Lots of models get really close on benchmarks, but benchmarks only tell us how good they are at solving a defined problem. Opus is far better at solving ill-defined ones.
Ah, the "trust me bro" advantage. Couldn't it just be brand identity and familiarity?
My dashboard goes from all green to 50/50 green/red for our agents whenever I switch from Claude to one of the cheaper agents... This is after investing a substantial amount of effort in "dumbing down" the prompts - e.g. adding a lot of extra wording to convince the dumber models to actually follow instructions - that is not necessary for Sonnet or Opus.
I buy the benchmarks. The problem is that a 10% difference in the benchmarks makes the difference between barely usable and something that can consistently deliver working code unilaterally and require few review interventions. Basically, the starting point for "usable" on these benchmarks is already very far up the scale for a lot of tasks.
I do strongly believe the moat is narrow - With 4.6 I switched from defaulting to Opus to defaulting to Sonnet for most tasks. I can fully see myself moving substantial workloads to a future iteration of Kimi, Qwen or Deepseek in 6-12 months once they actually start approaching Sonnet 4.5 level. But for my use at least, currently, they're at best competing with Athropics 3.x models in terms of real-world ability.
That said, even now, I think if we were stuck with current models for 12 months, we might well also be able to build our way around this and get to a point where Deepseek and Kimi would be cheaper than Sonnet.
Eventually we'll converge on good enough harnesses to get away with cheaper models for most uses, and the remaining appeal for the frontier models will be complex planning and actual hard work.
My default model has now dropped to Sonnet, because Sonnet can now do most of my tasks, and we already use Kimi, Deepseek, and Qwen.
They're just not cost-effective enough to be my main driver yet. They are however cheap enough that for things where the Claude TOS does not let me use my subscription, they still add substantial value. Just not nearly as much as I'd like.
The bulk of my tasks won't get harder as time passes, and so will move down the value chain as the cheaper models get better.
For the small proportion of my tasks that benefits from a smarter model, I will use the smartest model I can afford.
But of course this is also only viable for non-latency sensitive work, for starters.
OpenAI can sometimes get an edge over Anthropic in hard narrow STEM tasks. I trust benchmarks over vibes there - and the benchmarks show the teams trading blows release after release. Tracking Claude Code vs OpenAI Codex on SWE-bench Verified feels like watching the back alley knife fight of the AI frontier.
But the vibe of "how easy is that model to interact with" and "how easy it is to get it to do what you want it to" does matter a lot when you are the one doing the interacting. And Opus makes for a damn good daily driver.
GLM5, the largest Qwen 3.5 model, and Kimi K2.5 are more fair comparisons, though they are, yes, a bit behind. They're more than capable for routine operations though.
Anyways, I'm back to using Opus & Claude Code after a month on Codex/GPT5.3 and 5.4 and it's frankly a rather obvious downgrade. Anthropic is behind OpenAI at this point on coding models, and there's nothing to say they couldn't fall behind the Chinese models as well.
The moat is very shallow. After the events of the last two weeks there's likely a significant % of international capital very interested in breaching it. I know I would like to see this... Anthropic basically said F U to any non-Americans, and OpenAI is ... yeah.
Define "much worse".