Re:The Brand Age
by ChadNauseam on Thursday March 05, 2026 @04:21PM
(#47267457)
They may be beautiful, but the fact remains if you could produce and sell Patek Philippe Nautilus for $200 no one would be interested in it. The same is not true for most other beautiful objects
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Well firstly, they don't charge $200 for them because they can't produce them for $200. But the point I'm making is he seems to be trying to say they aren't beautiful. He says he's describing this "dark" world or "strange" watches. I do actually think he probably thinks the watches look strange. I don't think he thinks they're beautiful, maybe he'll find a brand to fall in love with one day. I doubt it because he seems to have too much of himself invested in this. But the people buying them don't think they're strange, they think they're beautiful. I don't go out telling everyone that they shouldn't buy a Ferrari because my Honda Civic can do the same job.
Re:The Brand Age
by munificent on Thursday March 05, 2026 @06:25PM
(#47268642)
> But the people buying them don't think they're strange, they think they're beautiful.
Can you reflect on why they think those designs are more beautiful than others?
I think you are missing his point - the items are desireable because of the brand. The stories, the movie stars, the songs and so on.
They don’t possess a universal, objectively valuable beauty that motivates the desire. If they did, fakes would be equally desireable and they are not.
I have a set of very expensive hand made japanese irons (golf clubs). I assure you I did not buy them from social influence or clout. In fact, nobody ever really sees them except me. I bought them because the craftsmanship and how truly beautiful they are. They make me smile.
Re:The Brand Age
by ChadNauseam on Thursday March 05, 2026 @07:18PM
(#47269080)
No one is saying that beautiful things don't exist. Just that watches specifically are rarely worth $100k because of their beauty.
You're confusing the price of something with how much it costs to make it. Prices are just a made up number. Hopefully, the amount someone will pay you for the watch you made is more than it costs you to make it, and you have a sustainable business, but the funny thing about capitalism is that is not at all guaranteed. If the company wants to juice sales, they'll have a limited time discount. Or how about when the company is bankrupt and out of business? Then theres a fire sale and the price of something is pennies on the dollar. So they could sell the watches for $200, or they could give them away for free, or they can charge $100k, or they could barter for them. It's all a matter of business.
Re:The Brand Age
by conception on Thursday March 05, 2026 @07:38PM
(#47269251)
So you’re saying that $200 watches don’t sell?
But here - https://spechtandsohne.com/product-category/icon-quartz/
And they are pretty popular with folks who like watches.
Re:The Brand Age
by KolmogorovComp on Friday March 06, 2026 @07:06AM
(#47273967)
They’re only popular because they appeal to the real luxury product, like counterfeit Rolexes.