroic man. His car company is a marvel, and his space program is spectacular. His unfettered ability to speak without a mouth full of funder's cock or a PR minder sitting in the room is refreshing. His visions are grounded in technical and physical reality, his powers of observation are keen, and he has the personality and resources it takes to organize people in service of great accomplishments.

Sanely priced two-way trips to Mars will change the course of humanity by enabling us to colonize the solar system and perhaps ensure a longer story for all mankind. This is the most interesting thing I've read all day, and he deserves every bit of attention.

Now back to your regularly scheduled pessimism:

Humanity has a long way to go, and a change of scenery isn't going to do all that much for her. The United States of America with her vast resources and impeccable pedigree in advancing Enlightenment is operating a torture camp for political prisoners in a subtropical shithole.

What exactly happens when we send a thousand of our best and brightest and edgiest and most ambitious to live in what is essentially an submarine entombed underground for a decade? Do they live up to the Star Trek ideal? Or do they do what people in confined spaces tend to do?

Can we provide a reasonable quality of life for colonists? Beyond maintaining air pressure and food, can we provide for them spiritually and emotionally? Can we provide a -life-? Geology only gets you so far. Even on Earth it's kind of an obscure trade, and geology is about all there is to -do- on Mars.

What does a day to day life look like there? Do the children go to school? How is conflict handled? Who participates in what activities? What if there is too much to do? What if there isn't enough to do? How do you settle transplanetary custody battles when it means mommy or daddy taking the kid on a potentially lethal trip to another planet? How do you handle disease when everyone's in a thousand foot wide sphere? How do you bury people on an igneous planet? What does suicide mean for a Martian civilization?

There are a billion things to consider, and Elon has the first five thousand handled. I am delighted that we get to think about the rest now.

Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by guylhem on Friday November 02, 2012 @05:03PM (#4734739)
First, a reply to your original post :

> In a box, on a dead planet, for life.

Sign me up, right now!!!

> Can we provide a reasonable quality of life for colonists?

I don't care. I would need a) air+water b) food c) a place to sleep d) tools to colonize the planet - like create more living space. For quality of life, if I can get e) book or movies or even f) internet access, great! If I can't that's not a dealbreaker.

So, sign me up!!

Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by aardvark179 on Friday November 02, 2012 @05:35PM (#4734874)
I do admire this sort of enthusiasm, but I also wonder if it can survive such a mission. However we don't need to send a mission to Mars to find out, and if anybody truly wants to send people to Mars on anything other than short term suicide mission then we really need to do a lot more research in this area. Build enclosed isolated environments with limited space, resources and comms, and see how teams get on over long time periods if they believe there is no way out.

I'm not convinced that our future as flesh and blood humans is in space, or even on any of the other planets in our solar system, but if we're going to try then we cannot focus solely on the hard technical challenges.

Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by guylhem on Friday November 02, 2012 @06:48PM (#4735160)
I'm totally motivated and committed to Mars. Would that commitment survive in a mission? IMHO, totally because I'd even say yes to a one-way trip with a time limit (ie your "life support system will stop working in 3 years")

But the idea of an enclosed isolated test environment just doesn't raise the same kind of enthusiasm in me.

Unless there are side benefits (like freedom - ie build a new country from scratch in the middle of say Antarctica!!) I don't know why, but I really don't feel like taking part in the experience.

I guess it's all about selfishness - being on Mars matches my selfish motives. Doing a 10 years test somewhere in a controlled bunker on earth, a sacrifice for the next team who might do the same on real Mars??? I'll pass the opportunity.

That makes me wonder if it would be a good thing to run such an experiment, considering the volunteers would certainly be different (in their reason and personalities) from the ones who would volunteer for a real Mars mission.

Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by nickzarzycki on Friday November 02, 2012 @01:55PM (#4733886)
>I am delighted

You certainly don't sound like it.

Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by jpxxx on Friday November 02, 2012 @02:10PM (#4733962)
I would sprint through a minefield to be on that first boat out. My wallpaper at one point in life was panoramic prints from the Opportunity rover. I wrote Kim Stanley Robinson a fan letter, signed with a chewed up gelly pen. I am utterly delighted.

But the hard part is extremely, extremely, extremely hard. It's not getting there, it's staying there. And scant few people are focusing on what it would actually look like and how it would actually work if we actually sent people offworld, which I very much want to happen. Mars500 needs to be Mars5000000 before this dream is real.

Honestly, if we could airlift people into the Sahel with a real-world replica of what would be going to Mars and they could make it a few years, I could die happy.

Elon Musk has the easy job in all this.

Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by waterlesscloud on Friday November 02, 2012 @03:29PM (#4734329)
I can answer all your questions:

Some people will be happy with the life.

Some people will be unhappy with the life.

Same as it is in every single other living situation.

Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by koide on Friday November 02, 2012 @05:22PM (#4734812)
I'm not convinced. After all, colonization of far away lands has been done throughout history and in many cases the return trip was as hard as it would be on Mars.

I picture the confinement problem as the most troublesome, but astronauts spend months in orders of magnitude tighter spaces and surviving in relatively good condition.

There's no reason at all you should send untrained people on those first missions and there's also no reason at all not to schedule yearly trips to bring back the people who couldn't stand the pressure.

Now, of course it will be insanely hard, there will be highly complex issues with no apparent solution that will have to be solved via improvisation without the proper means. But humans seem to have done it again and again.

Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by InternetUser on Friday November 02, 2012 @02:26PM (#4734042)
I have to say that I definitely agree with your point--and your writing style is great. Do you happen to have a blog or contribute material to any other website (aside from this one, of course)?
Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by jpxxx on Friday November 02, 2012 @03:07PM (#4734235)
Soon, thank you. But I doubt I'll connect it to this or any of my other sour and shitty identities. Time for a fresh start.
Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by indiecore on Friday November 02, 2012 @01:49PM (#4733852)
>What exactly happens when we send a thousand of our best and brightest and edgiest and most ambitious to live in what is essentially an submarine entombed underground for a decade?

That's what we're trying to find out.

Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by Retric on Friday November 02, 2012 @01:12PM (#4733655)
There competing and making money, but they are still a tiny player so I don't know if you can say there winning. The space industry is much like the healthcare industry in that once your a large player you can't really grow much and there are a lot of perverse incentives to be less efficient.
Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by damoncali on Friday November 02, 2012 @01:26PM (#4733730)
I think you're being a bit hyperbolic. Musk built a small aerospace company. He's not exactly crushing Boeing.
Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by trafficlight on Friday November 02, 2012 @01:53PM (#4733876)
Not crushing, but he's competing with them and that's impressive.
Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by jberryman on Friday November 02, 2012 @04:39PM (#4734634)
I really liked his comment, and didn't consider it dismissive. Reminded me of Ray Bradbury in fact.
Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by mbrubeck on Friday November 02, 2012 @12:30PM (#4733394)
Why "for life"? Even if a permanent base is established, what would stop people from traveling there to work for a year or so and then returning home? I know health concerns related to radiation and gravity may impose some constraints, but would a round-trip journey be out of the question? Musk's explicit goal is to make and use fully-reusable rockets, so obviously he intends them to travel both directions.

If you're talking about an eventual permanent colony, it will definitely need some brave souls willing to make a one-way trip -- but so have many colonies in Earth history. And the colonists needn't be as cut off as you say if they could have visitors from Earth coming and going regularly. The round-trip radio delay between Mars and Earth is anywhere from 7 minutes to 45 minutes (I think your "ping time" was off by an order of magnitute or two), which is far shorter than the delay for, say, European colonists in 18th-century America or Africa to write to their friends back home.

By the time we are thinking about raising children on another planet, we might even be able to build them an indoor swimming pool. :)

Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by robotresearcher on Friday November 02, 2012 @01:34PM (#4733769)
> what would stop people from traveling there to work for a year or so and then returning home?

It might be cheaper and easier to deliver sustainable life support to Mars than the fuel, oxidizer and engines to return (or the machinery needed to harvest it in situ).

Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by jpxxx on Friday November 02, 2012 @12:57PM (#4733582)
Yes! The idea of 0.38G water is fascinating. It must look "wrong" when it ripples or pours.
Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by sbierwagen on Friday November 02, 2012 @02:25PM (#4734033)
I prefer 0.16G water.
Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by Willwhatley on Sunday November 04, 2012 @10:43AM (#4740025)
Lunacy!
Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by forgottenpaswrd on Friday November 02, 2012 @12:43PM (#4733481)
"Men wanted for a hazardous journey. Small wages, bitter cold. Long months of complete darkness. Constant danger, safe return doubtful. Honour and recognition in case of success."

More than 5000 applications followed. Not everybody is made for adventure though.

Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by martincmartin on Friday November 02, 2012 @12:59PM (#4733589)
This was the ad that Shackleton placed in the paper to find a crew for his most famous expedition:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imperial_Trans-Antarctic_Expedi...

Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by jpxxx on Friday November 02, 2012 @01:48PM (#4733845)
If anyone here hasn't, Ernest Shackleton's 'South' is basically mandatory reading. It's his own book about his own experiences, it's dispassionate and yet wildly exciting, and even though you know how it ends, you're on the edge of your seat. Superb adventure.

http://www.amazon.com/South-Endurance-Expedition-Ernest-Shac...

Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by desas on Friday November 02, 2012 @04:43PM (#4734649)
I thought it was fantastic. Project Gutenburg has also made it available.
Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by jpatokal on Sunday November 04, 2012 @04:54AM (#4739376)
...but unfortunately actually didn't. Still a great quote though!

http://conversation.cipr.co.uk/posts/andy.green/the-myth-of-...

Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by ricardobeat on Friday November 02, 2012 @12:31PM (#4733401)
Or you're a space explorer, at the very edge of civilization and technology, pushing the human race forward and signing your name in history for the next thousand years.
Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by anonymouz on Friday November 02, 2012 @12:47PM (#4733512)
I am all for people being motivated by a higher calling and trying to be explorers, but you'd better forget about the "signing your name into history" bit. Unless you're one of the very first or do something very special, very few people will remember you. Could you, off the top of your head, recount the names of all the Apollo astronauts? Could you list, even with some research, say, the first 100 people from Europe that settled in North America?

People should do that stuff because they love to do it, not out of a misguided hope of becoming famous for future generations.

Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by btown on Friday November 02, 2012 @01:36PM (#4733777)
Even if you don't remember their names, though, you can recall the fact that there existed Apollo astronauts, men who were brave enough to go on those pioneering missions.

DHH put it very eloquently in an essay 4 years ago: http://37signals.com/svn/posts/1437-put-a-dent-in-the-univer... -

"The key is that your efforts would be missed, your customers would have a sense of loss, if you stopped doing what you’re doing."

Imagine if history said this about Apollo: "The technology was there, but in the end, we lacked people brave enough to risk the voyage. So the project stagnated, the rockets languished on the launching pads. And America moved on, a president's promise forgotten."

I'd say the nameless astronaut makes a pretty big dent.

Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by mdonahoe on Friday November 02, 2012 @01:28PM (#4733739)
I don't remember apollo astronauts, but Wikipedia does.

Hopefully our records will be better preserved than those from the Mayflower.

Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by tjic on Friday November 02, 2012 @04:45PM (#4734660)
> Hopefully our records will be better preserved than those from the Mayflower.

I dunno. They Mayflower records are pretty decent. And online.

http://www.mayflowerhistory.com/images/MayflowerCompact.gif

Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by javert on Friday November 02, 2012 @01:08PM (#4733636)
"Signing your name into history" does not have to equate to "having your name remembered." In other words, it would be great to make history (in such an important way as this), whether you are remembered or not.
Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by hnriot on Friday November 02, 2012 @01:28PM (#4733737)
but it's not really pushing anything, it's just a huge waste of money that would be better spent on developing technologies for extra-solar system travel. People living on a dead planet serves no purpose, it doesn't even increase the species potential for surviving cataclysmic events, because without an earth bases resupply any martian colony will be soon dead. Build spaceships that people can live on and head out of the solar system, not set up camp on the doorstep.
Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by jpxxx on Friday November 02, 2012 @02:00PM (#4733914)
I cannot agree.

Physically getting to Mars and setting up camp is a challenge. Physically getting to another solar system and setting up camp is a challenge to the power of challenge. The numbers and difficulties are profoundly greater between the two.

Self sufficiency is entirely possible given enough energy, material, and care. We've managed to do it for four billion years on this planet. There's no reason it can't be done on another planet, or a ship as you mention.

I maintain that creating a stable-enough social structure that can survive offworld long-term seems to be most difficult part of the quest to leave Earth.

Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by sliverstorm on Friday November 02, 2012 @02:17PM (#4733997)
Colonizing Mars serves the purpose of developing and proving out the ability to colonize.
Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by dbaupp on Friday November 02, 2012 @02:23PM (#4734023)
I think you are just imagining a worst case scenario.

Why is any point of this true:

No chance to ever feel fresh air on your face, no chance to go swimming, never meeting a stranger until they're suddenly your neighbors for life, no chance to ever get away and start anew, and no chance to go back to Earth.

The fresh air one maybe, but there's no particular reason the chemical and physical make-up of Earth air can't be recreated.

Swimming can happen in a swimming pool and fake/indoor beaches exist.

You can move with people you already know; anyway, isn't "never meeting a stranger until you're living next to them" the standard procedure for moving house on Earth?

There's no reason that one can't move around, even back to Earth. They did get to Mars/other planet in the first place.

Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by zacharycohn on Friday November 02, 2012 @12:32PM (#4733407)
That problem seems like Step 2, where Step 1 is getting to the point where that's a problem.
Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by eru on Friday November 02, 2012 @12:27PM (#4733376)
Exciting, isn't it?
Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by jpxxx on Friday November 02, 2012 @12:41PM (#4733464)
Honestly, yes. :3 I remember drawing habitations as a kid. But morally I feel this would have to be a two-way street: Mars cannot be a prison for either the first settlers or the native generations.
Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by TeMPOraL on Friday November 02, 2012 @12:59PM (#4733588)
Or, as Lawrence Krauss suggested[0], just send older astronauts first, who can then live the rest of their lives on Mars, building the first habitat and thus paving the way for further generations to - maybe - travel both ways.

[0] - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mars_to_Stay#cite_ref-krauss_25...

Re:Elon Musk’s Mission to Mars by tjic on Friday November 02, 2012 @04:40PM (#4734642)
> The complexity of getting to Mars is nothing compared to the complexity of creating a social unit that can survive and thrive on another planet.

What's so complicated about "a family" ?