News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Introducing the new compose in Gmail by andrewljohnson on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @03:52PM (#4719162)
Ugh, why would anyone up-vote this comment? Some how this is the top comment, even though it doesn't address the content of the article. This happens all the time on HN and I find it very annoying.

It's not just that I don't want to scroll past this comment. These meta-comments may seem harmless, but when this is the top comment, it stifles the entire discussion about the article. Instead of people discussing the merits of the new GMail UI, there is an endless chain of replies burying all the topical comments.

I've said it before - I'd like to see a community guideline advising people not to make comments like this. These comments end up being easy ways to score points, entertaining for the people involved in the criticism, but harmful for the topical discussion. If it's a "Show HN" post about a hacker's new project, it seems topical to criticize the technology, but when it's a blog post, it seems so lame to criticize the blog software.

This kind of complaint belongs in its own thread - it should be a blogpost or something. The comment doesn't even apply to me - the page works perfectly and crisply for me.

Re:Introducing the new compose in Gmail by guelo on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @04:34PM (#4719400)
I found your meta-meta comment more useless, better to just let it be. OTOH this meta-meta-meta comment is fantastic, especially this sentence.
Re:Introducing the new compose in Gmail by TeMPOraL on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @06:01PM (#4719924)
> These meta-comments may seem harmless, but when this is the top comment, it stifles the entire discussion about the article.

And for others this is one of the main values of HN. Usually the discussions here are much better / insightful than original articles, and quite often those interesting discussions are tangential to the article itself. Let the community decide what to discuss about, in terms of topic (and the community do decide, by the means of an upvote).

Re:Introducing the new compose in Gmail by GHFigs on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @07:45PM (#4720359)
it doesn't address the content of the article

I wholeheartedly disagree. The singing and dancing crap that people surround their text and images with is content. It's just crap content. Think about it the other way: if it's not content, why is it even there? Why does a blog need a loading screen?

Re:Introducing the new compose in Gmail by MaysonL on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @05:49PM (#4719861)
I never did read the article because of the same features that the comment you're complaining about complains about. The format of the google blog seriously sucks.

EDIT: I just realized: the Readability bookmarklet manages to hide all the cruft, and make the post readable. Amazing.

Re:Introducing the new compose in Gmail by afterburner on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @04:57PM (#4719568)
He's getting upvoted because it had to be said... finally.
Re:Introducing the new compose in Gmail by Kylekramer on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @06:57PM (#4720160)
Yeah! After all, it isn't like this comes up every (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4070192) single (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3767025) time (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4196833) a official Google blogpost is submitted or even is brought up.
Re:Introducing the new compose in Gmail by te_chris on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @04:01PM (#4719212)
I'm finding HN harder and harder to deal with without comment upvote counts to provide perspective as a filtering mechanism. I find that regulars and comments like this always tend to get upvoted, even when they're normally far from the most insightful comments posted.
Re:Introducing the new compose in Gmail by ablefire on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @08:49PM (#4720567)
It would be helpful to have some way to collapse a comment thread that we are not interested in.
Re:Introducing the new compose in Gmail by tharris0101 on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @04:23PM (#4719333)
Normally I'd agree but I came in here to post this same thing as the page is almost unreadable for me in Chrome.
Re:Introducing the new compose in Gmail by jaydz on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @04:13PM (#4719271)
Agreed, these ux complaints are getting annoying.
Re:Introducing the new compose in Gmail by MaysonL on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @05:50PM (#4719866)
So, of course, are these horrible ux's.