Re:Teenagers report for duty as Croatia reinstates conscription
by pinkmuffinere on Monday March 09, 2026 @05:41PM
(#47315933)
Why does male only conscription imply no bodily autonomy for men?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Teenagers report for duty as Croatia reinstates conscription
by klipt on Monday March 09, 2026 @05:46PM
(#47315996)
The government forcing you to put your body in harm's way is the opposite of bodily autonomy.
Re:Teenagers report for duty as Croatia reinstates conscription
by pinkmuffinere on Monday March 09, 2026 @06:03PM
(#47316254)
I think I disagree with the claim that this implies _no_ bodily autonomy. People are often compelled to do certain things -- you can be forced to go to court cases/jury duty/jail, to get a vaccines (if you want to attend public school), to stay seated on a flight, etc. These are reductions in autonomy, but I don't think they are complete eliminations. Mandatory military service for n years is a reduction, but I don't think an elimination of bodily autonomy.
That said, I do prefer true equality before law, and if mandatory service is required, I'd prefer to have mandatory service for _everybody_, not just men.
Re:Teenagers report for duty as Croatia reinstates conscription
by asksomeoneelse on Monday March 09, 2026 @06:17PM
(#47316417)
There is a significant difference between jury duty and military service when it comes to risks and bodily harm. Equating the two as both being "reductions" is absurdly missing the point.
Re:Teenagers report for duty as Croatia reinstates conscription
by pinkmuffinere on Monday March 09, 2026 @06:21PM
(#47316485)
I'm not equating them. Military service is a much bigger reduction. But it doesn't seem fair to call it a complete elimination of bodily autonomy -- that's my main claim.
Re:Teenagers report for duty as Croatia reinstates conscription
by ranger_danger on Monday March 09, 2026 @05:58PM
(#47316185)
They're not forcing you, you can register as a conscientious objector.