News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Online age-verification tools for child safety are survei... by bilekas on Tuesday March 10, 2026 @09:34AM (#47323057)
The fact that these tools are 'active' centric, i.e : You must perform an action to validate you're NOT a child, these will never protect children. A predator simply needs not to verify anything and appear benign and ironically more anonymous than law abiding people.

I'm not saying the inverse is the answer either, just that if anyone without an agenda of surveillance looked at this for a second, the penny would have dropped. So I can only assume that this was the purpose the whole time.

Re:Online age-verification tools for child safety are survei... by kristopolous on Tuesday March 10, 2026 @09:48AM (#47323218)
Sob stories about children are always weaponized for oppression.

It was used to bash interracial marriage, gay rights, suppress dissent, attack the first amendment, and now this.

Whenever you hear some dramatic story involving kids about how you have to live a little less free, know the tactic.

Re:Online age-verification tools for child safety are survei... by tt24 on Tuesday March 10, 2026 @11:13AM (#47324369)
Don’t forget the second amendment.
Re:Online age-verification tools for child safety are survei... by seanw444 on Tuesday March 10, 2026 @12:32PM (#47325516)
You're on HN. Expect downvotes.
Re:Online age-verification tools for child safety are survei... by tremon on Tuesday March 10, 2026 @05:31PM (#47329043)
I don't understand your point. Can you quote the part of the second amendment that specifically addresses children, or schools for that matter?
Re:Online age-verification tools for child safety are survei... by tt24 on Tuesday March 10, 2026 @08:39PM (#47330577)
> Sob stories about children are always weaponized for oppression.

This is common for opponents of the second amendment as well. "Think of the children!" etc etc.

Re:Online age-verification tools for child safety are survei... by xethos on Tuesday March 10, 2026 @09:40PM (#47330911)
While I think you and I would agree if I argued it was more about culture than firearms per-capita, it's pretty hard to say children aren't suffering some pretty real harms from said firearms (to say nothing of adult suicide statistics when firearms are kept in the house)

Reducing the number of guns doesn't solve the root issue (which I think we'd also agree on), but it should minimize the harms while being dramatically easier than changing the American ethos. Hell, America could likely get 80% of the results (no school shootings) with 20% of the effort (additional restrictions on firearms, more akin to Canada)

I further think the second amendment is causing Americans more harm than it's worth, though that's a seperate discussion; some examples include suicide statistics, accidental discharge, a lack of protection even when carried legally (such as in Alex Pretti's murder) and the fact that, when firearms could be anywhere, police must treat every interaction as potentially fatal - with all the force that requires

Re:Online age-verification tools for child safety are survei... by cultofmetatron on Tuesday March 10, 2026 @09:56AM (#47323310)
whats incredible to me are how many useful idiots out there STILL fall for it.

___ said hamas beaheaded 40 babies and that turned out to be a complete fabrication. That fake info was used in part to justify killing thousands of kids in ____

meanwhile the recent strike on Iran resulted in 80 little girls getting killed (with plenty of evidence) and its swept under the rug while we get blasted about the 7 soldiers that died.

Re:Online age-verification tools for child safety are survei... by hobs on Tuesday March 10, 2026 @10:00AM (#47323373)
More useful idiots are born every day, most of them never are educated and do not see their past blunders as anything wrong happening, they are completely blind to the real implication of their actions.
Re:Online age-verification tools for child safety are survei... by a456463 on Tuesday March 10, 2026 @02:14PM (#47326875)
I know some idiots that read newspapers and technical papers and yet would rather have company like discord providing safety for their new born daughter but would vote for small govt republicans (or democrats, i don't care, it's just a label that is applicable now. they are mostly all the same) and do nothing about calling out the actual child predators and taking proper action against them. It is bonkers
Re:Online age-verification tools for child safety are survei... by dennis_jeeves2 on Tuesday March 10, 2026 @07:12PM (#47329953)
>whats incredible to me are how many useful idiots out there STILL fall for it.

That's about 99% of the population.

Re:Online age-verification tools for child safety are survei... by Y_Y on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @10:11AM (#47335807)
But none of us here, right?
Re:Online age-verification tools for child safety are survei... by dennis_jeeves2 on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @10:20AM (#47335914)
We are special of course. Edit: Actually just me, I'm special
Re:Online age-verification tools for child safety are survei... by banannaise on Tuesday March 10, 2026 @05:28PM (#47329017)
The best way to protect children is to educate them to protect themselves, but that argument generally falls on deaf ears, doubly so when there's an opportunity to use "but the children" as a political cudgel.
Re:Online age-verification tools for child safety are survei... by jasonfarnon on Tuesday March 10, 2026 @11:21PM (#47331411)
sob stories about children were used even more vigorously promote gay rights. not to mention child labor laws, indoor smoking laws, welfare,... is that what you mean by 'weaponized for oppression'? or do you get to pick and choose which are valid uses of sob stories about children?
Re:Online age-verification tools for child safety are survei... by ej31 on Tuesday March 10, 2026 @09:36AM (#47323080)
Age verification doesn't stop determined bad actors, it just builds a database of everyone who cooperated...........
Re:Online age-verification tools for child safety are survei... by BLKNSLVR on Tuesday March 10, 2026 @09:39AM (#47323117)
Know they sheep, the better to keep them penned.
Re:Online age-verification tools for child safety are survei... by SV_BubbleTime on Tuesday March 10, 2026 @11:49AM (#47324886)
Now do Covid… tracking the non-compliant is surely the smaller task.
Re:Online age-verification tools for child safety are survei... by bilekas on Tuesday March 10, 2026 @09:41AM (#47323130)
Exactly my point.. And all the industry experts who they must have consulted in to write the laws are coincidently invested in personal data harvesting. Who could have foreseen this happening.
Re:Online age-verification tools for child safety are survei... by hedora on Tuesday March 10, 2026 @01:42PM (#47326452)
A much better approach would be to hold platforms responsible if they allow a stranger that does not have explicit parental consent to communicate with or get information about a minor.

This would block the most common classes of abuse on platforms like Roblox, Fortnight, Lego (kids) Fortnight, YouTube Kids, Minecraft, and "educational" social networks / games.

Note that it doesn't require any centralized surveillance at all. Parents just need to control the kids' ability to create random accounts, by (for example) turning on parental controls as they already exist on most tablets/phones, and blocking app installation / email applications (or other 2FA vectors).

When the parent allows an account to be created, they just tick the "kid mode" box. This even works with shared devices that don't support multiple accounts (so, iPads and iPhones).

Re:Online age-verification tools for child safety are survei... by nomel on Tuesday March 10, 2026 @06:54PM (#47329801)
> A predator simply needs not to verify anything and appear benign and ironically more anonymous than law abiding people.

Roblox takes the sane approach with this: communication features are completely disabled for "unverified" users.

Re:Online age-verification tools for child safety are survei... by voxic11 on Wednesday March 11, 2026 @12:45PM (#47337954)
Minecraft is going this direction as well, at least for UK based users.