News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Software Chief Refused to Sign Maps Apology by SHOwnsYou on Monday October 29, 2012 @11:44PM (#4715921)
I hope I'm reading the situation incorrectly, but all I get out of this is that Forstall has an epic ego.

He is asked to sign an apology letter for the short comings of an app that he was in charge of and was at least confident enough in to present to the world. When it was time to pay the piper and accept responsibility for the app he told the world was great, he shirks all responsibility.

I fully support the decision to remove him from his position.

Re:Apple Software Chief Refused to Sign Maps Apology by Volpe on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @12:30AM (#4716071)
Well sure if you believe that's how it happened.

Or, he was against releasing, but was overridden (by Cook perhaps), then refused to apologise because it wasn't his mistake...

The reality is, we don't, and probably won't know. Seems strange though, that Forestall did exceptionally good releases [1] up until iOS 6 and then all of a sudden he just dropped the ball with maps...

[1] Excluding the fact that new iOSes generally suck for older iPhones, and force a hardware upgrade.

Re:Apple Software Chief Refused to Sign Maps Apology by droithomme on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @01:33AM (#4716253)
iOS is behind Apple's present riches and Forstall is the hard ass visionary genius that made that happen. Before that, he was a primary architect on OS X before it was even called OS X. He's the single most important engineer at Apple (since Bertrand Serlet was tossed out last year). To pooh pooh this guy's contributions as many are doing, while celebrating Cook as some great visionary genius is totally absurd.

Cook is a bean counter with no vision. He is very good at bean counting and has a lot of success at it. He is not appropriate as anything more than transitionary CEO for a visionary company.

Replace visionaries with bean counters that have allegiance to the established hierarchical order of bean counters? This works well for commodity companies that sell fizzy sugar water. Will it work for Apple this time around? Last time they went this route with Sculley there were some problems.

Re:Apple Software Chief Refused to Sign Maps Apology by shinratdr on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @04:36PM (#4719416)
> This works well for commodity companies that sell fizzy sugar water.

Why can't you just say soda, pop or whatever regional dialect you prefer? I don't understand why any time anyone ever says this it has to phrased in the most condescending way possible.

Re:Apple Software Chief Refused to Sign Maps Apology by droithomme on Wednesday October 31, 2012 @02:40PM (#4724402)
Because it's highly relevant to the story I was discussing. Jobs had asked Sculley, head of PepsiCo at the time, Do you want to sell sugared water for the rest of your life? Or do you want to come with me and change the world?" Sculley then ran Apple from the perspective if his experience at a commodity company, driving the company to the edge of bankruptcy and irrelevance. It worked out well for me, I bought a lot of Apple stock at around $5 a share. But it almost destroyed Apple.

This quote has since been simplified to asking people in technical fields if they want to make fizzy sugar water. Familiarity with this story is widespread in the industry and not an obscure reference, and in this case I wanted to discuss both Jobs, Sculley, Apple, and the result of having a bean counter type person who is excellent at reducing manufacturing costs within a commodity company be in charge of a company whose entire value is based on not being a commodity.

Re:Apple Software Chief Refused to Sign Maps Apology by Volpe on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @10:27PM (#4720847)
Because steve jobs said it that way... and we all love worshipping jobs.
Re:Apple Software Chief Refused to Sign Maps Apology by lostlogin on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @05:37AM (#4716714)
There wouldn't be too many people who would be confident they could pick winner better than Jobs.
Re:Apple Software Chief Refused to Sign Maps Apology by enraged_camel on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @10:22AM (#4717421)
Cooks is no Sculley. The latter was very ineffective as CEO and made huge mistakes such as porting Apple's OS to the PowerPC platform. As such, he was ousted by the board. Cooks is far more capable, and has the advantage of being "home-grown" as opposed to coming from another company.
Re:Apple Software Chief Refused to Sign Maps Apology by mikeash on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @10:06AM (#4717360)
Do you have any info about just what Forstall did on OS X back in the day? I can't find much beyond some pretty vague statements, and I don't recall hearing his name at all until iOS started getting attention, while names like Tevanian showed up quite a lot back when Mac OS X was first taking shape.
Re:Apple Software Chief Refused to Sign Maps Apology by SHOwnsYou on Tuesday October 30, 2012 @12:56AM (#4716137)
How it actually happened doesn't matter.

If you've accepted the role of svp of IOS software, you're at fault if there is horribly broken IOS software.