News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Banned in California by richwater on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @06:51PM (#47159790)
> has an agenda

Everyone has an agenda. Is anything on this site false? Is it incorrect information?

Re:Banned in California by burkaman on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @07:01PM (#47159897)
Really difficult to say because it doesn't make many concrete claims. It doesn't mention any regulations or say what chemicals or processes are actually banned. These are not easy things to look up. I can tell you that at least the semiconductor fabrication stuff is false, there are many fabs in California and here's a new one as of a few days ago: https://www.mercurynews.com/2026/02/19/san-jose-tech-nokia-i....

I realize it isn't completed yet but I don't think anyone is buying sites for something that's impossible to build.

Here's another one: https://www.bosch-semiconductors.com/roseville/

Re:Banned in California by creddit on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @07:39PM (#47160235)
I can tell you that your two articles that intended to refute the semiconductor fabrication stuff fail to do so. Both sites were existing facilities and would therefore fall under the granfathered in point in the site.
Re:Banned in California by burkaman on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @08:49PM (#47160768)
That's true they are not new buildings. Here's one that is: https://www.appliedmaterials.com/us/en/semiconductor/epic-pl...

The Infinera one is described as a "new fab" though (https://www.nist.gov/chips/infinera-california-san-jose) and the Bosch one is adding a new type of fabrication to an existing site. If you can do all that without getting new permits then that makes California sound like a pretty lenient place to do business. I'm assuming they did have to get new permits though.

Re:Banned in California by creddit on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @10:25PM (#47161431)
> Here's one that is: https://www.appliedmaterials.com/us/en/semiconductor/epic-pl...

This might be a refutation but it's not super clear. It's definitely not a commercial semiconductor fab but it might do all of or some subset of what a commercial fab does at R&D scale. Hard to know for sure how this jives with the claim in the main website.

> If you can do all that without getting new permits then that makes California sound like a pretty lenient place to do business.

Being able to retool under original zoning/permitting is specifically lenient? That's extremely basic. If you're a co-Californian with me, though, it does help to understand that many people think that anyone doing anything without a permit is "lenient".

> I'm assuming they did have to get new permits though.

Well, that makes it really easy to be "right". I should try this more.

Re:Banned in California by saghm on Thursday February 26, 2026 @09:25AM (#47166533)
> This might be a refutation but it's not super clear.

As others have pointed out, the article itself fails to provide any direct citations of the regulations either. This is classic Russell's teapot territory; the one making the initial claim shouldn't have a lower burden of evidence than the one refuting it.

Re:Banned in California by no-dr-onboard on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @07:01PM (#47159907)
Maybe reworded as “He has skin in the game”

> so obviously his point can’t be true > so obviously he’s biased and we can’t do the mental work of sifting > so obviously I can dismiss this as teleologically false.

Please don’t be so lazy you guys. There is something to be gained here.

Re:Banned in California by autoexec on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @07:15PM (#47160045)
> so obviously he’s biased and we can’t do the mental work of sifting

This guy, with an obvious bias, created a website that misrepresents the situation in California (by implying things are banned or "nearly impossible" when in actuality they just take time/effort), while also failing to show the specific regulations or requirements for any of it. Without supplying that kind of information this website is little better than "It's banned. trust me bro". It's not our responsibility to try to dig up evidence to support or verify this guys claims just because he can't be bothered to do it.

His motivations, his framing of the problem, and his failure to back up his own statements makes the site pretty damn easy to dismiss and I don't even doubt that there might be instances where bad regulation exists, especially regulation that protects the profits of established players in certain industries by keeping out competition. I'm entirely sympathetic to the idea that it might be happening, but if there is something to be gained you aren't going to find it on this guys website. Serious coverage on this topic would include actionable information we can use to identify and solve specific problems. This is just anti-regulation propaganda.

Re:Banned in California by Brian_K_White on Thursday February 26, 2026 @12:30PM (#47169164)
The lack of citations makes it not just easy to dismiss but an obligation to dismiss.

Your downvotes are invalid.

Re:Banned in California by no-dr-onboard on Thursday February 26, 2026 @09:15PM (#47175501)
Your argument makes sense to me and changed my mind. Thank you.
Re:Banned in California by vampirical on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @08:55PM (#47160800)
Why do you think there's something to be gained here? There are a lot of cheap and easy checks this content fails that it represents a well formed argument based on reality.
Re:Banned in California by kortilla on Thursday February 26, 2026 @07:13AM (#47165028)
Post these “checks” that failed. Don’t hide behind some bullshit about the author being motivated
Re:Banned in California by Brian_K_White on Thursday February 26, 2026 @12:26PM (#47169123)
There is no rational basis for anyone else to expend any effort refuting anything when the author has not said anything in the first place.

The article contains no citations, and so may be presumed 100% false by default.

"may be presumed", as in, sure it might actually contain some other mix of true and false, but it doesn't matter what that mix actually is. That only matters in some other article written by someone else that citates any of it's assertions.

This piece is the same as if monkeys typed stuff at random and some of it could possibly happen to be the same as something true. It doesn't mean the monkeys made a valid point, and no one should spend one second either defending or refuting it.

Re:Banned in California by thephyber on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @06:54PM (#47159820)
Lies can be either by commission or omission.
Re:Banned in California by teaearlgraycold on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @06:57PM (#47159847)
I don't think it makes a good case for itself. No automotive paint shops sounds kind of ridiculous. I don't know anything about that industry but there has to be a way to paint cars in a safe way, right??

But lumping that in with semiconductor fabs, which are extremely toxic, makes me wonder how many of these banned industries I don't want in my state. I think if we want to build them in the US maybe don't build them in the most agriculturally productive and highest population state. Or first figure out how to do it without turning the US into China with its "cancer villages" from poisoned river water.

I'm not defending the dysfunctional CA bureaucracy, but the site should probably focus on specific cases of government-produced insanity than a general complaint that certain industries are banned from operation.

Re:Banned in California by MikeTheGreat on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @07:14PM (#47160038)
> No automotive paint shops

Wait, hold on - I watched all the seasons of "Rust To Riches" on Netflix, about a small shop that flips cars.

They routinely painted cars.

They'd paint in this sealed-up room/garage thingee, the guy would wear and industrial-grade mask, and the camera would slide past as he expertly painted the car. The 30 second montages looked awesome!

That show took place in Temecula, California. So there's no way that site is accurate.

And, more to the point, if they want to show that they are accurate they should be linking to the rules & regulations that actually prohibit these things instead of just making a claim & calling it a day.

Re:Banned in California by creddit on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @07:41PM (#47160251)
The website is extremely clear about this being about _new_ automotive paint shops, so nothing you said here refutes the website.
Re:Banned in California by avs733 on Thursday February 26, 2026 @08:41PM (#47175216)
He doesn’t need to refute it he just needs to offer an alternate claim.

The site provides no citations, no evidence, so there’s no need to defend the count argument or honestly even make it.

The sit isn’t just false, it is flat out disrespectful to all the workers, engineers, founders, and everyone else involved in the industries he says don’t exist that actually do exist. The site is basically “I think this is hard so no one else could possibly do it”.

Re:Banned in California by cucumber3732842 on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @08:29PM (#47160647)
They're likely falling under some "we aren't selling car painting as a service or main part of our business, we're painting our own cars as a small ancillary part of our real business" exemption.
Re:Banned in California by mothballed on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @08:36PM (#47160680)
Sounds like the "llantera" model you see out west. There's about 10x the number of them that would actually be needed just to change tires.
Re:Banned in California by chipsa on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @11:52PM (#47162017)
It’s not claiming: you can’t have an automotive paint shop. It’s claiming you can’t start a new paint shop. Specifically, if you don’t have one for your car manufacturing line already, you can’t set one up. Wikipedia shows 13 pages for auto plants in CA. Most of them have the verb “was” in the opening sentence. There are two current plants: Tesla Fremont and Toyota California. Both of these plants are over 50 years old, and only one of them produces actual cars instead of parts.
Re:Banned in California by inigyou on Thursday February 26, 2026 @06:50AM (#47164830)
It's claiming you can't get a permit to release VOCs into the air, but the GP comment describes a setup that apparently is designed to paint cars while preventing VOCs getting released into the air, so that you can still paint cars in California.
Re:Banned in California by nayroclade on Thursday February 26, 2026 @08:32AM (#47165838)
Firstly, an auto paint shop is not the same as an auto manufacturing plant.

Secondly, it says you can't permit a new auto paint shop in CA, but it specifically mentions the Bay Area AQMD as the reason. But, as its name implies, the Bay Area AQMD only regulates within the San Francisco Bay Area. It is only one of 35 air districts in California: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_California_air_distric...

So, it is impossible to permit a new auto paint shop in all of these districts, or just the bay area? Because those are very different. It also labels starting a new paint shop as "impossible", but then says it's "nearly impossible". So is it actually impossible, or just nearly impossible?

Re:Banned in California by ashdksnndck on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @07:22PM (#47160108)
I assume you use semiconductors yourself, since you are posting here. But you want their manufacture to be banned in your state.

So the right thing is to outsource the dirty jobs to countries that can’t afford to be picky?

Wouldn’t it be better for the world if we used our wealth to develop methods of safe semiconductor manufacturing with low environmental impact, and proudly built those facilities in California?

Re:Banned in California by WD-42 on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @07:27PM (#47160146)
Well that's the whole problem isn't it?

It's not like the laws are simply "you can't make semiconductors here". The laws ban the harmful externalities of the process. The companies that want to make semiconductors don't want to find a way to make the processes less harmful: it's cheaper and easier to just go somewhere where they can pollute instead.

Re:Banned in California by ashdksnndck on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @08:11PM (#47160490)
In many cases, California’s environmental regulations don’t make an earnest attempt to permit safe ways to do things.
Re:Banned in California by WD-42 on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @08:15PM (#47160529)
And in all cases, those industries make no earnest attempt to develop safe ways to do things instead of simply doing it where it doesn't matter.
Re:Banned in California by CamperBob2 on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @10:04PM (#47161288)
[Citation needed]
Re:Banned in California by saghm on Thursday February 26, 2026 @09:21AM (#47166483)
A sibling comment a few levels up provided it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47160514
Re:Banned in California by CamperBob2 on Thursday February 26, 2026 @10:16AM (#47167194)
Got anything from the last 50 years?

There's a large middle ground between "Build absolutely nothing anywhere near anyone" and letting blatant polluters turn your neighborhood into a Superfund site. California solved the latter problem by going too far in the other direction.

Re:Banned in California by saghm on Friday February 27, 2026 @07:54AM (#47179972)
You're asking for an example of an environmental disaster of the type the regulation is intended to prevent that happened since the regulation came into effect, with the implication that there aren't any is evidence that the regulation is bad? I'd argue there's no way to differentiate between perfectly calibrated regulation and regulation that's too onerous by the metric you're giving, so your conclusion isn't supported without more evidence.
Re:Banned in California by _DeadFred_ on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @08:14PM (#47160514)
When an industry leaves this many superfund sites in an area, that industry can expect some regulatory blowback from that area.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Superfund_sites_in_Cal...

https://www.epa.gov/superfund/search-superfund-sites-where-y...

Re:Banned in California by amluto on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @07:15PM (#47160047)
I would imagine a paint booth with negative pressure and particle and carbon filters on the exhaust would work fine.

I go by a paint shop every now and then. It’s not nearly as smelly as a quite of a few of the nearby restaurants.

Re:Banned in California by ixtli on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @07:00PM (#47159890)
It actually makes me wanna move to CA.
Re:Banned in California by bsder on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @07:43PM (#47160266)
> I don't know anything about that industry but there has to be a way to paint cars in a safe way, right??

There are. They just cost more and take more time.

> But lumping that in with semiconductor fabs, which are extremely toxic

People say this all the time, but semiconductor fabs simply aren't very toxic compared to just about every other industrial manufacturing process. Mostly this is because everything is sealed and sealed and sealed some more.

Yes, they handle stuff like arsenic gas (arsine AsH3), but they really try to reclaim it all. The semiconductor waste stream is often purer than most industrial inputs. Yeah, old plants would just dump crap into the environment. However, for modern semiconductor facilities, it is generally more economic to reprocess your waste than try to purify from primary sources.

Now, PCB manufacturing, on the other hand, is quite terrible or at least it used to be. I don't know if people have sealed and automated that yet.

Re:Banned in California by chrismcb on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @09:09PM (#47160902)
California, by density, is that highly populated. I didn't really like the idea is "hey we need to build something that uses a toxic process, by just don't build it here. Build it somewhere else." Unless that somewhere else is in outer space.
Re:Banned in California by zdp7 on Wednesday February 25, 2026 @09:15PM (#47160953)
I don't know. He didn't provide anything to backup his claims. Without data that site is worthless.
Re:Banned in California by SecretDreams on Thursday February 26, 2026 @07:19AM (#47165075)
Yes. They lump in sheet metal stamping with giga casting. They are completely different techs with different energy footprints. Banning aluminum casting does not implicitly ban stamping.
Re:Banned in California by matthewmacleod on Thursday February 26, 2026 @07:23AM (#47165100)
It isn't even information – it's noise.

I'm actually quite surprised by the number of people who have fallen for this. There aren't even any concrete claims here – just the vague assertion that some things are "impossible".

Re:Banned in California by jwagenet on Thursday February 26, 2026 @07:52AM (#47165399)
> Aluminum Anodizing & CNC Machining

There are a ton of CNC machining (AL and otherwise) and anodizing shops in the Bay Area.