Re:North Carolina teacher's resignation letter
by zellyn on Monday October 29, 2012 @01:27PM
(#4713361)
If you look at the "I have a dream speech" you'll see a similar form of repetition. Not that this letter is comparable. But it is a useful construct.
Re:North Carolina teacher's resignation letter
by MartinCron on Monday October 29, 2012 @01:41PM
(#4713459)
Is that how he teaches his students to write as well?
If those students can write something this straightforward, impassioned, and moving, they'll be better writers than most high school graduates.
Re:North Carolina teacher's resignation letter
by abduhl on Monday October 29, 2012 @01:26PM
(#4713349)
It seemed to me that he was doing this on purpose as a stylistic choice to convey his frustrations with the system.
Also, it sounds like he teaches math.
Re:North Carolina teacher's resignation letter
by phil on Monday October 29, 2012 @01:47PM
(#4713502)
You might find the parallel structure listing grievances familiar, since it was used in the Declaration of Independence (and many, many times since).
Re:North Carolina teacher's resignation letter
by w1nterl0ng on Monday October 29, 2012 @01:52PM
(#4713533)
@Hammock, I would argue that the second half of that document was intended to be Parallelism as a Rhetorical Device. In terms of grammar, that may be how he teaches (at least for a class or two).
I...
I...
I...
I...
I...
I...
Is that how he teaches his students to write as well?
edit: Hi downvoters, I understand parallelism. When it's used the way this teacher has used it, he risks coming across as whiny and juvenile. His point would come across more powerfully if he reframed his grievances in a way that shows their impact on the real victims, the children, as opposed to himself.
"I have a dream" came from a place of hope and opportunity. King was laying out a roadmap for what progress would look like. Similarly, the Declaration of Independence was not a list of self-referential, logorrheic splatter. It contained specific, directed complaints combined with a plan of action.
This man merely said I hate the world in a selfishly-worded cry for attention, threw up his hands and gave up. We do not say the same of King or the Founding Fathers.