In the short term, strict capitalism would say that a wealthy businessman makes better use of that tank of gasoline than someone who is desperately hoping to transport their family out of a flooded house to stay with relatives in another city. That social burden created by the loss the family man endures doesn't carry a dollar amount, so a system based strictly on capitalism can't recognize that it has become poorer than if the resource had been shared in some other fashion.
How much gas do you think someone needs to transport themselves to another city? Imagine gas prices doubled so that someone had to spend $120 instead of $60 to fill their tank. Are you really trying to tell me that $60 is all that separates a functioning society from 'ruin'?
During a shortage, the high prices don't last forever, they only last as long as the shortage persists. Arguing as if the high prices are an ongoing problem for the poor or the rich doesn't make sense. In any case, it would be much better for the government to give the poor person $60 to purchase the more expensive gas (or the ice, or the food, or whatever was most critical for that person) rather than artificially manipulate market prices.
Thoughtless adherence to an academic principal ruins societies.
it would be much better for the government to give the poor person $60 to purchase the more expensive gas
Why do you think that doubling the price will level supply and demand? It would take at least an order of magnitude, and the seller would have to conduct an auction in the presence of a representative sample of buyers in order to determine pricing. Also you're arguing for setting up an effective social program in the middle of an emergency. It's far more practical to suspend the free market for a week.
Unfettered capitalism in an emergency creates a divided, third world community of normal and desperate. If you want to argue anything, argue that.
There is a lot of evidence that other economic systems do ruin societies (communism, socialism, command economies, crony capitalism, etc) but generally capitalism is credited with being the most successful system for producing wealth and lifting people out of poverty.