News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The IDE Divide (2004) by iyulaev on Thursday November 01, 2012 @03:17PM (#4729201)
"I'd argue that auto-complete, one of the major IDE/editor features, is alone responsible for most of the boost I get from coding in an environment. Instantly, thousands of symbols can move out of my brain and into a list that appears as I type."

This is exactly what I had in mind reading this article. My experience with IDEs and languages has been that they are, for the developer, orthogonal to one another. Throughout school I never even touched an IDE - ended up writing a 100KLOC+ program (C compiler) with a text editor and debugging using print statements, no debugger or anything. It was a ball of mud but it worked great.

Where IDEs have really helped me is for larger scale projects, especially where I integrate lots of new-to-me 3rd party libraries. Being able to contextually explore the namespace of the libraries without sorting through all the documentation is a huge time-saver. Refactoring is also a plus; I don't end up using the refactoring tools that often but Eclipse's refactoring beats find-replace any day.

I guess what I'm trying to say is, languages help developers implement algorithms and data structures. These tend to be the 2-by-4s and screws of software development; a high-quality language is a straight, square, well-finished set of building materials that are sized & shaped for the structure you're building. IDEs help explore namespace and refactor, they're your drills and saws. Understandably the building materials can influence how easy it is to work on them with high-powered tools, but from a development perspective, they're complements, not substitutes.

Re:The IDE Divide (2004) by subb on Thursday November 01, 2012 @03:27PM (#4729244)
My feeling is similar as your, that is, I consider my IDE to be something that helps me understand and inspect my code. Language features, on the other hand, helps me write code.
Re:The IDE Divide (2004) by kevhsu on Thursday November 01, 2012 @04:17PM (#4729484)
no gcc in school?
Re:The IDE Divide (2004) by iyulaev on Thursday November 01, 2012 @04:24PM (#4729521)
No, we had gcc :-P but for a compilers class the goal is to write your own. Lots of people used gdb for debugging their assembly programs and probably at least half the people I know used Eclipse for development.
Re:The IDE Divide (2004) by eru on Thursday November 01, 2012 @05:18PM (#4729759)
Did you have to write your compiler in C? (I wonder, because OCaml or Haskell seem like much better choices. Or even Java, just for the GC.)
Re:The IDE Divide (2004) by iyulaev on Thursday November 01, 2012 @07:28PM (#4730352)
We wrote it in Java. We had some tools for the parsing (something like yacc for Java), we built a parser but it was in another class.