News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Would you use a job board where every listing is ... by antonymoose on Saturday March 07, 2026 @05:16PM (#47291985)
What makes a job verified in this case? You can easily verify a firm exists, but that’s not really the critical part. The question “is this a ghost job with no intention to be filled” is the real struggle.
Re:Ask HN: Would you use a job board where every listing is ... by BelVisgarra on Saturday March 07, 2026 @05:29PM (#47292087)
Good point. Verifying that a company exists is relatively easy, but confirming that the role is actually open and actively being hired for is definitely harder. I was thinking verification could include confirming the recruiter’s identity and requiring employers to periodically confirm that the position is still active. Ghost jobs are definitely an important challenge.
Re:Ask HN: Would you use a job board where every listing is ... by pavel_lishin on Saturday March 07, 2026 @05:51PM (#47292259)
> confirming the recruiter’s identity and requiring employers to periodically confirm that the position is still active.

If a position is only listed due to a requirement, and is already basically guaranteed to someone making an internal transfer, knowing the recruiter's identity and having a manager pinky-swear the job offer is real does nothing.

Re:Ask HN: Would you use a job board where every listing is ... by aeonfox on Saturday March 07, 2026 @06:40PM (#47292585)
Add a visible count of how many verified applicants got verified jobs at the verified business. Higher count increases confidence.
Re:Ask HN: Would you use a job board where every listing is ... by isbvhodnvemrwvn on Sunday March 08, 2026 @04:46AM (#47295686)
Unless you recruit mainly via this new job board I can hardly see why employers would go for it, it would just show a very small percentage because you fill most openings via LinkedIn or whatever, damaging the company branding.
Re:Ask HN: Would you use a job board where every listing is ... by aeonfox on Sunday March 08, 2026 @07:29AM (#47296489)
I never said percentage.

"<small_boutique_company> has filled 8 verified positions on <product_name>"

Re:Ask HN: Would you use a job board where every listing is ... by 306bobby on Sunday March 08, 2026 @04:03PM (#47300814)
Not a bad idea. Has the added benefit of giving a signal if the position/company has a turnover issue
Re:Ask HN: Would you use a job board where every listing is ... by BelVisgarra on Saturday March 07, 2026 @06:27PM (#47292498)
That definitely makes things harder. Roles posted for internal transfers or compliance reasons are tricky because they may never have been intended for external candidates. Maybe verification would need signals showing that the role is actually open to external applicants. I wonder if something like an “externally open role” label would help.
Re:Ask HN: Would you use a job board where every listing is ... by didgetmaster on Saturday March 07, 2026 @07:45PM (#47293128)
If I knew that a company had paid a refundable fee (e.g $1000), that was only paid back if the job was filled by someone outside the company within 6 months; then I would take it much more seriously.
Re:Ask HN: Would you use a job board where every listing is ... by AnimalMuppet on Saturday March 07, 2026 @07:55PM (#47293184)
I like it. Now, what are you going to do to employees? How do they verify (to the board and/or the employer) that they're who they say they are, and are serious about looking?

I like this for employers. Money talks and baloney walks; if you're serious, prove it. But that could come down badly on desperate employees - Either take a job that you decide you don't like, or lose a significant amount of money. And yet, the "not seriously looking" issue is on both sides.

And even for employers, you have to gate this. Something like, they get the $1000 back if, after six months, the board has not supplied them with N qualified candidates. (Which gets back to the employee issue: How do you prove they're qualified?)

I like the idea in general. Really, I do. But I'm not sure it solves the whole problem. (And maybe it doesn't need to in order to be a good step forward.)

For amusement value, consider the following wrinkle: If a company forfeits the $1000, the board keeps $200. The other $800 gets split among the candidates whose time the company wasted.

Re:Ask HN: Would you use a job board where every listing is ... by ipnon on Saturday March 07, 2026 @08:31PM (#47293393)
Put some money on the line. I'm not an economist but you could structure a market where you cannot just take up mental space in the job market for practically nil. That's the current malincentive, that companies put up job listings they have no intention of filling, even when candidates who are qualified by their own criteria apply. The current job market maladies are a perverse incentive of the price of posting a job and applying for a job are effectively nil, the spread is too big for anyone to make the trade.
Re:Ask HN: Would you use a job board where every listing is ... by sqircles on Saturday March 07, 2026 @09:08PM (#47293623)
Interesting proposal, but I think it would take a good size of money. Maybe 50% escrow of first year salary?
Re:Ask HN: Would you use a job board where every listing is ... by ipnon on Saturday March 07, 2026 @10:57PM (#47294275)
Yeah something like that. A breakup fee between the job board company and the hiring company: “if you don’t hire someone within 90 days we keep half of the salary.” But there’s not much incentive for the hiring side to do this!
Re:Ask HN: Would you use a job board where every listing is ... by neya on Saturday March 07, 2026 @09:28PM (#47293751)
On top of this, you also cannot verify if the position was filled through another job board. The company/HR might say "we filled it through a different portal" and in most portals, expired listings don't show up and there is no way to verify if they actually did hire someone from there.