News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Someone needs to go to jail by Animats on Tuesday March 03, 2026 @02:26PM (#47237539)
It begins to look like Citizens United [1] cost us democracy.

"That government of the rich, by the rich, and for the rich shall not perish from the earth."

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizens_United_v._FEC

Re:Someone needs to go to jail by deathanatos on Tuesday March 03, 2026 @03:09PM (#47238216)
I know people hate Citizens United, but to me, if the debate on this is ever to progress: what's the alternative? Say I and a bunch of my friends donate money to promote some cause; let's say "Black Lives Matter", for the sake of argument. Is that also off the table? Is there to be no ability for people to associate & collectively argue for change (e.g., by buying an ad to raise awareness)?

Or, is it fine when I do it, but not when others do it? Where do I draw the line, between what association for the purposes of political advocacy is fine, and what association isn't fine?

Re:Someone needs to go to jail by throwaway87543 on Tuesday March 03, 2026 @04:12PM (#47239073)
Campaign finance laws were set up tell you where the line is. There needs to be a line because the amount of reach you have should not grow with your wealth. But Citizens United made the money as speech an unlimited right. Spending $250 is a completely different category than spending $250 million.
Re:Someone needs to go to jail by judahmeek on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @11:24AM (#47249817)
But where's the line between political contribution & opinionated news article about a political candidate?
Re:Someone needs to go to jail by tartuffe78 on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @01:38PM (#47251863)
Having unlimited funds to make sure everyone sees your opinion.
Re:Someone needs to go to jail by judahmeek on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @03:11PM (#47253131)
In the age of LLMs, separating money from speech on the internet (where the most desired sociodemographics live) is literally impossible.

You restrict ads, they just create more bots or even pay actual people to express certain opinions.

Re:Someone needs to go to jail by snovv_crash on Tuesday March 03, 2026 @04:02PM (#47238943)
As an individual you can. Not as a corporation.
Re:Someone needs to go to jail by deathanatos on Tuesday March 03, 2026 @06:45PM (#47240824)
Again, I'm asking about generalized freedom of association. I get the hate for corporations, I do, but if you ban freedom of people to associate, and through that association, to pool money for a common cause: are you just straight up good with that?

The underlying law in Citizen's United didn't just target corporations: it targeted unions, it targeted non-profits. That's why I'm asking about those other cases that would be banned. I understand wanting to ban Evil Inc., but are you ready to ban World Peace Non-Profit, too? Not only that, but Citizens United itself wasn't a corporation.

If you have a defensible case, that, yes, that'd be fine, go ahead. But when only individuals can spend money on politics, are we not in the same situation, where Bezos or Musk can afford an ad, but I cannot?

Re:Someone needs to go to jail by mingus88 on Tuesday March 03, 2026 @07:00PM (#47241005)
Convince me that the solution is not to remove money from the process entirely.

I’m just spitballing here but why don’t we have a system where every candidate gets the same allocation of money for ads and it is outlawed to use your own fortune to bankroll your candidacy

In a world where social media companies are all run by billionaires, let them pollute the feeds with their candidate of choice. This only speedruns the complete collapse of SM in an era where we can no longer distinguish real discourse from AI

And good riddance.

Re:Someone needs to go to jail by bobomonkey on Tuesday March 03, 2026 @08:46PM (#47241933)
Workaround: I'm rich and would just start up a newspaper that gave my candidates good coverage.

In my opinion, this isn't a easy problem if you value freedom of speech, freedom of association, and freedom of people to spend their own money.

Re:Someone needs to go to jail by jmye on Tuesday March 03, 2026 @11:10PM (#47242957)
> Workaround: I'm rich and would just start up a newspaper that gave my candidates good coverage.

Or buy Twitter.

Re:Someone needs to go to jail by Tadpole9181 on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @09:35AM (#47247971)
And fix: a functioning government would make a law that outlaws such flagrant abuse of a media company.

What, if making murder illegal was hard would you just throw your hands and give up and make murder legal? Why is it that suddenly, when it's about corporations to do whatever they want - including destroy democracy itself - we're little babies who can't possibly lift a single finger to stop it?

But that guy who sold an eighth? Implement the full extent of mass surveillance and send a tactical SWAT team to the wrong house to arrest him for 40 years!

Re:Someone needs to go to jail by actionfromafar on Tuesday March 03, 2026 @03:52PM (#47238801)
Is this "Black Lives Matter" running for President?
Re:Someone needs to go to jail by deathanatos on Tuesday March 03, 2026 @06:56PM (#47240962)
Is this "Citizens United" running for President?

Obviously neither is running for president. But collective groups of people may wish to support certain causes, bills, or even candidates who support such things. Do I prevent all collectives of people — and since everyone's favorite punching bag is the evil corporation — including non-profits and unions (which is what the original case was about!) — from spending money?

And I'll distill this down to what I said to the other commenter: assume we do, and no political money from anyone except individuals. Is it not just Bezos and Musk who can afford the ad, whereas I'm left without a voice?

Re:Someone needs to go to jail by actionfromafar on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @09:34AM (#47247947)
Citizens United has tax ID 91-1433368 and is a 501(c)(4) in Washington, D.C.

Where is "Black Lives Matter" headquartered?

Re:Someone needs to go to jail by pickleglitch on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @02:30PM (#47252590)
It's in the same building as antifa headquarters, duh.
Re:Someone needs to go to jail by UncleMeat on Wednesday March 04, 2026 @12:09PM (#47250597)
The alternative was what we had between McCain-Feingold and Citizens United, which was not a hellscape of limitations on collective action.

This isn't some hypothetical world. We had it.